A response of the polar winter upper mesosphere to short-period solar variations
Abstract. Effects of short-period variations in the flux of solar UV radiation on the intensity of airglow emissions coming from the hydroxyl (OH) airglow layer and temperature variations in the upper mesosphere over Kiruna, Sweden, have been investigated. Measurements were performed with the OH airglow imager, measuring selected emission lines in the OH(3-1) Meinel band. Measurements for four winter seasons from 2022 to 2026 have been considered. Solar activity is represented by diurnal flux changes in the Lyman alpha (α) line. It has been shown that short-period changes in the Lyman–α flux lead to statistically significant changes in the temperature and intensity of OH(3-1) emissions with a positive response and with about zero time delay (0–5 days). This result indicates the dominance of the mechanisms of direct radiative and photochemical influence of Lyman–α on change in the physical-chemical state of the polar winter upper mesosphere. Average temperature amplitudes due to short-period changes in the Lyman–α flux are approximately 2–4 K, which are comparable in magnitude to temperature variations due to atmospheric planetary waves. A relationship has been found between characteristic features of the power spectrum of the Lyman–α flux and the time delay in the mesospheric response at time intervals of about 4–6 months.
Review report on the manuscript "A response of the polar winter upper mesosphere to short-period solar variations" by Peter Dalin et al.
This work examines the relationship between short-term fluctuations in the solar ultraviolet flux and the intensity of the OH* layer, as well as the temperature in the vicinity of this layer. Observations were carried out using a ground-based instrument for imaging airglow. The authors found that short-period variations in the Lyman-α flux lead to statistically significant changes in temperature and in the intensity of OH(3-1) emission, with a positive correlation. The amplitudes of temperature fluctuations caused by short-period (27-day) variations in the Lyman-α flux are ~2–4 K.
The paper is well written. The introduction is informative. In my opinion, the proposed method is sound, the analysis has been carried out appropriately, and the authors’ conclusions are well-founded. The study is of scientific value. In my view, the article will provide a deeper understanding of the processes involved in the formation of the thermal regime in the mesopause region and will provide the knowledge necessary to understand the variability of the OH* layer.
I found this article interesting to read, and I recommend it for publication in the journal Annales Geophysicae once answers to a few important questions have been provided.
Main questions.
The negative relation between Layman-alpha flux and altitude of OH* layer has been found recently, based on global 3D model simulations (Figure 13, Grygalashvyly et al., 2014). In winter season the mesopause temperature minimum at high and mid latitudes is placed above OH* layer and, in general case, in the vicinity of OH* layer temperature has negative vertical gradient. Consequently, downward shift of OH* layer due to increase of Layman-alpha flux may result in positive effect in temperature observed by ground based airglow measurements.
Could it be that positive relation between short-term solar variation and temperature, discussed in the paper is partially or completely the result of such effect?
The authors go on to write (lines 292-302): “Variations of the regression coefficient for the winter of 2022-2023 have a complex (non-harmonic) form, but a basic period of about 9 days can be traced (Fig. 7A). This period is absent in both the temperature spectrum and the Lyα spectrum (Fig. 5A). The regression coefficient variation for the winter of 2023-2024 also has a complex form, with a major period of approximately 12-13 days (Fig. 7B). This period is absent in both the temperature spectrum and the Lyα spectrum (Fig. 5B). The regression coefficient period for the winter of 2024-2025 is 18-19 days (Fig. 7C). This period is absent in both the temperature spectrum and the Lyα spectrum (Fig. 5C). The period of the regression coefficient for the winter of 2025-2026 is 19-20 days (Fig. 7D). This period is also absent in both the temperature spectrum and the Lyα spectrum (Fig. 5D). All these results mean that such periods in the regression analysis are created by the "interaction" of eigen periods in the temperature and Lyα flux.”
Could it be that such “artificial” periods are the result of superposition of direct effect of layman-alpha flux on temperature and observed temperature variation due to variation of OH* layer altitude (please note that such effect may come with delay of order couple of days, that is related to photo-chemical lifetime of atomic oxygen in the vicinity of OH* layer)?
Minor Comments.
Line 94. “red dotted line” -> red dashed line
References
Grygalashvyly M., Sonnemann G. R., Lübken F.-J., Hartogh P., Berger U. (2014), Hydroxyl layer: Mean state and trends at midlatitudes. J. Geophys. Res., 119:12391–12419. https://doi.org/10.1002/2014J D0220 94