A Novel Synergistic Approach Using Altimeter Backscatter for an Improved Radiometer Thin Sea Ice Thickness Retrieval
Abstract. This study proposes a novel altimetry-radiometry synergistic approach for improving SMOS thin sea ice thickness retrievals by incorporating permittivity estimates derived from CryoSat-2 backscatter observations. Since sea ice permittivity remains the dominant source of uncertainty in L-band radiometric thickness retrievals, the sensitivity of the CryoSat-2 backscatter signal to variations in this parameter offers a promising pathway to better constrain it. By integrating these permittivity estimates into a hybrid scheme that includes the inversion of an L-band sea ice emission model using machine learning, the approach aims to enhance the accuracy and robustness of thin sea ice thickness estimates obtained from SMOS. A set of independent in situ datasets is used to validate the proposed methodology and to assess its performance across different ice regimes. The CryoSat-2-derived permittivity values lead to realistic and physically consistent estimates, although its validity is limited to first-year ice. Overall, the synergistic combination of Ku-band altimetry and L-band radiometry yields improved results compared to SMOS-only retrieval methods, which are included as a baseline for reference. This highlights the potential of cross-sensor synergies to advance thin sea ice monitoring, establishing a framework applicable to present and future satellite missions such as CIMR, CRISTAL, and ROSE-L.
This study proposes a novel altimetry-radiometry synergistic approach to improve SMOS thin sea ice thickness (SIT) retrievals by incorporating permittivity estimates derived from CryoSat-2 backscatter observations. By integrating these estimates into a hybrid machine-learning scheme based on an L-band emission model, the authors aim to better constrain sea ice permittivity, which remains a dominant uncertainty source in radiometric retrievals. Validation against independent in situ datasets demonstrates that the synergy of Ku-band altimetry and L-band radiometry yields more physically consistent SIT estimates compared to SMOS-only baselines, particularly for first-year ice. Overall, the manuscript is clear and the proposed framework shows potential for enhancing thin sea ice monitoring for future missions like CIMR and CRISTAL. However, the paper still requires improvements in the following aspects: the simplification of model parameters, the sensitivity of roughness assumptions, and the temporal mismatch between sensors.
General Comments:
Specific Comments: