the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Comparative Study of HEC-RAS and TELEMAC for Two-Dimensional Flood Simulation in a Densely Built Urban Area
Abstract. Flooding is a natural disaster and a long-term challenge for urban planning. Numerous studies have stated how flood risk could increase with climate change and urbanization. HEC-RAS and TELEMAC are some of the sophisticated two-dimensional modelling tools to simulate floods. However, they have different numerical schemes, especially their meshing and discretization. A comparison is needed to evaluate how their results can differ. This study simulated a historical flood event in Sapan, a region in the Upper Citarum Watershed, Indonesia, using HEC-RAS and TELEMAC. Additionally, this study investigated how both models simulate flood extent, propagation, velocities, and depths, especially from TELEMAC since it is underutilized in Indonesia. The models’ setup was configured to be equivalent. However, differences remain, especially in the building interpretation. The flood extent from both models was remarkably similar, with a 1.34 % difference in max inundated area. The main differences were velocity distribution around buildings because TELEMAC had a finer mesh. However, with a coarser mesh, HEC-RAS could simulate a similar flood extent through the utilization of subgrid bathymetry information. Both models have demonstrated good performance. HEC-RAS might be more suitable for broad-scale modelling, where inundation depth is the main concern. However, if detailed velocity mapping is needed, TELEMAC might be more suitable.
- Preprint
(15440 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4597', Anonymous Referee #1, 07 Oct 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4597', Anonymous Referee #2, 27 Oct 2026
1) Please perform a strong polishing in the text since it contains many short sentences making it rather difficult to read; for example, in the Abstract is mentioned that "A comparison is needed to evaluate how their results can differ. This study simulated a historical flood event in Sapan, a region in the Upper Citarum Watershed, Indonesia, using HEC-RAS and TELEMAC. Additionally, this study investigated how both models simulate flood extent, propagation, velocities, and depths, especially from TELEMAC since it is underutilized in Indonesia. The models’ setup was configured to be equivalent. However, differences remain, especially in the building interpretation.", which could be easily merged in only a couple of sentences.
2) The Authors mention 2 well-known flood simulation softwares (HEC-RAS and TELEMAC), by also focusing to their differences and similarities (for example, different numerical schemes, meshing, etc.). Although this could be of practical use, the scientific reasoning should be further investigated preferably by a sensitivity analysis including all required input and output factors. In this manner, the Authors could then report the impact of each factor to the flood risk as estimated by each software and discuss and justify the differences.
3) The Authors mention that both climate variability and urbanization are increasing flood risk; however, these factors are not of the same severity. As illustrated in several studies, both increases and decreases in floods can be caused by the strong climatic variability (see, for example, the study for Europe by Bloschl et al., 2019, doi:10.1038/s41586-019-1495-6). On the other hand, the impact of urbanization to flood risk can be quite severe if one considers how the human-river distance is often decreasing and the area of the urban environment is increasing (see, for example, the study by Wang et al., 2023; doi:10.1029/2023GL105064, how the human-river distance has increased or decreased in the area of interest). I would recommend the Authors showing the flood risk maps of the areas of interest and the urbanization expansion over the last years and measure the human-river distance and the urban area that both can highly increase the flood risk as discussed in the above studies.
4) In the flood risk metrics used for comparison between the models, please use also the non-flooded are metric (i.e., whether the models have successfully captured not only the flooded area but also the non-flooded one).
5) The main conclusion "Both models have demonstrated good performance. HEC-RAS might be more suitable for broad-scale modelling, where inundation depth is the main concern. However, if detailed velocity mapping is needed, TELEMAC might be more suitable." does not seem very strong and should be further investigated to exert more decisive results. In my opinion, the strongest conclusion is the ones related to investigation of the impact of the mesh resolution (e.g., "The main differences were velocity distribution around buildings because TELEMAC had a finer mesh. However, with a coarser mesh, HEC-RAS could simulate a similar flood extent through the utilization of subgrid bathymetry information."), which however, needs to be further investigated through a sensitivity analysis (as mentioned above) and discussed with comparisons to other similar studies regarding the mesh resolution impact and the discretization in the topography; for example, see such studies in Cook and Merwade (2009; doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2009.08.015), recent review in urban models by Alexopoulos et al. (2024;doi.org/10.1080/02626667.2024.2378487), where the overestimation of the flood extent (expressed in terms of the fact that coarser grids yield in higher flood depths) regarding the discretization impact is estimated to be significant at the order of 30 m grid sizes.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4597-RC2
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 360 | 182 | 65 | 607 | 61 | 64 |
- HTML: 360
- PDF: 182
- XML: 65
- Total: 607
- BibTeX: 61
- EndNote: 64
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
For Authors;