the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Clarifying the controlling factors of the seasonal variation of droplet concentrations in marine low-level clouds
Abstract. Marine boundary layer (MBL) clouds exert a strong cooling influence on Earth’s climate, yet their response to aerosol perturbations remains one of the largest uncertainties in climate projections. A key challenge is identifying which aerosol and meteorological factors control cloud droplet number concentration (Nd), especially when boundary-layer structure alters the transport of surface-emitted aerosol to cloud base. Here, we combine aircraft and ground-based measurements from the Aerosol and Cloud Experiments in the Eastern North Atlantic (ACE-ENA) campaign with the aerosol activation parameterization to quantify controlling factors on Nd during different seasons. We found that summer and winter boundary layer decoupling modulates the vertical transport of aerosols within the MBL and thereby influences cloud condensation nuclei number concentration (NCCN) at cloud base. In both seasons, decoupling occurs for roughly 32 % of the total time, during which ~60 % of accumulation-mode and ~75 % of Aitken-mode aerosols fail to reach the cloud layer. The out-of-cloud accumulation-mode particle number concentration (Nacc) is higher in summer than in winter, whereas the corresponding Nd is comparable between the two seasons. Sensitivity experiments show that Nacc is the dominant control on Nd in summer, whereas cloud droplet formation in winter is additionally sensitive to Aitken-mode aerosol number concentration (Nait) and size. In contrast, seasonal variations in updraft velocity and aerosol hygroscopicity have weaker effects. These results help clarify how boundary-layer coupling and aerosol size distributions jointly regulate marine cloud droplet formation and provide observational constraints for representing aerosol-marine cloud interactions in climate models.
- Preprint
(2300 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(4881 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 26 Nov 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-6243', Anonymous Referee #1, 09 Nov 2026 reply
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-6243', Anonymous Referee #2, 11 Nov 2026
reply
Summary
This study examines the controlling factors of cloud droplet number concentration (Nd) of extratropical marine low clouds using airborne observations from the ACE-ENA field campaign and ground observations collected from the ENA site in summer and winter. The factors examined include aerosol concentrations and properties, boundary layer coupling state, and updraft velocity. The authors used activation parameterization developed by Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (2000, ARG2000) to investigate and quantify the importance of different factors, and concluded that accumulation-mode aerosol concentration played the most important role in both summer and winter, while Aitken-mode aerosol concentration is also important in winter. Overall, this paper presents an interesting perspective on controlling factors for Nd through combining in situ data with an activation model. However, I believe further clarification is needed regarding the analysis. I recommend accepting this paper with the major revisions suggested below.
Major Comments
1 It is unclear why Figure 1 shows substantially higher accumulation-mode aerosol concentrations than observed Nd in summer, and consequently much higher ARG2000 predicted Nd than measured Nd in Figure 2. Does this suggest that a large fraction of accumulation-mode particles are not activated, or that other processes reduce Nd after activation? Given that the current scheme neglects other potential aerosol sources, such as free-tropospheric entrained aerosol and new particle formation, one might expect the model to underestimate rather than overestimate Nd. The observed overestimation therefore warrants further explanation. Despite the discussion in 3.3.2, it is still not clear what the cause of the bias is. Given that the main difference between winter and summer is the accumulation-mode aerosol concentration, could this seasonal contrast indicate limitations or inappropriate assumptions in the ARG2000 scheme that affect its ability to reproduce the observed variability in Nd? If the ARG2000 scheme itself is biased, then how trustworthy are the sensitivity tests done in section 3.3.2 to understand the relative importance of different factors? At minimum, there should be more discussion on what previous studies have found regarding bias in the ARG2000 scheme (e.g., Gordon et al., 2020; Ghosh et al., 2025).
On a related note, given that surface CCN measurements are available, a sanity check would be to compare CCN concentrations at different supersaturations with the observed Nd in coupled cases to identify which supersaturation provides the best agreement, as the model's performance is highly sensitive to the calculated maximum supersaturation (Smax).
