the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
PALM-Traffic 2.0: Implementation of the traffic-induced heat and velocity in the PALM model system
Abstract. The new Traffic model has been developed and integrated into the PALM model system 26.10. Using data typically available for traffic emission modelling, it adds the parameterised impacts of car-induced heat and air flow on modelled tendencies of potential temperature and advection. Model evaluation in a realistic urban environment showed a significant impact of the traffic model at 1 m resolution on street canyon turbulent flow: it changes the wind component aligned with the street canyon by about 2.0 m s−1 and turbulent kinetic energy by about 0.6 m2 s−2. The increase of potential temperature was the strongest during stable stratification at night and early morning by up to 1.5 K; after the start of convection there was a modest increase of ≈ 0.5 K. The 4 m resolution domain showed a lower impact. Comparison with measurements obtained in a dedicated observation campaign in two parallel streets with heavy traffic showed that applying the model typically brings simulated results closer to observations, with good agreement between modelled and observed values. Comparison of the horizontal turbulent spectra showed that applying the Traffic model brings modelled spectra very close to those calculated from observations, with the impact at all frequencies including high frequencies close to the observation and model time resolution 1 Hz. The impact on air quality was tested in a simulation replicating a previously published study of a stable, low-wind winter situation. The results showed that the Traffic model significantly affected PM10 concentrations, changing both their magnitude and spatial distribution and substantially reducing the instabilities found in simulations without traffic effects. It demonstrated that inclusion of the transportation-produced momentum and heat forcing in the model is necessary for reliable realistic simulations of the stable low wind meteorological conditions.
- Preprint
(24839 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 03 Dec 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5699', Anonymous Referee #1, 06 Nov 2026 reply
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5699', Anonymous Referee #2, 10 Nov 2026
reply
Publisher’s note: this comment was edited on 11 November 2026. The following text is not identical to the original comment, but the adjustments were minor without effect on the scientific meaning.
The manuscript addresses an interesting and relevant problem: representing the mechanical and thermal effects of traffic in urban atmospheric simulations using commonly available input data. The dedicated field measurements are a valuable part of the study.
However, I found the manuscript difficult to follow. The novelty relative to the previous Traffic model is not sufficiently clear, and the links between the methodological description and the configurations evaluated in the results need strengthening. The two case studies are also presented without a sufficiently clear account of their different objectives and inputs. Some technical detail is necessary, but it often obscures the main reasoning.
The results show that the module substantially affects the simulated flow and concentrations. Whether these changes consistently improve predictive performance is less clear. I recommend to substantially revise the paper adressing the following points.
1. Novelty and methodological clarity
Please explain what Traffic 2.0 changes relative to the previous implementation, both in the introduction and alongside the relevant equations. General statements about an improved physical formulation or greater flexibility do not allow the reader to assess the contribution.
Sections 2–3 also need a clearer conceptual overview. In particular, the generation of speed perturbations is insufficiently described, although this option is central to the sensitivity experiments. A table linking each configuration in Sections 5.1 and 5.3 to the equations and options enabled would help. Please define the default settings and use consistent terminology for the momentum forcing.
2. Thermal formulation
Equations (7) and (8) require clarification and dimensional checking. If (P_{\mathrm{car}}) is a power in watts, Eq. (7) appears to lack a volume in the denominator. Please explain its derivation from Eq. (6), including the conversion to potential temperature.
In Eq. (8), converting fuel consumption per unit distance into a consumption rate appears to require multiplication by speed rather than division. Unit conversions should be explicit, and the heat of combustion should have units of J kg(^{-1}). Please clarify whether these are errors in the manuscript only or also affect the implementation.
3. Traffic inputs and the two case studies
The use of commonly available data is an attractive feature, but obtaining reliable traffic inputs is often difficult. More information is needed on how speeds, vehicle properties, speed variability and heat release are assigned, particularly when measurements are unavailable.
For Section 4.4.1, please explain the profile normalisation, the choice of four clusters and the assignment to unmonitored roads. For Section 4.4.2, some verification of the video-derived counts and speeds is needed, together with details on lane assignment and missing data.
Please also clarify the transition from hourly traffic profiles to pollutant emissions, including fleet composition, emission-factor sources and the treatment of driving conditions. For PM₁₀, specify whether exhaust, wear and resuspension are included. The relationship between the traffic information used for emissions and that used for mechanical and thermal forcing should be explicit.
The choice of separate episodes for flow validation and air-quality assessment needs a clearer explanation. It is particularly unclear which procedures in Section 4.4 apply to the February 2023 episode. Please identify the sources and processing methods used for each case, explaining which are shared and why others differ.
A targeted sensitivity test using plausible input uncertainties or less detailed traffic data would help establish practical applicability. The key question is whether the benefits of the more detailed formulation remain meaningful relative to the uncertainty in the inputs.
4. Sensitivity analysis and flow validation
Section 5.1 should make clearer what is learned from comparing the active configurations. Their mean velocities are similar, while differences in TKE and the strong dependence on resolution deserve more quantitative interpretation. The maps are not particularly effective at showing these differences.
