the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Assessment of the PACE/SPEXone Aerosol Layer Height (ALH) Retrievals and Intercomparison with EarthCARE/ATLID Observations
Abstract. Here, we present the first evaluation of the PACE/SPEXone aerosol layer height (ALH) products over oceanic regions, assessing retrievals from the two independent algorithms and their products, RemoTAP and FastMAPOL, against aerosol layer heights derived from EarthCARE/ATLID. The ATLID aerosol layer heights are calculated using a center-of-mass (COM) approach applied to aerosol extinction profiles. The selected oceanic regions provide insight on the PACE/SPEXone ALH retrieval performance, highlighting its sensitivity to the aerosol optical depth (AOD) loading and the aerosol vertical structure. Better agreement is observed over the Mediterranean region, where dust and mixed-dust aerosol types dominate. The RemoTAP and FastMAPOL retrievals show correlation coefficients of R = 0.30 and R = 0.60, with corresponding mean absolute errors of 1.12 and 1.07 km, respectively. Conversely, weaker correlations are found over the South Atlantic and Indian Ocean regions. Overall, global statistics indicate moderate agreement between SPEXone and ATLID ALH products, showing the dependence on the aerosol vertical distribution. We conclude that improved consistency is found for cases with strong agreement between SPEXone and EarthCARE AOD retrievals, particularly under higher aerosol loading conditions (AOD > 0.1). We further examine the impact of different ALH definitions by applying alternative Gaussian-fit approaches to the ATLID profiles, which leads to a slight improvement in the agreement between active and passive ALH estimates.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of Atmospheric Measurement Techniques.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.- Preprint
(2921 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 18 Nov 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5990', Anonymous Referee #1, 12 Nov 2026 reply
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 369 | 178 | 35 | 582 | 41 | 35 |
- HTML: 369
- PDF: 178
- XML: 35
- Total: 582
- BibTeX: 41
- EndNote: 35
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
The study by Voudouri et al. presents a comparison of aerosol layer height (ALH) retrievals from PACE/SPEXone, using the two algorithms FastMAPOL and RemoTAP, against EarthCARE/ATLID observations over oceanic regions. It also introduces an ATLID-modified ALH to better resemble the SPEXone retrievals. This represents the first validation effort of an ALH retrieval from a passive sensor using ATLID lidar measurements and serves as a successor to previous CALIPSO-based studies. The results indicate a better agreement over the Mediterranean region associated with the higher aerosol content, particularly for the FastMAPOL retrievals.
The manuscript is well written and falls within the scope of the journal. However, I would appreciate clarification on a few points that, in my opinion, would further improve the paper. Specific comments and technical corrections are provided below for the authors' consideration.
General comments
As a general comment, I would advise the authors to increase the resolution of the figures and follow the journal guidelines for the acronyms.
L32: It is worth mentioning other techniques for the estimation of the ALH (e.g., aerosol scale height; Winker et al., 2013 - ACP) when using active sensors. Also, please refer to studies that use the same method although named differently. For instance, Koffi et al. (2012 - JGR) use the mean extinction height, Xu et al. (2019 - Geophys. Res. Lett.) aerosol centroid altitude, and Yao et al. (2018 - RSE) minimum aerosol height.
L59: Explain the difference between ALD and EBD products.
L151-152: Are you planning to assess ALH over land? Are there references discussing the effect?
L157, Figure1: Does the Mediterranean domain contain overpasses over land?
L166-168: Please expand on the filtering. What is the motivation? On which dataset is applied?
L181, Equation1: Explain the variables.
L185-186: “…that fits …observations.” It is incomprehensible.
L213, Figure2: Are the circles off the SPEXone grid the effect of the +-50 km corridor? Please explain.
L260-261: Is this filter applied to SPEXone and ATLID? When this filter is invoked, how do the metrics change? Of what origin are these layers for the case of ATLID? If I understand correctly, for ATLID it is not a retrieval error and that the ALH is pushed that high because of stratospheric activity. Do you think to apply a dynamic filter instead of a hard cutoff limit? For instance, disregard aerosol layers that are isolated.
L268: Give a reference for the Bland-Altman analysis.
L280, Figure4: What does the dashed line represent?
L304, Figure6: It seems that global statistics shown in Figure 3 are driven by the Mediterranean domain as they present similar values in the metrics considered. Why is this happening?
L335-342: The central panels do not report the target classification. Please correct. Also, there are no red/blue/green circles in the figure. You use different symbols.
L406: What do you mean by “true layer centre”? Is it the geometric centre?
L410: The agreement over the Mediterranean is better for ATLID-RTAP (0.48 km) even though minimally better when comparing with Indian Ocean (0.5 km) but this not the case for ATLID-MAPOL (0.46 km). The ATLID-MAPOL performance for South Atlantic (0.4 km) and Indian Ocean (0.25 km) is better. Can you please clarify?
Technical comments
Line18: Change products to product
Line19: Remove “and their products”
Line20: Change aerosol layer heights to ALH. Be consistent with the abbreviations throughout the text.
Line21: Better “insight into”
Line 22: Remove loading
Line42: Better rephrase “passive retrieval techniques”.
Line55: Lidar appears 2 times.
Line408: Remove “;”.