GHGPSE-Net: A method towards spaceborne automated extraction of greenhouse-gas point sources using point-object-detection deep neural network
Abstract. Point sources account for a large portion of anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Timely detection, localization, and quantification of these emissions are critical for supporting carbon neutrality efforts. Spaceborne monitoring satellites can provide essential concentration data for identifying point sources. However, existing methods often require human intervention and typically detect plume masks instead of source locations, limiting their utility for regulatory applications. In this study, we present GHGPSE-Net, a deep learning method for greenhouse gas point source extraction. GHGPSE-Net simultaneously performs detection, localization, and quantification of emissions, eliminating the need for traditional segmentation steps. To train and evaluate the model, we construct synthetic datasets using an atmospheric transport model and validate its accuracy against radiosonde profiles and satellite observations. GHGPSE-Net demonstrates desirable performance in the simulation data across detection (F1-score of 0.96), subpixel-level localization and quantification (Pearson's correlation of 0.99, root mean square error of 89.9 tCO2 hr-1), tested on ideal instrument of 2 km × 2 km resolution with retrieval noise of 1.5 parts per million (ppm). The results also demonstrate considerable generalization of the proposed model when tested using two independent datasets. On the identified sources from OCO-3 spaceborne observations, GHGPSE-Net achieves a detection precision of 0.60, localization accuracy of 2.47 km, and a Pearson's R of 0.89 for quantification. The proposed method and datasets provide a valuable foundation for future research towards rapid and automated GHG point source extraction, offering critical data to support swift responses to abnormal emission events.
The manuscript "GHGPSE-Net: A method towards spaceborne automated extraction of greenhouse-gas point sources using point-object-detection deep neural network" presents a novel deep learning framework and a large dataset for detecting and quantifying greenhouse gas (GHG) point sources from satellite imagery. The authors are the first to introduce the point object detection approach in this domain, which is very valuable and insightful for the GHG point source monitoring community, as it has the potential to integrate and simplify the processing complexity largely. The authors also demonstrate the feasibility of the model by evaluating it on two datasets, including authentic satellite observations. Though I anticipate more evaluations may be required on the upcoming moderate-resolution carbon monitoring satellites (e.g., CO2M and TanSat-2) to fully explore the potential. This work marks an important step towards automated GHG point source monitoring and has the potential to make a significant contribution to the GHG remote sensing community.
Minor suggestions:
(1-1) The dataset construction process, including WRF-GHG simulation, XCO2 construction and data augmentation, involves multiple scenarios, especially it seems that the model is trained on the synthetic dataset and evaluated using independent datasets. It may be better clarified using a diagram.
(1-2) The authors summarized GHGPSE-Net in Figure 3. However, the overall methodology, including simulation, simulation evaluation, training dataset preparation, and deep learning evaluation, is quite complex and somewhat difficult to follow. The authors may consider summarizing the entire methodology in Section 2.
(1-3) In some related GHG plume detection studies, deep learning models usually require wind as an input. Does GHGPSE-Net not require the 2D wind field as input?
(1-4) According to the result (e.g., Table 3), it seems the "2 km × 2 km" in L10 should be 0.5 km × 0.5km.
Technical comments:
(2-1) Typo in L59 and L137.
(2-2) It should be "mean squared error" instead of "mean square error" in L10, L208, and L223.