Permian-Triassic redox shift and its ferruginous aftermath in epicontinental seas
Abstract. Marine anoxia has been implicated as a key environmental driver of the end-Permian mass extinction (EPME) and the subsequent prolonged recovery. However, the spatial and temporal extent of oxygen limitation during the EPME interval remains contentious. Here, we present iron speciation, pyrite framboid and molybdenum-uranium (Mo-U) covariation data from two palaeogeographically distinct settings: the Tethyan Chibi section (South China) and the Panthalassian Ursula Creek section (Western Canada) to evaluate redox dynamics across the Permian-Triassic transition. Our data suggest that bottom waters were predominantly dysoxic during the late Changhsingian at both sites. Later, the prevalence of small pyrite framboids, elevated Mo and U enrichment factors (MoEF and UEF), and high MoEF/UEF ratios near the EPME horizon implicate seafloor anoxia as a key trigger for marine extinctions in epicontinental seas. In the post-extinction Early Triassic, iron speciation and MoEF-UEF covariation data reveal a shift to persistently ferruginous conditions in both locations. A global compilation of iron speciation data indicates that anoxic conditions fluctuated between ferruginous and euxinic in epicontinental seas during the Permian-Triassic crisis, with ferruginous conditions expanding significantly in the earliest Triassic. The expansion of a ferruginous seafloor would have limited phosphorus bioavailability, suppressing primary productivity in the immediate aftermath of the EPME, thereby contributing to the slow recovery.
General comments
Good research on paleoclimate. Please, follow my suggestions to improve the manuscript.
Specific comments
Line 32. “An extreme greenhouse climate prevailed during the Early Triassic”. Please, add the following references on the Early Triassic climate and stratigraphy.
- López-Gómez, J., Arche, A., Marzo, M., Durand, M. 2005. Stratigraphical and palaeogeographical significance of the continental sedimentary transition across the Permian–Triassic boundary in Spain. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 229, 3-23.
- Medici, G., West, L.J., Mountney, N.P. 2019. Sedimentary flow heterogeneities in the Triassic UK Sherwood Sandstone Group: insights for hydrocarbon exploration. Geological Journal, 54(3), 1361-1378.
Line 83. Summarize the overall goal of your research on paleoclimate.
Line 83. Describe the objectives of your research by using numbers (e.g., i, ii, and iii).
Lines 85-109. Provide detail on the major Permo-Triassic tectonic phases.
Lines 85-109. Mention the major tectonic lines in the study area.
Lines 111-136. If the result section is divided in sub-paragraphs, it should be the same for the methodology section. Please, fix the issue and expand the methodology.
Lines 357-365. “The Conclusions”. This section is too short. Please, expand.
Figures and tables
Figures 1a-c. The logs are of paramount importance. Please, increase the graphic resolution.
Figures 1a-c. Make the letters larger.
Figure 1c. What about nature of faults? Extensional?
Figure 7. Please, increase the graphic resolution also for this figure.
Figure 7. Make the letters larger also here.