Alkalinity loss and limited ecological responses in a trio of tropical coastal ocean alkalinity enhancement experiments
Abstract. The Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement Pelagic Impact Intercomparison Project (OAEPIIP) defines common CO2-unequilibrated and CO2-equilibrated scenarios to systematically test the pelagic effects of OAE using sodium hydroxide (NaOH) worldwide. Two key uncertainties in the application of OAE to coastal systems are whether the carbonate chemistry and ecological responses to alkalinity additions remain comparable between inshore and offshore waters. Inshore, and particularly estuarine, environments are more susceptible to loss of alkalinity from heterogeneous precipitation of calcium carbonate. Similarly, inshore pCO2 and pH dynamics are typically more spatially and temporally variable than offshore systems, such that inshore ecosystems may be less sensitive to pH perturbations from OAE. Critically, the NaOH doses applied in the OAEPIIP protocol were intended to be sufficiently low to exclude the possibility of calcium carbonate precipitation and significant ecological effects. Here we ran three simultaneous 20-day OAEPIIP experiments using estuarine, inner bay and offshore seawater from Daya Bay (Guangdong, China) during a diatom bloom. In all three cases, there was no clear evidence for responses of bulk biomass, nutrients, biogenic silica, nitrous oxide (N2O), methane (CH4), or prokaryotic communities to NaOH addition. Phytoplankton exhibited some modest, taxon-specific responses to NaOH addition. All equilibrated treatments approached the intended +500 µmol kg−1 total alkalinity (TA) increase. However, TA concentrations in unequilibrated treatments were only +149 to +253 µmol kg−1 above control treatments on Day 20. This result was reproducible between replicate treatments and resembles the apparent TA loss reported in other regional OAE experiments using both NaOH and Mg(OH)2 as alkalinity sources. Whilst not explicitly confirmed, as OAEPIIP was designed with an assumption that TA loss would not be observed, these results implicate heterogeneous alkalinity loss as a key concern for OAE deployment in this environmental context.