Monitoring, Reporting and Verification procedures for soil health: Current landscape, stakeholder dynamics and future pathways
Abstract. To counteract green washing, the effects of the activities that lead to an intended outcome should be quantified and monitored in a scientifically robust way and results should be transparently reported and verified. With this objective, Monitoring, Reporting and Verification (MRV) procedures were developed and studied in the context of soil carbon credits. However, no broader overview, including other aspects of soils, exists to date. The objective of this study was to fill this gap of knowledge by gathering, describing and classifying the MRV procedures including soil parameters, across the world. As the term MRV seems to be sparsely used by scientists, we combined three methodologies to collect information about MRV procedures: the classical use of scientific article database, web scraping and Artificial Intelligence browsers. We found 96 MRV procedures and partial information was available. Most of the available MRV procedures were applied on a local scale, in agricultural areas, responding to the methodological requirements of voluntary carbon markets standards, which illustrates the hegemony of carbon markets in the soil MRV context. Results were mainly gathered in a classical report and result-based verified. We classified the MRV procedures into six groups. Group 1 was only characterized by the lack of information and thus reflected the main limitation of our study. The five other groups addressed different stakeholders. Four of them targeted stakeholders of the agricultural sector and the last one project developers for peatlands and wetland restoration. The two largest groups demonstrated different strategies: more accurate monitoring and verification methodologies or cheaper ones. We also highlighted the lack of transparency from companies offering MRV procedures. In complement, we developed a decision tool to help future users of MRV procedures to navigate our dataset and select the most adequate MRV procedure, adapted to their context. The next steps are 1) to strengthen the collaboration between scientists and MRV providers and to 2) understand how to transition from carbon-focused MRV procedures to more holistic, soil health-focused MRV procedures.