Wet Cyclone Sampling for Time-Resolved Molecular Analysis of Organic Aerosols: Performance Evaluation and Application to Incense Smoke
Abstract. This study was motivated by the need for a practical alternative to conventional filter sampling that retains its ease of field deployment while providing improved temporal resolution. A condensational growth wet cyclone sampler was developed and characterized for time-resolved collection of organic aerosols and coupled with liquid chromatography mass spectrometry for molecular analysis of aerosol composition. The sampler combines the condensational growth chamber of a particle-into-liquid sampler with a miniature wet cyclone, where the grown droplets are collected by centrifugal deposition into a continuously wetted liquid vortex. Collection performance of the sampler was optimized using polydisperse oleic acid particles as a representative of water-insoluble organic aerosols. Under optimized conditions, the collection efficiency of oleic acid particles reached 64.5±8.3%, with remaining losses attributed primarily to liquid entrainment into the gas exhaust and compound-specific retention within the collection pathway. Collection efficiency was relatively insensitive to the initial particle size distribution over the range examined, as condensational growth produced droplets sufficiently large for effective cyclone collection. The sampler was subsequently applied to incense smoke, where its recovery of molecular components was compared with conventional filter sampling under the same mass-spectrometric analysis. The cyclone samples captured major molecular features observed in paired filter samples and also recovered molecules extending to relatively high carbon numbers. Sequential collection further resolved the temporal evolution of particulate diethyl phthalate, a major component of incense smoke. These results demonstrate that the condensational growth wet cyclone broadens liquid-based collection to a wider range of particle-phase constituents and provides an accessible interface for time-resolved molecular characterization of organic aerosols.
The manuscript presents the development and characterization of a condensational-growth wet cyclone sampler for the collection of organic aerosols and subsequent molecular analysis by liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (LC/MS). The proposed instrument combines condensational particle growth with centrifugal collection into a continuously supplied washing liquid. This setup offers an alternative to conventional filter-based sampling. The authors systematically examine the effects of sampling flow rate, washing-liquid composition, and aerosol physicochemical properties on collection efficiency and show the instrument's applicability using incense-burning aerosols. The study is relevant to Atmospheric Measurement Techniques. The experimental characterization is generally comprehensive, and the results provide useful insights into the operating conditions and limitations of the proposed instrument. Several aspects of the methodology and interpretation would benefit from further clarification. In particular, the definition of collection efficiency, the representativeness of the selected model compounds, the relationship between sampling conditions and analytical sensitivity, and the interpretation of the comparison with filter sampling should be addressed before publication.
Major comments:
Minor comments: