the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Resolving the complex responses of ozone transport and chemistry to typhoons in South China: Insights from process-level analysis
Abstract. Typhoons are major synoptic systems linked to ozone (O3) pollution in the Pearl River Delta, South China, particularly in autumn and summer. Although previous studies have identified various mechanisms of typhoon-induced O3 pollution, analyses of meteorological conditions or overall process contributions alone do not fully explain how typhoons affect O3 pollution through specific atmospheric processes, particularly transport and chemistry. Here, we combine O3 mass budget analysis, source apportionment, precursor-transport sensitivity simulations and chemical diagnostics based on WRF-CMAQ models to investigate the responses of these processes to typhoons in autumn and summer. Typhoons enhance O3 transport through both vertical exchange and horizontal transport, with increased transport of O3 derived from upwind emissions in both seasons and background O3 mainly in autumn. Transported precursors also contribute considerably to local O3 pollution (>10 µg m-3), which is further enhanced under typhoon influence, primarily driven by increased contributions from acyl peroxy nitrates (APNs) and NOx. Local photochemistry exhibits more complex responses: typhoons accelerate O3 production in autumn but suppress it in summer, reduce HOx cycling efficiency while enhancing O3 production efficiency, alter VOC contributions to OH reactivity, and generally shift O3 production toward more NOx-limited conditions. These findings reveal that typhoons influence regional O3 pollution through multiple transport pathways, transported precursor contributions and different aspects of photochemistry, providing further process-level evidence for understanding the mechanisms underlying typhoon-induced O3 pollution.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.- Preprint
(1980 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(1978 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 10 Dec 2026)
- CC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-6493', Xiaobing Li, 18 Nov 2026 reply
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 299 | 98 | 28 | 425 | 75 | 31 | 31 |
- HTML: 299
- PDF: 98
- XML: 28
- Total: 425
- Supplement: 75
- BibTeX: 31
- EndNote: 31
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
The paper by Qu et al., is a thoughtful and technically rich follow-up to their previous publication. The authors move from "net process contributions" to actual process-level attribution, which is exactly what the field needs for typhoon–ozone work. The combination of WRF-CMAQ mass budgets, source apportionment, precursor-group sensitivity experiments, and photochemical diagnostics gives a rare look at how horizontal transport, vertical exchange, aged-air-mass chemistry, and local radical cycling respond to typhoon influence in the PRD. Results of the paper are valuable. The study reframes typhoon-induced ozone not as a single mechanism but as a seasonal trade-off among transport pathways, precursor reservoirs (especially APNs), and shifting NOx/VOC sensitivity. That has practical implications for air-quality management under extreme-weather conditions. The paper is well organized and well written. I recommend a major revision because I still have some concerns.
Major Comments
1. The paper leans heavily on APNs as the dominant transported precursor group in autumn, interpreted via boundary-cut experiments. However, PAN-type species are thermally labile reservoirs, not direct O3 producers. The boundary-condition zeroing tells us what removes O3 when APNs are absent, not cleanly how much APN-derived NOx actually decomposes inside the PRD. The authors can add a diagnostic, tracking how APN releases NOx explicitly (or at least discuss OPE and NOx/NOy together) to separate "PAN transported in" from "PAN actually decomposed locally."
2. The link among lower NOx/Noy, more aged air, lower LOH but higher OPE, is plausible and broadly consistent with photochemical-age thinking, but the manuscript doesn't fully close the loop. LOH drops while OPE rises, that's interesting, yet the manuscript doesn't show how HO2/OH partitioning or peroxy-radical termination responds. I believe a short additional discussion may make this section much stronger instead of correlational.
3. ABLex-H and ABLex-A are central to the whole story, but the evaluation is essentially horizontal-surface O3 plus meteorology. Given that you argue for enhanced downward transport of background O3 (especially autumn), the lack of any vertical constraint, such as sonde, lidar, tower, or even satellite-derived UT/LS tracers, is a real weakness. Even a qualitative comparison with available vertical observations would help. At minimum, add a sensitivity discussion about how much of the "background O3" signal could be an artifact of boundary-condition nudging rather than true subsidence? At least, I believe in the results because another preprint paper (EGUsphere - Decoupling chemical formation and vertical recirculation in driving urban ozone pollution) also highlight the enhancement of downward transport in driving zone pollution in PRD.
4. The summer response is spatially messy. Xijiao flips to upwind, Daxuecheng becomes less VOC-limited, Heshan barely moves. Averaging RIR and kOH across sites risks smoothing out the exact heterogeneity that matters. I'd like to see more emphasis on site-specific behavior in the main text (not just Supp Info), and a clearer statement of whether the "NOx-more-limited" conclusion holds robustly or mainly for the regional site.
Minor Comments
5. p.2, line ~38: "reduce HOx cycling efficiency while enhancing O3 production efficiency". This is a nice phrasing, but define "efficiency" earlier or it reads tautological on first pass.
6. p.3, lines 70–75: "weather-process-pollution" framework is referenced before Fig. 1 is discussed. It’s better to move the citation or briefly explain inline.
7. p.4, line ~90: "Part I" is used repeatedly, consider spelling out Qu et al. (2021) once per section for readers who meet this paper standalone.
8. p.5, line 145: Model evaluation says NMMB within ±20%, but NMHCs are speciated, clarify this is total NMHC, not individual VOCs?
9. p.6, Eq (2): ABLex-A term is hard to parse. It’s better to add a one-line plain-English gloss for non-modelers.
10. p.7, BFM equations: clarify that averaging top-down/bottom-up assumes linear additivity, mention when that assumption breaks.
11. p.8, Table 1: "HCs" excludes methane but the table doesn't clarify so until the caption, put it in the row label.
12. p.8, line 220: "S5 close to sum of S1–S4", give the actual numerical difference, not just "close."
13. p.9, Sect 2.6: LOH definition is fine, but "OH chain length" means different things in different communities, add a parenthetical: "number of HO2→OH recycles per OH initiation."
14. p.9, RIR: 25% emission cut is ok, but note RIR is quasi-linear only near base state, large perturbations would change regime identification.
15. p.10, line 255: "morning increase until ~14:00 LT", figure shows decrease after 14:00. It’s better to say "peaks near 14:00" to avoid ambiguity.
16. p.11, Fig 3 discussion: arrows vs flux signs are confusing. In text, spell out "positive = inflow" explicitly.
17. p.13, Horizontal transport: "inflow from north and east" is a key claim, tie it to the actual typhoon quadrant/geometry briefly.
18. p.14, Fig 5: APNs dominate autumn, but error bars / day-to-day variability are missing. Four to six days per scenario is small add spread or bootstrapped confidence.
19. p.15, line 340: "HCs nearly negligible in summer" — maybe true, but check whether this is a transport-oxidation artifact vs emission artifact; one sentence on why.
20. p.16, P(O3) values: 5–25 ppb h⁻¹ is reasonable, but compare to observed box-model ranges in PRD, not just prior CMAQ studies. In addition, the mass units and volume mixing ratios are mixed used in the manuscript.
21. p.18, kOH section: OVOCs dominate 50–75%, but you also note "missing OVOCs" in observations; soften the claim that OVOCs sustain O3, say "appear to dominate in model space."
22. p.21, line 510: "RIR(NOx) from negative to positive", explain negative RIR physically (titration removal) before using it as evidence.
23. p.22, conclusions: "shift toward NOx-limited" is overstated for urban core; say "shift toward less VOC-limited / more NOx-sensitive" to stay defensible.
24. p.24, limitations: dry deposition under typhoon winds is waved off; even a 2-line speculation would help.