Adjusting Diurnal Error in In-Situ Soil Moisture Measurements via Fourier Time-Filtering Using Land Surface Model Datasets
Abstract. Soil moisture (SM) measurements obtained via dielectric-based sensors are widely used in hydrological and climate studies. However, these measurements exhibit significant temperature sensitivity due to the Maxwell–Wagner polarization effect, causing an unrealistic diurnal cycle having spurious daytime peaks. This study introduces a Fourier transform-based method to correct such temperature-induced errors using physically consistent diurnal patterns from land surface model (LSM) reanalysis datasets (ERA5-Land and MERRA-2). The proposed approach adjusts the spectral power of the SM diurnal cycle to align with model-derived patterns constrained by conservation of mass, resulting in physically realistic SM behavior—peaking in the morning and decreasing during the daytime due to evapotranspiration. Validation against non-dielectric reference sensors indicates that the adjusted SM measurements are significantly improved. The diurnal correlation between SM and soil temperature shifts from predominantly positive to negative, particularly evident in regions with large diurnal temperature ranges and dry climates. Furthermore, applying this method to flux tower observations improves the characterization of land–atmosphere interactions by depicting the energy-limited process at sub-daily timescales, where increased incoming radiation during the daytime drives enhanced latent heat flux and subsequently reduces SM. Overall, this Fourier transform-based adjustment enhances the verity of in-situ soil moisture observations, promoting accurate sub-daily analyses of soil moisture dynamics and enabling improved understanding of land–atmosphere coupling processes.
Review: Adjusting Diurnal Error in In-Situ Soil Moisture Measurements via Fourier Time-Filtering Using Land Surface Model Datasets
This manuscript focuses on addressing the temperature-sensitivity issues inherent in dielectric-based soil moisture (SM) sensors, which often lead to spurious daytime peaks in diurnal cycles. The authors propose an empirical correction method based on Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) by leveraging the physically consistent diurnal patterns from land surface model (LSM) reanalysis datasets. The performance of the adjusted SM data was validated against reference sensors and further evaluated through land-atmosphere coupling analysis. Overall, the study provides a practical and innovative solution to a long-standing problem in the hydrological community. The topic fits well within the scope of the journal. However, considering there are some critical methodological issues and data inconsistencies that need to be clarified, I recommend a major revision.
Major Comments:
Minor Comments: