Silicon redistribution and promoted low-latitude diatom growth after Atlantic circulation recovered from deglacial meltwater discharge
Abstract. How the marine silicon cycle modulates the biological carbon pump and contributes to glacial–interglacial variations in atmospheric CO2 remains unresolved. Proposed mechanisms include Southern Ocean silicic acid leakage, stimulating low-latitude diatom productivity either during the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) or at the onset of deglaciation, and deglacial silicon redistribution from the abyss to the surface. To test these hypotheses, we performed two equilibrium simulations (pre-industrial and LGM), one LGM sensitivity simulation with pre-industrial dust deposition and two freshwater perturbation experiments under LGM conditions with the Earth system model AWI-ESM2.1, in which the diatom silicon-to-nitrogen (Si:N) uptake ratio varies with the nutrient limitation state. Glacial dust deposition enriches Southern Ocean surface waters and southern-sourced intermediate waters in silicon relative to nitrogen, but strengthened stratification traps this reservoir, preventing it from fuelling low-latitude diatom growth. We identify two mechanisms that release silicon to low-latitude surface waters: (1) the recovery of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) after the freshwater perturbation strengthens intermediate-water formation, upwells the leaked silicon and drives short-lived but pronounced opal export peaks in the tropics; (2) continued warming and sea-ice retreat mobilise the deep glacial silicon pool, sustaining a more persistent enhancement. A longer freshwater perturbation suppresses the first mechanism. Despite some discrepancies in timing, our results reconcile previous hypotheses within a unified framework, defining circulation recovery as the critical trigger that links freshwater forcing to sedimentary opal records.
Many thanks for the opportunity to review “Silicon redistribution and promoted low-latitude diatom growth after Atlantic circulation recovered from deglacial meltwater discharge”. The aim of this paper is to use an Earth system model to explore the hypotheses that have been posited surrounding the shifts in silicon cycling across a deglacial cycle. I’m excited to see this modelling work carried out, and fascinated to see the results, which I’m sure will be of interest to others in the biogeochemistry and palaeoclimate communities. The paper is well written, clear, and the methods are explained well (with the caveat that I’m not an expert in model development). I only have a few minor suggestions, which I hope will be useful.
Opal accumulation rates:
I think the authors should add to section 2.4 some explanation that the opal accumulation data used have been normalised using 230Th in each case, to account for lateral redistribution of the sediments. Do the authors think that this correction has an impact on how the comparison with the model results is carried out?
Likely a minor point, but perhaps worth noting, is that the opal measurements are carried out in a different way to the other papers in Lippold et al. Perhaps a note could be added to the tables in the supplementary information about the methods used?
Intermediate depth archives:
There are some archives of DSi concentrations that have been reconstructed from sponge spicule silicon isotopes, which could be useful to refer to here (Hendry et al., 2012; 2016 – apologies for the self-citing!). If my understanding is correct, they will support the findings of this model study, at least as far as showing fluctuations in DSi concentration in mid-depths of the lower latitudes during the deglacial (again, however, the timing might be difficult to align, as with the other records cited).
Figures and supplementary figures:
I wondered if it might be useful to make some of the figures and supplementary figures more consistent. For example, in Figure 6, the values of Si:N have been masked in white where the DIN values are less than 1uM in one of the simulations, whereas this doesn’t seem to be the case for Figure A8? Is there a reason for this? (perhaps relating to the near surface nutrient concentrations in the RG-PIdust simulation)? Perhaps the same colour scheme could be used for consistency?
The caption of Figure 6 states that the seafloor has been masked in white, which doesn’t make sense to me as there doesn’t seem to be any seafloor present?
Could the authors clarify what the background shading is in Figure 8? The caption says “changes in DSi”, so does that mean that this is an anomaly? If so, relative to what? I don’t think that the shading can represent absolute DSi concentrations, as that would suggest a strong surface source in cases (e.g., in panel 3, recovered AMOC-phase).
References:
Hendry, K. R., Robinson, L. F., Meredith, M. P., Mulitza, S., Chiessi, C. M., & Arz, H. (2012). Abrupt changes in high-latitude nutrient supply to the Atlantic during the last glacial cycle. Geology, 40(2), 123-126.
Hendry, K. R., Gong, X., Knorr, G., Pike, J., & Hall, I. R. (2016). Deglacial diatom production in the tropical North Atlantic driven by enhanced silicic acid supply. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 438, 122-129.
Signed Kate Hendry