the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Dynamical adjustment and observational constraints to estimate recent forced European warming
Abstract. Europe has experienced rapid warming in recent decades. Previous studies have shown that changes in atmospheric circulation can explain part of this warming, but whether these dynamical changes are driven by internal variability or by external forcings remains unclear. In this study, we provide an estimate of the forced dynamical response over the 1979–2024 period, combining dynamical adjustment and observational constraint methods. While non-dynamical processes account for most of the observed warming, we show that the dynamical component also contains a non-negligible positive forced contribution. Overall, by incorporating dynamical information into observational constraints, we provide a new estimate of the future European warming, but find that this addition does not substantially reduce the uncertainty in climate projections.
- Preprint
(10836 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 18 Nov 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5426', Anonymous Referee #1, 01 Nov 2026 reply
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5426', Anonymous Referee #2, 13 Nov 2026
reply
Review of “Dynamical adjustment and observational constraints to estimate recent forced European warming” by Enora Cariou and colleagues.
This manuscript explores a decomposition of dynamically and thermodynamically forced temperature trends over Europe. The authors nicely combine recent advances in the field, building on a UNET to estimate the dynamic contribution with an observational constraint based on kriging. The manuscript is well-structured and well-written. Results and conclusions are clearly presented and add to the literature, highlighting the importance of forced dynamical trends in the context of dynamical adjustment.
I have some minor comments outlined below.
Minor comments:
Line 15: “In the mid-latitudes, weather and climate variability is mainly driven by the North Atlantic atmospheric circulation and particularly by fluctuations in the position and speed of the jet stream”
I’d argue mid-latitudes exist at all longitudes and in both hemispheres in general, while this statement seems to be mainly about at Eurasia?18: “typically temperature” maybe more precise: surface temperature?
72: I’m not fully convinced by the selection of observational references. Using (only) ERA5 regionally and HadCRUT globally seems ad hoc. What do we gain from being consistent with previous studies in the selection of the GSAT dataset? How would using ERA5 for GSAT as well change the results? The authors could also consider using an additional regional dataset such as the latest JRA3Q reanalysis to provide at least some estimate of observational uncertainty at a regional scale.
Small technical point: For me, GSAT is a model-only product. HadCRUT provides blended air temperature over land and SST over ocean (sometimes referred to as GMST).108: Might be worth mentioning here that about half of the models do not have multiple members, so this step is skipped if I understand correctly?
156: Missing citation175: Maybe the authors could add an indication of the 90% CMIP range in the right panels of figure 2 to show this more explicitly?
176 / 178: I have to admit that you lost me here:
“However, the majority of simulated trends of the term T are lower than the observed trend: 72% of the members show trends below the observed value.”
“The difference between observed and simulated trends is more pronounced: 78% of simulations show lower trends than observed, and only 3 of the 13 multi-member ensembles give average trends that exceed it.”
I get a bit lost here: What trends is either of these statements referring to?196: Maybe mention here that this is not surprising given that the authors use the very high warming SSP585 scenario for the future?
241: “Future temperature changes are anomalies in 2100 relative to the 1970–2024 baseline,” Delete ‘in 2100’? The entire time series in figure 5 are anomalies, not only 2100, or do I misunderstand something?
243: Ah, now it makes more sense, but I guess the comment still stands. Maybe add a panel with barplots similar to figure 2? Or a boxplot indicating the ranges in 2100?
264: “For TDyn (Figure 6b), the uncertainty is reduced by 25%” Should this be reference 6c?
300: Panels in fig6 are mixed up.
I’m a bit confused by this statement; from table 2 I take away that the constraint from the combined components is 39% versus 31% from constraining T directly. That seems like an improvement, even if not huge. Is this what the authors describe with “However, applying the method separately to the dynamical and non-dynamical components does not further reduce uncertainty in future projections compared to T”?Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-5426-RC2
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 322 | 173 | 44 | 539 | 48 | 45 |
- HTML: 322
- PDF: 173
- XML: 44
- Total: 539
- BibTeX: 48
- EndNote: 45
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Review’s comments for the manuscript egusphere-2026-5426, entitled “Dynamical adjustment and observational constraints to estimate recent forced European warming"
General comments
By using observations and climate model simulations this study estimates the forced dynamical response of European warming trends over the 1979-2024 period and provides estimated future projection warming trends by combining dynamical adjustment and observational constraint methods. The study is a good contribution in understanding recent European warming. However, there are some aspects that need to be addressed before the paper can be accpeted for publication. The reviewer recommend major revision by addressing the following major and specific comments.
Major comment
Specific comments