The validation in Section 5.2 is mixed. At L-W, activating the module worsens the longitudinal velocity prediction; at S-W, TKE is frequently overestimated. Please quantify errors by variable and location and discuss deteriorations alongside improvements. Statements such as “almost perfectly” and “fully restored” are too strong.
Comparing the simplified configurations with observations would help establish whether the additional model complexity improves performance. Please explain the selection of days, time intervals and locations used in the comparisons, particularly the single-hour spectral analysis, and assess how representative the reported improvements are. Please also explain why the temperature measurements are not used to evaluate the thermal response.
5. Air-quality results
The reduction of simulated PM₁₀ peaks does not, by itself, demonstrate improved accuracy. In Fig. 9, observations are shown only at ALEG, where large discrepancies remain and some periods worsen when mechanical forcing is included.
I would encourage the authors to include the validation described as ongoing, at least for the episode analysed here. Otherwise, Section 5.3 should be framed as a sensitivity study and the claims about reliable air-quality simulations moderated. Please also justify the exclusive focus on PM₁₀ and consider whether NOₓ or NO₂ observations could provide useful complementary evidence.
The term “model instability” also needs clarification. What evidence distinguishes a numerical instability from excessive pollutant accumulation caused by the representation of transport or emissions?
6. Discussion and conclusions
Section 6 raises relevant uncertainties, but is lengthy and largely qualitative. It would be stronger if it distinguished demonstrated effects from plausible explanations, supported the latter with relevant references, and concentrated on the uncertainties most likely to affect the conclusions.
The treatment of parked cars at L-W is a particular concern: their influence disappears when the Traffic model is disabled, complicating attribution of the differences. Likewise, the circulation mechanism proposed in Section 6.3 explains the model behaviour but does not establish its accuracy. The claim of greater pollutant retention within the canyon needs more support than a local concentration increase.
The conclusions should state the specific advances of Traffic 2.0, reflect the mixed validation results and identify the main limits of applicability and what remains to be validated, particularly for temperature and air quality. The statement that agreement is poorer at 4 m also needs observational support: a weaker response to traffic forcing is not equivalent to poorer accuracy.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-5699-RC2
Data sets
Dataset Open PALM-Traffic 2.0: Implementation of the traffic-induced heat and velocity in the PALM model system [dataset] Jaroslav Resler, Michal Belda, Martin Bureš, Kryštof Eben, Vladimír Fuka, Jan Geletič, Josef Keder, Pavel Krč, Veronika Květoňová, Tereza Pikousová, Jelena Radovic, Hynek Řezníček, Petra Tesařová, and Ondřej Vlček https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22831866
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 335 | 150 | 43 | 528 | 38 | 40 |
- HTML: 335
- PDF: 150
- XML: 43
- Total: 528
- BibTeX: 38
- EndNote: 40
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
The manuscript by Resler et al. presents a new traffic module for the building-resolving LES model PALM. It presents the effect of the vehicles on the near-surface air temperature, wind speed, TKE and particulate matter concentrations. Results are compared to data from a measurement campaign in Prague, Czech Republic. As also shown by the authors, the topic is highly relevant for the modelling of air quality in a city. In general, the paper is structured and written well. However, several issues in the model description and the description of the results need to be dealt with before the paper could be accepted for publication.
Issues in the model description
My main issue in the model description is a potential double-counting of energy in (8) in L133: In this equation, the full energy contained in the fuel is used to heat the environment. However, a certain fraction of the energy is used to accelerate or maintain the speed of the car, causing the drag force and eventually the additional traffic wind speed tendency. Thus, you seem to be using more energy in the model than is actually available in the fuel. Please comment on this in the model description or in the discussion.
L108: Explain the reasoning in (2) more. While I understand that the drag force acting on the car acts also on the air, you use the volume of the car to be equal to the air volume to be affected by the drag force. Is this a model assumption? If so, state this clearly.
L128: The equation seems to be wrong, yielding a quantity with unit K m3 s-1, not K s-1.
L133: s_car is not introduced. (From (9) it seems to be the velocity of the car.)
L133: The equation seems to be wrong. Should the velocity be multiplied to yield the power?
L135: The unit of the combustion heat is wrong, probably J kg-1.
L141: Please explain this relationship a bit more. For example, I do not understand what U_car is?
L146: Please either call it wind speed tendency or advection tendency throughout the document to help the reader.
L153: What is speed instability? This is one of the characteristics of the different scenarios in section 5.1 and needs to be explained to understand the results.
Main issue in the methods and results section
It is unclear which days are analysed in the main result section. L225 says 28 May 2026 and 18 June 2026, also L281. However, L285 states that only 18 June was evaluated. Does this refer to section 5.2 or also 5.1. Be specific in the text as well as in the figure and table captions. The caption of figure A2 seems to mix different simulations and dates.
Other minor issues
L53: RANS is only explained later in the text. CFD is not defined.
L96: Indices like car and air are partly upright (preferred) and partly italic. Make this consistent.
L229: What are upper-layer parameters?
L231: What is the DFI blending method? Is it an abbreviation?