the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Variability and drivers of carbonate chemistry at shellfish aquaculture sites in the Salish Sea, British Columbia
Eleanor Simpson
Debby Ianson
Karen Elizabeth Kohfeld
Ana C. Franco
Paul A. Covert
Marty Davelaar
Yves Perreault
Abstract. Ocean acidification reduces seawater pH and calcium carbonate saturation states (Ω), which can have detrimental effects on calcifying organisms such as shellfish. Nearshore areas, where shellfish aquaculture typically operates, have limited data available to characterize variability in key ocean acidification parameters pH and Ω, as samples are costly to analyse and difficult to collect. This study collected samples from four nearshore locations at shellfish aquaculture sites on the Canadian Pacific coast from 2015–2018 and analysed them for dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) and total alkalinity (TA), enabling the calculation of pH and Ω for all seasons. The study evaluated the diel and seasonal variability in carbonate chemistry conditions at each location and estimated the contribution of drivers to seasonal and diel changes in pH and Ω. Nearshore locations experience a greater range of variability and seasonal and daily changes in pH and Ω than open waters. Biological uptake of DIC by phytoplankton is the major driver of seasonal and diel changes in pH and Ω at our nearshore sites. The study found that freshwater is not a key driver of diel variability, despite large changes over the day in some locations. Shellfish mortality events coincide with highly favourable pH and Ω conditions during summer and are most likely linked to high surface temperatures and disease rather than ocean acidification. To reduce shellfish mortality, shellfish could be hung lower in the water column (5–20 m) to avoid high temperatures and disease, while still experiencing favourable pH and Ω conditions for shellfish.
- Preprint
(2326 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Eleanor Simpson et al.
Status: open (until 30 Sep 2023)
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2023-1553', Anonymous Referee #1, 22 Sep 2023
reply
The ms presents interesting and relevant data and elaborations addressing the issue of the variability of the CO2 system at shellfish aquaculture sites and the relevance of the main drivers. The authors base their study on 14 campaigns over a period of 4 years. They address both seasonal (two season) and diel variability considering two depth (surface and midlayer) at 4 study sites. The data presentation is clear and the ms is well structured.
The ms has a long descriptive part which could be more appropriate for the technical report than for ta scientific paper. It could be summarized, in particular, when presenting the saturation state o aragonite and calcite which have quite similar variations as shown in figures 2 and 3.
The authors discuss the biological role assessing that “DIC drawdown by primary production is the dominant driver of seasonal and diel pH and carbonates saturation state changes at nearshore locations but they do not present dissolved oxygen data among the Biologically significant parameters (figures 3 and 4) but only in the figure A10 in the Appendix (not very easy to read) instead a better representation of the seasonal variation in the different site would be very useful for the discussion where may variation are explained on the basis of the change in primary productivity.
Regarding the oxygen saturation presented in the Fig A10 It would be interesting to explain the existence in Summer at Okeover inlet of surface waters where there are both strong oversaturation and at least there cases of anoxia but no minima of pH.
The authors outline that there has been shell fish mortalities attributed to temperature and diseases in the study area however the info is very generic, some more detail on the organisms which caused the mortalities (of both natural and cultivated clams and oysters?) in the area would be useful to understand the potential relationship with temperature increase.
Methods
The authors should specify in the ms at least on which scale of pH they have chosen, the reader has not to go to another paper to know this.
Conclusion
The conclusions are not coherent with the main objectives, they seem to be more implications deriving from conclusions. The chapter named “implications” instead contains conclusions both should be revised in order to provide more clearly the conclusions related to the objectives of the ms.
Specific Comments
Tables 1 and 2. it is not clear what the number between parenthesis represent.
Lines 684-685. It is not clear what is the meaning of “is highly sensitive to carbonate space”.
Line 896. Only omega calcite undersaturation occur in winter or also omega aragonite?
Technical comments
Table A2. Caption Suggest to specify that end members are related to freshwater and seawater
Table A4. PSU is adimensional therefore remove the “unit” specify in the methods section that how salinity is expressed.
Table A5 align the numbers in the column with the title of the column.
Table A6 I wonder the reason for expressing Temperature uncertainty on the basis of the instrumental uncertainty whereas salinity uncertainty on the basis of geometric mean pooled deviations of replicate pairs of all the campaigns.
Tables A9 and A10. Explain in the caption the significance of the numbers between parenthesis and those in bold.
References: Check and correct the subscript for “CO2”
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2023-1553-RC1
Eleanor Simpson et al.
Data sets
NCEI Accession 0244177 Eleanor Simpson, Debby Ianson, Karen E. Kohfeld, Yves Perreault, André M. Comeau, Keith Reid, Marty Davelaar, Danielle Caleb, Kenny Scozzafava, and Paul Covert https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/metadata/landing-page/bin/iso?id=gov.noaa.nodc:0244177
Eleanor Simpson et al.
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
146 | 39 | 10 | 195 | 4 | 6 |
- HTML: 146
- PDF: 39
- XML: 10
- Total: 195
- BibTeX: 4
- EndNote: 6
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Country | # | Views | % |
---|
Total: | 0 |
HTML: | 0 |
PDF: | 0 |
XML: | 0 |
- 1