Gordon, H., Field, P. R., Abel, S. J., Barrett, P., Bower, K., Crawford, I., et al. (2020). Development of aerosol activation in the double-moment Unified Model and evaluation with CLARIFY measurements. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 20(18), 10997–11024. https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-20-10997-2020
Ghosh, P., Evans, K. J., Grosvenor, D. P., Kang, H.-G., Mahajan, S., Xu, M., et al. (2025). Assessing modifications to the Abdul-Razzak and Ghan aerosol activation parameterization (version ARG2000) to improve simulated aerosol–cloud radiative effects in the UK Met Office Unified Model (UM version 13.0). Geoscientific Model Development, 18(15), 4899–4913. https://doi.org/10.5194/gmd-18-4899-2025
2 The paper lacks discussion of the free troposphere as an important source of aerosol particles, implicitly assuming that the surface is the only aerosol source. For example, Zheng et al. (2018) found that entrained Aitken particles could contribute up to approximately 60% of the CCN population at ENA. In addition, the discussion does not adequately address processes that reduce Nd, such as entrainment-induced dilution, evaporation and precipitation.
Zheng, G., Wang, Y., Aiken, A. C., Gallo, F., Jensen, M. P., Kollias, P., Kuang, C., Luke, E., Springston, S., Uin, J., Wood, R., and Wang, J.: Marine boundary layer aerosol in the eastern North Atlantic: seasonal variations and key controlling processes, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 18, 17615–17635, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-18-17615-2018, 2018.
3 Essentially, this work is in the spirit of an offline aerosol activation closure study, where an aerosol activation parameterization or parcel model is used to predict activated cloud droplet number concentrations from measured aerosol properties and meteorological conditions (e.g. Braga et al., 2021; Chen et al., 2026; Ephraim et al., 2026; Russotto et al., 2013; Varghese & Prabhakaran, 2025). However, the current introduction does not adequately review this line of research or contextualize the present study within the existing literature. I recommend expanding the introduction to discuss previous studies that have used ARG schemes or parcel models to predict cloud droplet number concentrations and evaluate their predictions against observations. It would also be informative to discuss the key assumptions and limitations of the ARG2000 scheme in the Methods or Discussion section, as these may help explain discrepancies between predicted and observed droplet number concentrations.
Braga, R. C., Ervens, B., Rosenfeld, D., Andreae, M. O., Förster, J.-D., Fütterer, D., et al. (2021). Cloud droplet formation at the base of tropical convective clouds: closure between modeling and measurement results of ACRIDICON–CHUVA. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 21(23), 17513–17528. https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-21-17513-2021
Chen, Y., van der Werf, G. R., Mu, M., van Wees, D., Hall, J. V., Giglio, L., et al. (2026). Tracking recent extremes and interannual variability of global fire emissions using a near-real-time extension to the Global Fire Emissions Database. Earth System Science Data, 18(10), 7535–7555. https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-18-7535-2026
Ephraim, S., Zuidema, P., Bansemer, A., Cai, L., Petters, M., Rosky, E., et al. (2026). A closed-to-open cell mixed-phase cloud transition observed over the Nordic Seas under high aerosol loading and strong surface fluxes. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 26(21), 15375–15404. https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-26-15375-2026
Russotto, R. D., Storelvmo, T., & Smith, R. B. (2013). Modeling aerosol activation in a tropical, orographic, island setting: Sensitivity tests and comparison with observations. Atmospheric Research, 134, 12–23. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.atmosres.2013.07.017
Varghese, M., & Prabhakaran, T. V. (2025). Reconciling observed and predicted droplet concentration at the Indian summer monsoon cloud base. Science of The Total Environment, 973, 179077. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2025.179077
4 More details are needed for the methods section:
- Line 106-Line 108. Please clarify how the Nd data are sampled. From which part of the cloud? Are these measurements taken near the cloud base?
