Raman lidar-derived aerosol optical properties and classification during the FENNEC experiment – Coherence with CAMS data
Abstract. As part of the FENNEC programme, a field campaign was conducted on the Mediterranean coast of southern Spain, close to Gibraltar, from June to August 2011. Using a relatively straightforward ground-based N2–Raman lidar, several aerosol optical properties were retrieved at 355 nm, including the linear particle depolarisation ratio (PDR), the lidar ratio (LR), and the aerosol backscatter and extinction coefficients. Of the 58 sampled nights, several periods were identified in which aerosol events exhibited optical thicknesses greater than 0.5. The primary causative agents of these events are the influx of Saharan dust mixed with local polluted and marine air masses. Pairing PDR and LR has been shown to be significant in identifying three distinct bulk aerosol classes: dust, carbonaceous and soluble (predominantly marine) aerosols. After processing the night-time data to ensure sufficient lidar range, the study demonstrates the efficiency of lidar profiles in evaluating the reliability of the Copernicus Atmosphere Monitoring Service (CAMS) reanalyses of atmospheric aerosols up to approximately 7 km above mean sea level (a.m.s.l.). The two datasets show excellent consistency in terms of the optical thickness and vertical profile of the aerosol extinction coefficient in the Saharan dust aerosol layers. CAMS reproduces the temporal evolution well, with a correlation coefficient (COR) greater than 0.8. However, this is less true for the layer below 2 km a.m.s.l. (COR = 0.56), where there is a tendency for CAMS to underestimate compared to ground-based lidar.
This article describes a new dataset of aerosol optical properties taken in southern Spain during the Fennec campaign in June-August 2011 using a relatively simple ground-based lidar system. The author presents a novel method for classifying aerosols into three types based on a combination of depolarization and lidar ratio. The new dataset and classification is used to evaluate the aerosol vertical profiles and speciation in the CAMS aerosol reanalysis. The author finds that the reanalysis performs better in the free troposphere, with lower correlations in the boundary layer.
This article presents an interesting method for identifying aerosol types. Evaluation of the CAMS reanalysis is important both for users of the reanalysis and for identifying where improvements are required. However, the writing requires significant improvements as detailed below. Moreover, the calculation of aerosol extinction for the reanalysis seems overly simplistic.
General Comments
Specific Comments
P1, L10: Expand FENNEC acronym.
P2, L32: This should be after the Mediterannean dust experiment?
P5, L20: This is incorrect. Aeronet observations are not assimilated into the model
P13, L9: During the day…
P16, L10: No need for upper case The.
Fig. 9: Can you add ticks to the axis with the same orientation as the lines that show constant values for that aerosol to make it clear which lines correspond to which aerosol?
P19 L 23: expends should be extent?