Evolution of nonstationary hydrological drought characteristics in the UK under warming
Abstract. Although the United Kingdom (UK) is relatively wet, there is an increasing awareness of the impacts of droughts, and an expectation that droughts will become worse in the future. This has motivated studies that have developed projections of future UK drought characteristics. To date, however, very few have addressed future changes in terms of probability of occurrence, and none have quantified the evolution of rare nonstationary hydrological drought characteristics under different warming conditions. This study investigates future changes in the hydrological drought characteristics under varying global warming levels (1.5 °C, 2 °C, and 3 °C), using nonstationary extreme value analysis combined with a Bayesian uncertainty framework across 200 river catchments in the UK. The analysis utilizes the enhanced future Flows and Groundwater (eFLaG) dataset, which is based on the most recent UKCP18 climate projections, and incorporates outputs from four hydrological models (G2G, PDM, GR4J, and GR6J). The findings indicate that rising temperatures will significantly influence future drought duration, severity, and intensity across a majority of catchments, with rare droughts (return period of 100–500 years) projected to be more severe in all seasons, particularly in the southern UK. Further, relatively frequent summer droughts (return periods of 10 years) are expected to become shorter but more severe and intense, particularly at higher warming. We observe notable differences between stationary and nonstationary return periods across seasons, with the change becoming more pronounced at longer return periods, particularly for drought severity. Although the trends remain consistent across models under stationary and nonstationary conditions, the results underscore the role of rarity, nonstationarity, and seasonal controls on the future evolution of hydrological droughts in the region.
Title: Evolution of nonstationary hydrological drought characteristics in the UK under warming
Recommendation: Accept after corrections
Explain the non-stationarity in the hydrological drought time series. How the future groundwater estimates are calculated and how accurate it is?
Line 35: 1.2 deg is the how many years average?
Line 80-81: ….”transient changes in low-flows characteristics”; what is the meaning of the transient changes here?
Line 113: What is “transient” is not clear from the introduction?
Line 117-118: “we aim to capture the full spectrum of possible future hydrological drought conditions under different climatic conditions.”
Line 133 – 135: “It should be noted that all 12 ensemble members originate from the same model framework and are based on the high emissions scenario (RCP8.5).” How it is same model framework? Please rephrase or write proper explanation for these lines?
Line 148: “recently developed CHESS-SCAPE” what do you mean by “recently developed”
Figure 1: which approach is more suitable for the drought identification; variable threshold or stationary approach? Have authors included the justification and applicability for these methods?
Conclusions:
Authors are advised to write the conclusions with the focus on the comparative analysis of the drought occurrence in the baseline and future periods under different warmings. Which can help in the framing/modifying the policy for the future dryness events.