Development and application of an analytical method for the quantification of tire wear in atmospheric deposition
Abstract. Tire wear particles (TWP) are a major source of microplastic pollution and a carrier of rubber additives and metal-containing compounds that can be released into the environment and adversely affect ecosystems. Reliable quantification of TWP remains challenging because tire materials are compositionally heterogeneous and environmental samples contain complex organic and inorganic matrices that interfere with their analysis. Here, we present a pyrolysis-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (Py-GC-MS) method for the quantification of TWP in atmospheric deposition samples. The method combines targeted sample pretreatment, including density separation and removal of organic matrix components, with the analysis of six characteristic pyrolysis products of tire rubber, namely butadiene, 4-vinylcyclohexene, isoprene, limonene, styrene, and α-methylstyrene. The sum of the integrated peak areas of these markers is used to quantify TWP mass.
Instrumental parameters, including pyrolysis temperature (set to 500 °C) and gas chromatographic separation, were systematically optimized to maximize sensitivity, reproducibility, and chromatographic resolution. Calibration was established using cryo-milled tread materials from 23 used passenger car and truck/bus tires as well as a mixture of cryo-milled tread materials representative of the U.S. tire market. The sum of the six marker signals showed a strong linear relationship with tire tread mass across different tire types (r² = 0.93). The method achieved a limit of detection of 0.16 µg TWP and a dynamic range extending to approximately 450 µg TWP. A comprehensive uncertainty assessment identified variability in tire composition as the dominant source of uncertainty. The expanded uncertainty for the quantification of TWP in a single atmospheric deposition sample ranged from −58 % to +63 %.
Application of the method to duplicate atmospheric deposition samples collected at two suburban sites demonstrated its suitability for environmental monitoring. Mean TWP mass deposition rates of 843.9 µg m⁻² day⁻¹ were measured at a site located near a busy road, compared with 253.4 µg m⁻² day⁻¹ at a nearby suburban background site. These results demonstrate that the proposed multi-marker Py-GC-MS approach enables quantitative TWP measurements in complex environmental samples while providing an explicit characterization of the associated measurement uncertainty.
This study is based on an improved method determining TWP in atmospheric deposition samples using Pyro-GC-MS. The Manuscript is timely and relevant. However, it has some methodology shortfalls that need to be addressed, some of them vital elements of method validation:
Lines 160: Please specify if it was tested that the TRWP are quantitatively distributed into the supernatant since centrifugal forces can overcome density differences, causing particles to deposit to the bottom?
Line 170: For the efficiency testing of the solvent cleanup the used method is not sufficient. The used spiking experiment is not well explained, and not easy to read from the figure in the SI. Please add more details also mention if replicates were done, adding standard deviations of the findings. Further, the source of the deuterated standards is not mentioned in the method chapter.
Line 180: The pyrolyses method is poorly described. Please add more info on splitt ratios/ times etc as for any other S/SL injector
Line 220: Add the masses used for identification of the additives in SI
Line 265: Is this Statement correct: “The maximum quantification amount of CMTT at the 400:1 split ratio was approximately 450 μg “ ? It is contradicting the 430 µg mentioned in the line before.
Line 275: Please elaborate on why the r2 in Table S3 are much better for all markers than the ones discussed here? Please add some more detail on the different data given.
Line 345: The specifics of the recovery experiments should be added to the method chapter. What were the concentration ranges tested? Was a concentration close to LOD and one at 10x LOD used as a minimum requirement for method validation? At which step was the CMTT spiked ? Was it added to sampling device to cover the whole process or at a later stage in the method? As of now the description is not sufficient enough to illustrate the suitability of the method.
Line 350: The established correction factor is difficult to evaluate with the lack of info on the recovery experiment. Since this number is used a major data manipulation step, the lack of detail and mostly with respect to concentration ranges the factor applies to, the quality of resulting data is impossible to evaluate.