- Line 110, please explain how the filtering is done here.
- Please clarify the meaning of “aloft”.
- Does precipitation affect the measured aerosol size distribution, or has any filtering or screening been done?
- Many flight-segment examples are presented in Figures S3–S22. It would be helpful to include at least one example in the main text to illustrate how measurements from different flight segments and altitudes are combined for the analysis.
- Line 126, please clarify the meaning of the SCCN system or provide a reference.
- Line 158, are temperature and pressure also used as inputs?
Minor comments
Line 85, Figure 1. The schematic is somewhat confusing. First, aerosol activation primarily occurs within clouds, yet the figure seems to suggest that aerosols aloft are activated outside of clouds. Second, neither the ARG scheme nor the present study explicitly considers evaporation, yet it is labelled in the schematic. If the intention is to illustrate other relevant processes that are not considered in this study, then additional processes, such as entrainment, should also be included. Otherwise, I would suggest focusing the schematic on the processes actually represented in the study.
Line 98. FIMS is not introduced until line 103.
Line 153. Should this be Section 2.3?
Line 285, Section 3.3. In this section, only coupled cases are considered for ARG activation analysis, correct?
Line 210-214. In the figure, why is there a gap between the cloudy layer (gray shading) and the cloud base (dotted blue line)?
Line 266. How have the free-tropospheric entrainment cases been removed? My understanding is that free-tropospheric entrainment is a fundamental process in the marine boundary layer. (Wood, 2012)
Wood, R. (2012). Stratocumulus Clouds. Monthly Weather Review, 140(8), 2373–2423. https://doi.org/10.1175/MWR-D-11-00121.1
Line 289-290. Why are wintertime updraft velocities larger than summertime? Does this suggest that the low cloud population considered here has different cloud regimes?
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-6243-RC2
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 343 | 116 | 33 | 492 | 78 | 40 | 36 |
- HTML: 343
- PDF: 116
- XML: 33
- Total: 492
- Supplement: 78
- BibTeX: 40
- EndNote: 36
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Review of Clarifying the controlling factors of the seasonal variation of droplet concentrations in marine low-level clouds, by Liwen Wang et al.
This manuscript examines aircraft and ground-based aerosol and cloud observations close to the Eastern North Atlantic Ocean site on the Azores Islands and focuses on explaining summer/winter contrasts in aerosol concentrations and cloud droplet concentrations in warm marine low clouds that are prevalent there. The authors find that although total aerosol and CCN concentrations are 2-3 times larger during summer than winter, the droplet concentrations (Nd) are only about 50% higher during summer. The authors try to explain these contrasts using a widely used cloud droplet activation scheme (Abdul-Razzak and Ghan, ARG). The authors cannot explain the seasonal cycle of Nd when using the observed aerosol size distributions and composition at cloud base. Winter data are well predicted, but summertime Nd values are underpredicted by ARG by a factor of two in summer, even for coupled PBL cases. Thus, the model cannot really close the gap on explaining why the seasonal Nd cycle is so weak. The authors then go on to use the ARG scheme to try to explain the weaker seasonal contrasts in Nd. Because the authors are unable to explain the seasonal Nd cycle, the sensitivity studies seem far less compelling than they would have been if ARG was able to explain the contrast. As they are, the sensitivity studies imply that neither the higher updraft speeds in winter nor the hygroscopicity are relevant factors in the seasonal Nd cycle. I came away from reading the paper unclear what the main reason is for the weaker Nd contrast. The authors show that activation of Aitken particles in winter may increase the concentration of Nd during winter, but it is the summertime Nd estimates that are not explained by ARG.
My main concern is simply that if the model is unable to explain the behavior when fed with the appropriate seasonal information, then I am not convinced of the utility of the sensitivity studies. The authors should use a parcel model first to test if the ARG is behaving correctly. The work is detailed and the authors have done an excellent job of screening the data, including the PBL for decoupled and coupled cases, but the conclusions seem somewhat inconclusive as to what is driving the much weaker seasonal cycle in Nd than in total aerosol or CCN concentrations. Perhaps the authors need to revisit how they estimate updraft speeds and how they apply these to the ARG model. Are the pdfs used with ARG, or just mean values for each flight?
