Fundamental trade-off between climate and air quality from sulfur reductions in shipping fuels
Abstract. International shipping is a major source of sulfur emissions. Combustion of marine fuels with high fuel sulfur content (FSC) releases SO2, promoting sulfate aerosol particle formation. These particles cool the climate by enhancing cloud albedo and reflecting solar radiation, but harm air quality and human health. In 2020, the IMO2020 regulation reduced the global FSC limit from 3.5 % to 0.5 %, decreasing sulfate aerosol burdens and their cooling effect, uncovering previously masked anthropogenic warming. Using a global aerosol–climate model, we quantify the loss of cooling and explore alternative emission scenarios that could preserve aerosol-induced cooling while improving air quality. Without IMO2020, model-simulated shipping-induced aerosol effective radiative forcing is −112 mW m⁻² globally. IMO2020 regulations reduce this cooling by 67 mW m⁻² and ship-induced PM2.5 concentrations decrease on average by 57 % across the world’s most populous coastal cities. Sensitivity simulations show that enforcing IMO2020 regulations in coastal regions yields the greatest air quality benefits, whereas regulations over the open-ocean have little impact. However, coastal FSC reductions also account for the largest loss of cooling, consistent with the combination of dense ship traffic and high cloud albedo susceptibility to changes in aerosol concentrations. Retaining pre-IMO2020 FSC in regions with at least 30 % mean low-cloud cover could mitigate this loss of cooling but at the cost of limited air quality improvements in some areas. Our findings highlight the trade-off between reducing shipping-induced air pollution and preserving aerosol-induced cooling. Future research should further assess this trade-off considering additional alternative fuels.