the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Accounting for Uncertainties in Forecasting Tropical Cyclone-Induced Compound Flooding
Kees Nederhoff
Maarten van Ormondt
Jay Veeramony
Ap van Dongeren
Jose Antolínez
Tim Leijnse
Dano Roelvink
Abstract. Tropical cyclone impacts can have devastating effects on the population, infrastructure, and on natural habitats. However, predicting these impacts is difficult due to the inherent uncertainties in the storm track and intensity. In addition, due to computational constraints, both the relevant ocean physics and the uncertainties in meteorological forcing are only partly accounted for. This paper presents a new method, called the Tropical Cyclone Forecasting Framework (TC-FF), to probabilistically forecast compound flooding induced by tropical cyclones, considering uncertainties in track, forward speed, and wind speed/intensity. The open-source method accounts for all major relevant physical drivers, including tide, surge, and rainfall, and considers TC uncertainties through Gaussian error distributions and autoregressive techniques. The tool creates temporally and spatially varying wind fields to force a computationally efficient compound flood model, allowing for the computation of probabilistic wind and flood hazard maps for any oceanic basin in the world, as it does not require detailed information on the distribution of historical errors. A comparison of TC-FF and JTWC operational ensembles, both based on DeMaria et al. (2009), revealed minor differences of <10 %, suggesting that TC-FF can be employed as an alternative, for example, in data-scarce environments. The method was applied to Cyclone Idai in Mozambique. The underlying physical model showed reliable skill in terms of tidal propagation, reproducing the storm surge generation during landfall and flooding near the city of Beira (success index of 0.59). The method was successfully applied to forecast the impact of Idai with different lead times. The case study analyzed needed at least 200 ensemble members to get reliable water levels and flood results three days before landfall (<1 % flood probability error and <20 cm sampling errors). Results showed the sensitivity of forecasting, especially with increasing lead times, highlighting the importance of accounting for cyclone variability in decision-making and risk management.
- Preprint
(3822 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Kees Nederhoff et al.
Status: open (until 27 Dec 2023)
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2023-2341', Anonymous Referee #1, 04 Dec 2023
reply
This paper presents a novel, flexible and open-source modelling framework, TC-FF, to probabilistically forecast tropical cyclone-induced compound flooding. The framework combines a Monte Carlo-based ensemble sampling generation with an autoregressive approach to create possible tropical cyclone scenarios, accounting for the uncertainties in track, intensity, and forward speed. The framework uses these scenarios to force a hydrodynamic model, SFINCS, that simulates the compound effects of tide, surge and rainfall on coastal flooding. The framework produces probabilistic flood maps that can support operational risk analysis and decision-making. The framework has been successfully applied to Cyclone Idai in Mozambique, and reproduced the tidal propagation, storm surge generation, and flooding extent near the city of Beira with reasonable model skills2. The authors also analyze the sensitivity of the flood forecasting results to the number of ensemble members and the lead time.
This is a well-researched and nicely written academic paper. The paper is worth being published with some modifications addressing the comments below.
Detailed comments:
- In the first paragraph of Introduction, please provide some examples to support the claim that compound flooding events are expected to worsen due to climate change and coastal development.
- In line 73, the paper should clearly state the disadvantages and limitations of the WES methods after analyzing their characteristics.
- The paper has logically explained the limitations of the current methods for forecasting tropical cyclone-induced compound flooding in the Introduction. However, the paper should add a summary of these limitations at the end of this section, and then state the research gap and research questions that motivate this study. The paper should also highlight the novelty and contribution of the proposed method, TC-FF, and how it addresses the limitations of the current methods. An explicit explanation of the advantages and benefits of TC-FF over other existing methods should be provided after line 108.
- In line 310, the paper states that the compound flood area model computes tidal propagation, storm surge, pluvial and fluvial flooding. However, the paper does not provide much information on fluvial flooding. If fluvial flooding is included in the model, the paper should add the details of fluvial forcing conditions in the Material part. The paper should also explain how the authors obtain and process the fluvial data, such as the river discharge, the river network, and the boundary conditions.
- From line 312 to line 314, how did the authors extend the model alongshore and in deeper water. Is there any references or principles about defining the water level boundary. Please give details.
- In line 321, the paper mentions that the model uses sub-grid bathymetry features to account for the effects of dunes and channels on the water level and flood extent. However, the paper does not provide much information on how the authors obtain and apply the sub-grid bathymetry data, especially in the estuarine area where bathymetry data is very difficult to get. The paper should explain the source, resolution, and processing of the sub-grid bathymetry data, and how they are incorporated into the model.
- In line 343, the paper states that the model runs on a high-performance computing (HPC) platform, but it does not specify the type of parallel computing used by the model. The paper should clearly indicate if the model uses parallel computing by CPU or GPU, or if it only runs on a single CPU core on the HPC platform.
- In line 368, the part of “Result” is divided into three subsections: verification of the numerical model, calibration and validation of the ensemble generation, and probabilistic forecasting of compound flooding. I suggest adding a brief introduction at the beginning of the section for a summary.
- The paper validates the SFINCS model for Cyclone Idai by comparing the model results with a limited number of observations, such as two high-water marks and one flood extent map. However, these data sources may not be enough to evaluate the model performance in different locations and time periods. The paper should use more data sources, such as satellite imagery or field survey, to assess the model spatio-temporal accuracy and reliability in simulating the compound flooding event.
- In the last paragraph, the paper briefly mentions that the results can be used for operational risk analysis, but it does not provide any explanations or examples of how the proposed model can support practical applications. The paper should add some explanations of how the results can be used for operational risk analysis, such as providing examples and recommendations for the use of the probabilistic flood maps.
- In line 129, there is a typo “Tthe”, which should be “The”.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2023-2341-RC1
Kees Nederhoff et al.
Kees Nederhoff et al.
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
89 | 47 | 8 | 144 | 5 | 6 |
- HTML: 89
- PDF: 47
- XML: 8
- Total: 144
- BibTeX: 5
- EndNote: 6
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Country | # | Views | % |
---|
Total: | 0 |
HTML: | 0 |
PDF: | 0 |
XML: | 0 |
- 1
Forecasting tropical cyclones and their flooding impact is challenging. Our research introduces the Tropical Cyclone Forecasting Framework (TC-FF), enhancing cyclone predictions despite uncertainties. TC-FF generates global wind and flood scenarios, valuable even in data-limited regions. Applied to cases like Cyclone Idai, it showcases potential in bettering disaster preparation, marking progress in handling cyclone threats.
Forecasting tropical cyclones and their flooding impact is challenging. Our research...