It is unclear if the authors are only considering coupled cases in the activation, or whether the activation scheme is applied flight by flight, whether it considers the pdf of updraft speed or just the flight mean, or the seasonal mean. More detail is needed. It is easy to get lost in the description.
The manuscript may be acceptable for publication following significant revisions.
MAJOR COMMENTS:
Line 187-189: The authors state "Although both summertime measured Nd and Nacc-A were higher on average, the seasonal contrast in measured Nd was much weaker than that in Nacc-A, consistent
with the results from Wang et al. (2022)." I immediately expected this to be followed by what was predicted by ARG, but these results are not presented. Instead, the authors explain a fit to the Nd-NaccA data that doesn't help me understand what ARG found for the seasonal contrast in Nd. This needs to be clarified. Based on Figure 5, I would say that the predicted ratio of summer:winter Nd is about a factor of 3, so essentially ARG is essentially completely unable to explain the summer-winter Nd contrasts. The authors need to be clear about this.
Line 249-251: There seems to be some misunderstanding about daytime decoupling in marine stratocumulus: "The low frequency of decoupled conditions in the aircraft dataset is likely attributed to the timing of flight operations, which were concentrated around local noon, when the MBL is typically well mixed". The stratocumulus-topped boundary layer is most decoupled during the day because shortwave absorption partly or totally offsets the negative buoyancy created by LW radiative cooling.
OTHER COMMENTS:
Line 23: The manuscript states that 75% of Aitken mode aerosol fail to reach the cloud layer. Yet my understanding is that Aitken mode aerosol sources are largely from the free troposphere, so how would decoupling lower down change that transport rate into the cloud layer?
Line 25: 56% is hardly "comparable". It is still a significant contrast.
Line 58: "insufficient" for what?
Line 60: "Activate all available particles". That almost never happens, because there are almost always small Aitken particles that do not activate.
Line 60-61: The references provided to support this statement are relatively new, but it has been known since Twomey (1959).
Line 110: According to Wang et al. (2021), this is the typical behavior, with the aerosol number concentration increasing with height above the PBL. Please provide more details. How many flights were excluded because of this criterion? What size range is assumed for the concentration?
Line 184. Uncertainty in N_acc,A is 96 /cm3, so we only need two significant figures at the most, i.e. 220 +/- 96 /cm3. Please correct throughout to improve readability (avoid including insignificant digits).
Line 347: I am confused. Even with all the measured aerosol properties, ARG is unable to represent summertime Nd. The cause of this bias is not explained at all. If the correct Nd cannot be achieved even when measuring all the inputs needed for the activation scheme, then something must be incorrect. What is incorrect?
Table S2: Particle hygroscopicity: Is this a separate CCN counter from the standard one that cycles through 5 or so supersaturations and intakes the ambient aerosol rather than a size-selection? If not, how much of the time is dedicated to these kappa-determining measurements?
References
Twomey, S. (1959). The nuclei of natural cloud formation part II: The supersaturation in natural clouds and the variation of cloud droplet concentration. Geofisica Pura e Applicata, 43(1), 243–249. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01993560.
Wang, Y., Zheng, G., Jensen, M. P., Knopf, D. A., Laskin, A., Matthews, A. A., Mechem, D., Mei, F., Moffet, R., Sedlacek, A. J., Shilling, J. E., Springston, S., Sullivan, A., Tomlinson, J., Veghte, D., Weber, R., Wood, R., Zawadowicz, M. A., & Wang, J. (2021). Vertical profiles of trace gas and aerosol properties over the eastern North Atlantic: Variations with season and synoptic condition. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 21(14), 11079–11098. https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-21-11079-2021