Chemical reactivity assessment of sediment organic matter: Comparison with thermal methods
Abstract. Continental shelf sediments are important blue carbon habitats, but they are also exposed to anthropogenic disturbances such as bottom trawling, which increase oxygen exposure and thereby enhance organic carbon remineralisation. Understanding the susceptibility of shelf sedimentary organic matter to oxidation is therefore important, and research has moved beyond simple estimates of total carbon stocks towards characterising the potential vulnerability of this stored organic carbon. Here, we employ a modified chemical oxidation approach (acid-dichromate) to assess organic carbon reactivity in muddy shelf sediments from the Fladen Ground in the North Sea and compare it with the prevalent thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) technique. Sediments were oxidised with acidified dichromate at 5 °C for 1.5 to 24 hours, and the fractional loss of organic carbon was quantified. Maximum (~30 %) of the chemically oxidisable organic carbon was lost during the first three hours of treatment, with only a limited additional loss over longer oxidation times. The fractional carbon loss after three hours showed a strong positive relationship (r = 0.69) with the thermally labile organic matter determined by TGA. The results indicate that chemical oxidation and TGA provide similar estimates of vulnerable organic matter, although the fractions identified by both approaches remain operationally defined rather than reflecting in situ degradation processes. The modified chemical oxidation method, therefore, provides an accessible, complementary approach for characterising the relative vulnerability of organic carbon in marine sediments. Incorporating such reactivity-based measurements alongside carbon-stock assessments could improve evaluations of the resilience of shelf-sea carbon stores to disturbance and inform spatial marine management and conservation.