the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
The effect of a short oxygen exposure period on algal biomass degradation and methane release from eutrophic and oligotrophic lake sediments
Abstract. Algal blooms in lakes result in large amounts of labile carbon being transported down the water column towards the sediments, often resulting in temporary water column hypoxia. The algal biomass is deposited at the surface sediments, where it is degraded by the microbial community. Negative effects of algal blooms and biomass depositions are sometimes mitigated by pumping air or oxygen into the bottom waters of lakes. The fate of the algal biomass, in terms of greenhouse gas release, is however often unknown. We investigated methane emissions from sediments originating from both a eutrophic and oligotrophic lake and tested the effect of additional algal C inputs. Additionally, we investigated the effect of a pulse supply of oxygen, a mediating measure that is currently being used in the investigated eutrophic lake. Our results show a difference in the control experiments based on the state of eutrophication, but the methane release from new algal biomass additions was the same, although the process proceeded more rapidly in the eutrophic sediments. A 3-week pulse of oxygen lowered the emitted methane from both types of sediments by 50 %, not only reducing the emissions of algal biomass additions, but also reducing methane emissions from the experiments without fresh organic matter inputs. This effect was relatively long-lasting: its effects were visible for several weeks after anoxic conditions were re-established, making it a potentially interesting measure to lower methane emissions over a longer period.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of Biogeosciences.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.- Preprint
(1344 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(4188 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2024-3979 250211', Anonymous Referee #1, 11 Feb 2025
- AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Sigrid van Grinsven, 19 Mar 2025
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2024-3979', Anonymous Referee #2, 17 Feb 2025
General comments
The preprint numbered egusphere-2024-3979 investigated methane emissions from sediments from both eutrophic and oligotrophic lakes and the effect of additional algal organic carbon inputs, and examined the corresponding microbial community, which falls right into the scientific scope of BG. However, the similar studies have been published in recent years, and no substantial new finding was reported in the preprint. In addition, the manuscript was not organized in a good state. Specifically, the results were not supported by statistical analyses, the units of parameters are not standard, and the figures are not as meaningful as they should have, many sentences are not supported by literatures, and some sentences and paragraphs are redundant.
Specific comments
ABSTRACT
It is argued that 3-week pulse of oxygen lowered the emitted methane for several weeks after anoxic conditions were re-established. However, this is because the 3-week pulse of oxygen decreased methane emission, which cause the total amount of methane in the headspace is lower than the control, not because oxygen pulse decreased methanogenesis rater after oxygen removal. It is suggested to re-evaluate the methanogenesis rate in different stages of the incubation based on the oxygen conditions.
INTRODUCTION
It is well known that there are little algae in the oligotrophic lakes, so the influence of algal organic matter on methanogenesis in oligotrophic lake is seldom concerned. Why did you concern the influence of algal organic matter input on methanogenesis in oligotrophic lake? No sufficient reason was explained.
The introduction is not well supported by references, many references should by supplemented in L41-49,L56-60, L66-75, 86-92, 100-106, 108-119.
The main hypothesis of the study should be explained and highlighted.
METHODS
More information about the two lakes should be supplemented, such as water depth, Chl a in water, hypoxia situations, etc.
Basic physical and chemical sediment properties should be supplemented.
L150, why 10 ℃?
Table1, why there was no N2 flushed after 1 week treatment in Lake Baldegg?
L193, how to examine oxygen by Pyroscience? How to avoid the influence of slurry?
L215, why whole core experiment was not performed in the eutrophic lake?
L224, why Chlorella and Spirulina were chosen in the study? Are they the predominant in the studied two lakes?
L227-230, how did you deposit algal biomass on the sediment surface, as freeze-dried algal cells usually are lighter than water. In addition, will the flushing of N2 influence the distribution of algal biomass?
L241-242, 10ml gas was sampled, why 10-15 ml gas was added?
RESULTS
Methane concentration in the headspace is the direct result from the examination, it is not suitable use the change of methane concentration to reflect the methanogenesis rate, such as Fig.1. The rate of methane emission in slurry incubation should be attributed to unit time and unit mass (or volume) of sediment, and methane emission from core should attributed to unit time and unit area of sediment, thus readers are able to compare your results with previous results.
Many units are not standard, such as 9 μmol per week in L299, μM in L305, μmol per L in L317, etc. Week is seldom used in the calculation of methanogens rate, and day is suggested in this study. μM should be replaced by μmol L-1.
Data of Fig1 are from Fig2, so their order should be changed in the manuscript.
It is argued that 3-week pulse of oxygen lowered the emitted methane from both types of sediments by 50%. However, this is because the 3-week pulse of oxygen decreased methane emission, not because oxygen pulse decreased methanogenesis rater after oxygen removal. In figure 2, the similar methanogenesis rates are expected in different treatments after oxygen removal. It is more suitable to analyze rates of methanogenesis (Fig 2) based on the oxygen conditions in incubation (Table 1).
Statistical analyses are needed in the results analyses, such as Fig 1, 6, 7, etc.
The community structure of methanogens is quite important in the study, they should be put in the text and with special concerns.
DISCUSSION
L529-541 are more suitable for the next section.
L593-594, ?
L612-614, why, how did you know?
L633, the FIGS9, S10should appeared in the results firstly.
On the base of the above suggestion, refine the main findings and polish the figures.
Technical corrections
Reference styles in the text must be uniformed according to the requirement of BG.
L51, sedimentary methane production→methane production in sediment
L80, H2?
L108, Artificial aeration is not only applied in Switzerland.
L130, showing and shown are repeated.
L144-147, sampling in the two lakes were carried out in different months, how about the environmental parameters in the water and sediment surface? How many cores were sampled?
L240, N2O?
Fig1, the symbols are too similar between 1 and 3 week oxic.
Fig4, which one is figure A?
L537, what does OM mean?
Some parts of the manuscript are redundant, not limited to the following sections, L302-303, 365-366, 473-475, 493-498, 668-669, etc. So, refine the language in the revision.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2024-3979-RC2 - AC2: 'Reply on RC2', Sigrid van Grinsven, 19 Mar 2025
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
137 | 36 | 12 | 185 | 21 | 4 | 4 |
- HTML: 137
- PDF: 36
- XML: 12
- Total: 185
- Supplement: 21
- BibTeX: 4
- EndNote: 4
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Country | # | Views | % |
---|---|---|---|
United States of America | 1 | 66 | 35 |
China | 2 | 17 | 9 |
Germany | 3 | 14 | 7 |
Switzerland | 4 | 12 | 6 |
France | 5 | 10 | 5 |
Total: | 0 |
HTML: | 0 |
PDF: | 0 |
XML: | 0 |
- 1
- 66