Drivers of CO2 emissions during the dry phase of Mediterranean and Temperate ponds
Abstract. Pond ecosystems play an important role in the global carbon cycle with the potential to act as both sinks and sources. Emissions of CO2 during their dry phases remain largely overlooked, despite growing evidence that climate change-induced shifts in temperature and precipitation will likely result in longer and more frequent dry periods. Here we assess CO2 emissions from dry pond sediments in relation to climatic region, seasonal changes, and hydroperiod duration. Specifically, we aimed to identify the key environmental drivers shaping CO2 fluxes during the dry phase. We measured CO2 emissions from air-exposed sediments in 30 ponds across Mediterranean and Temperate regions. Ponds acted as sources of CO2 during dry phases, with emissions ranging from 127 to 4889 mg C m⁻² d⁻¹ (mean ± SD = 1398 ± 1201). Although mean emissions did not differ significantly between climate regions, hydroperiod length interacted with climate and season, showing a significant effect in summer, particularly in Mediterranean ponds, where longer hydroperiods led to higher emissions. Emissions were considerably higher in summer than in autumn, primarily driven by an interaction between sediment temperature and water content. The highest fluxes occurred at c. 27 °C and sediment water content between 27 % and 44 %. Additionally, ponds in better conservation status and with lower carbonate content emitted more CO2. Our findings improve understanding of CO2 emissions during increasingly common dry phases and highlight how climate modulates local sediment conditions, thereby influencing the magnitude of these emissions. This underscores the need for comprehensive assessments of carbon fluxes that incorporate dry-phase emissions, accounting for climate, hydroperiod, and both direct and indirect effects of local environmental drivers.
Review of the manuscript “Drivers of CO2 emissions during the dry phase of Mediterranean and Temperate ponds” by Frutos-Aragón et. al for Biogeosciences:
The study examines CO₂ fluxes of dry sediments from 14 temperate and 16 Mediterranean ponds in Europe during their dry phase in summer and/or autumn of 2022. These fluxes were measured using chambers. Additionally, sediment and water analyses were conducted to characterize the sites and to investigate the differences.
I read the manuscript with great interest and believe that the study is promising, but that some improvements are necessary.
General comments or questions:
Detailed comments and suggestions: