the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Ice–ice collisional breakup enhances secondary ice production but reduces surface hailfall in a simulated pulse hailstorm
Abstract. Secondary ice production (SIP) can substantially modify the ice-phase structure of mixed-phase clouds, but its role in short-lived pulse hailstorms remains unclear. Here, an ice–ice collisional breakup (BR) parameterization is implemented in the NSSL two-moment scheme within Cloud Model 1 (CM1), and seven sensitivity experiments are conducted for an idealized pulse hailstorm to examine the effects of droplet shattering during freezing (DS) and BR on ice-phase evolution and surface hailfall. The results show that BR has a much stronger effect than DS on the cloud-ice structure and surface hail mass. Relative to CNTL, the experiments including BR show a marked reduction in the peak total hail mass at the surface, with the largest decrease reaching 41.94 %. BR increases the ice crystal number concentration by about two orders of magnitude between approximately 5 and 9 km, accompanied by reduced supercooled liquid water above 4 km, lower graupel mixing ratio, and weakened graupel riming growth. These changes reduce the size of potential hail embryos, weaken graupel-to-hail conversion at some heights, and limit subsequent hail growth. The decomposition of BR collision pairs shows that, during the mature hail-producing stage, collisions of ice crystals with graupel and hail become the main sources of BR fragments. Overall, BR can substantially reduce surface hail mass in this idealized pulse-hailstorm case by restructuring the ice phase and enhancing competition for supercooled liquid water.
- Preprint
(2119 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-3542', Anonymous Referee #2, 02 Oct 2026
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Yi Dong, 01 Nov 2026
Dear Referee,
We sincerely thank you for your careful review of our manuscript and your constructive comments.
We have carefully considered all your comments and prepared point-by-point responses, including additional analyses, figures, and tables. Our responses and the corresponding proposed revisions are provided in the attached PDF supplement.
We appreciate your time and effort in helping us improve the quality and clarity of our manuscript.
Best regards,
Yi Dong, Shaofeng Hua, Baojun Chen, and Tuanjie Hou
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Yi Dong, 01 Nov 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-3542', Anonymous Referee #1, 05 Nov 2026
Comment to “Ice–ice collisional breakup enhances secondary ice production but reduces surface hailfall in a simulated pulse hailstorm”
This manuscript investigates how secondary ice production (SIP)—specifically droplet shattering (DS) during freezing and ice–ice collisional breakup (BR)—modifies ice-phase microphysics and surface hailfall in an idealized pulse hailstorm. Using the CM1 model with the NSSL two-moment bulk scheme, the authors conduct a well-designed suite of seven sensitivity experiments. The core finding is that BR substantially increases ice crystal number concentrations (ICNCs) yet reduces surface hail mass. The findings are interesting with proposed mechanisms. The paper is well written. I would suggest its acceptance for publication with necessary modifications.
General Comments
- The manuscript presents a careful implementation of PH17 within the NSSL two-moment framework, including a bin-emulation approach and mass-conserving feedback. However, several simplifying assumptions introduce uncertainty that is not fully quantified, including fixed rimed mass fraction, given collision efficiencies, and assumed shape parameters for gamma distribution. Sensitivity analysis could be appreciated and help answer or discuss the issues.
- Enhanced ICNCs and modified latent heat release from deposition/sublimation could alter buoyancy profiles and cold-pool strength, which in a pulse storm can affect subsequent updraft pulses and storm longevity. This effect has not been considered or discussed in the study with the indication of “does not lead to a systematic increase in the domain-maximum vertical velocity" by BR.
- An interesting result is that BR_PH_2 reduces peak surface hail mass by 21.15% relative to CNTL, whereas SIP_ALL_2 (DS_LAW + BR_PH_2) reduces it by 41.94%—nearly double. Since DS_LAW alone produces only a slight increase in peak hail mass (Fig. 2c), the combined effect is strongly non-additive and synergistic, which is definitely worthy for further investigation and discussion.
Minor comments
Line 24-25, DS should be put just behind “droplet shattering”
Line 68-70, A recent study is highly suggested here, Li et al. (2025, doi: 10.1175/BAMS-D-24-0094.1).
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-3542-RC2 -
RC3: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-3542', Ted Mansell, 14 Nov 2026
The comment was uploaded in the form of a supplement: https://egusphere.copernicus.org/preprints/2026/egusphere-2026-3542/egusphere-2026-3542-RC3-supplement.pdf
Data sets
Data for “Ice–ice collisional breakup enhances secondary ice production but reduces surface hailfall in a simulated pulse hailstorm” Yi Dong, Shaofeng Hua, Baojun Chen, and Tuanjie Hou https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20556202
Model code and software
Model code for “Ice–ice collisional breakup enhances secondary ice production but reduces surface hailfall in a simulated pulse hailstorm” Yi Dong, Shaofeng Hua, Baojun Chen, and Tuanjie Hou https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20556202
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 331 | 142 | 52 | 525 | 46 | 47 |
- HTML: 331
- PDF: 142
- XML: 52
- Total: 525
- BibTeX: 46
- EndNote: 47
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
This manuscript investigates how the secondary ice processes affect the development of a pulse hailstorm using model simulations. In the past decade, the parameterization of secondary ice processes (mainly drop shattering and ice-ice collisional breakup) have been developed and implemented into numerical models. This study uses the recently developed parameterizations to simulate the development of a pulse hailstorm. The modeling results indicate that ice-ice collisional breakup is the dominating secondary ice process, whereas drop shattering is not so important. The study found that the hail mass is quite sensitive to the ice-ice collisional breakup. Including the ice-ice collisional breakup process in the model would reduce surface hail. This is a quite interesting point. The writing of the manuscript is generally good. However, there are some issues that need to be clarified. Below are some suggestions:
Main issues:
Minor issues:
The ice phase collision pairs, such as H-H, H-G, etc., should be written as complete words when they first appear in the manuscript.
In section 2.1, it is mentioned that data from two X-band radars are used. In Figure 1, is the radar reflectivity from one of the radars or from the combination of the two radars?
In section 2.1, the hydrometeor classification using X-band radar should be described in more details. It should at least point out that how many types of hydrometeors are classified.
Title of 3.1 should be “observed and simulated storm structure ……”
The fonts in almost all the figures are too small.