the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
ERF-SDM Simulations of a Convection Cloud Chamber: Model Development, Benchmark Evaluation, and Aerosol-Cloud-Turbulence Interactions
Abstract. Convection cloud chambers provide a unique platform for investigating aerosol cloud turbulence interactions under well controlled laboratory conditions and for evaluating numerical cloud microphysics models. This study extends the Energy Research and Forecasting model coupled with the Super Droplet Method (ERF-SDM) to simulate statistically stationary cloud chamber experiments through the implementation of Monin Obukhov similarity theory on all chamber walls, continuous aerosol injection, and wall deposition of super droplets. The model is evaluated using the recent Pi Chamber benchmark configuration from the cloud chamber modeling community and laboratory measurements from the Michigan Technological University Pi Chamber. ERF-SDM successfully represents characteristic chamber circulation and qualitative aerosol-dependent microphysical responses under the prescribed boundary conditions. Process-oriented analyses show that increasing aerosol injection strongly reduces mean and root-mean-square supersaturation, with most of the adjustment occurring between injection rates of 1 and 50 cm⁻³ min⁻¹. Higher injection rates also produce smaller cloud droplets and narrower droplet size distributions. However, the spatial standard deviation of supersaturation does not decrease monotonically, indicating that regulation of the mean thermodynamic state is not accompanied by a corresponding reduction in centered spatial variability. The simulations further demonstrate a transition from an aerosol limited regime at low aerosol injection rates to a vapor limited regime at higher aerosol loading, where competition for available water vapor increasingly limits aerosol activation. These results demonstrate that ERF-SDM, with the new cloud chamber capabilities, can effectively simulate laboratory cloud chamber experiments and investigate the coupled interactions among turbulence, supersaturation fluctuations, aerosol activation, and cloud microphysical evolution, providing valuable insights for understanding aerosol and cloud interactions in Earth system models.
- Preprint
(6201 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 04 Dec 2026)
-
CEC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5922 - No compliance with the policy of the journal', Juan Antonio Añel, 30 Oct 2026
reply
-
AC1: 'Reply on CEC1', Jungmin Lee, 10 Nov 2026
reply
Thank you for brining this to our attention. However, the manuscript does contain Code and data availability section. I added the Zenodo location where the code can be obtained. Please let me know if there's anything else I need to do.
Best regards,
Jungmin
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-5922-AC1 -
CEC2: 'Reply on AC1', Juan Antonio Añel, 11 Nov 2026
reply
Dear authors,
Thanks for the reply. The title of the section mentions data, but neither the section nor the repository cited contain the data used and produced in your work, which it must contain. Therefore you have to reply to this comment with a repository that contains all the data used and produced in your work. Citations to published papers that do not contain repositories that comply with the policy of Geosci. Model Dev. (please, check it) are not acceptable. This refers specifically to the:
- Pi Chamber drop size distributions, 18 K case from Prabhakaran et al., 2020.
- Pi Chamber droplet number and mean radius vs. aerosol concentration from Anderson et al., 2024.
- Measured 2D TKE from Thomas et al., 2019.
- Multi-model benchmark results from Chen et al., 2025.
- Input files for every run reported. This means the full configuration and namelists, initial conditions, boundary conditions and aerosol injection settings.
- Output files for all the model runs presented in the manuscript.
Therefore, please, reply to this comment as soon as possible with the requested information. I must insist that we can not have papers in Discussions that do not comply with the policy of the journal.
Juan A. Añel
Geosci. Model Dev. Executive Editor
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-5922-CEC2
-
CEC2: 'Reply on AC1', Juan Antonio Añel, 11 Nov 2026
reply
-
AC1: 'Reply on CEC1', Jungmin Lee, 10 Nov 2026
reply
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5922', Anonymous Referee #1, 06 Nov 2026
reply
This study modified ERF-SDM to simulate the Pi Cloud Chamber. The simulated mean cloud properties vary systematically with the aerosol injection rate, consistent with previous studies. The simulations also show a transition from an aerosol-limited to a vapor-limited regime as the injection rate increases. The authors conclude that ERF-SDM is capable of simulating a convection cloud chamber and could provide valuable insights for understanding aerosol–cloud interactions in Earth system models.
Overall, I appreciate the first effort to apply ERF-SDM to simulate a cloud chamber. However, many of the results reproduce findings from previous studies, and it is not yet clear in the current manuscript what new capabilities or insights ERF-SDM offers. The manuscript would be stronger if the authors highlighted some new features of ERF-SDM. One idea is to add an analysis of the side wall losses of droplets (see my major comment below). I recommend major revision before the manuscript can be considered for publication in GMD.
Major comments:
1. Aerosol–cloud interactions in the Pi Cloud Chamber have been studied extensively over the past decade through laboratory experiments, theory, and numerical simulations. The authors cite several of these studies, but a few highly relevant ones are missing. Krueger (2020) derived the equilibrium droplet size distribution in the chamber, a result that can explain how the size distribution changes with aerosol injection rate. Shaw et al. (2023) developed a minimalist model of cloudy Rayleigh–Bénard convection that can predict how cloud properties (e.g., droplet number concentration, droplet radius, and supersaturation) change with the aerosol injection rate. Most directly relevant is Yang et al. (2025), who conducted large-eddy simulations of the Pi Cloud Chamber over a wide range of aerosol injection rates and reported the changes in cloud properties with aerosol injection rates (see their Figs. 1–3). Fahandezh Sadi et al. (2026) discussed in detail how aerosol activation is limited in the vapor-limited regime, consistent with the conclusion of this study (e.g., lns571-573).
Reference:
Krueger, Steven K. "Equilibrium droplet size distributions in a turbulent cloud chamber with uniform supersaturation." Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics 20, no. 13 (2020): 7895-7909.
Shaw, Raymond A., Subin Thomas, Prasanth Prabhakaran, Will Cantrell, Mikhail Ovchinnikov, and Fan Yang. "Fast and slow microphysics regimes in a minimalist model of cloudy Rayleigh-Bénard convection." Physical Review Research 5, no. 4 (2023): 043018.
Yang, Fan, Hamed Fahandezh Sadi, Raymond A. Shaw, Fabian Hoffmann, Pei Hou, Aaron Wang, and Mikhail Ovchinnikov. "Microphysics regimes due to haze–cloud interactions: Cloud oscillation and cloud collapse." Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics 25, no. 6 (2025): 3785-3806.
Fahandezh Sadi, Hamed, Ernie R. Lewis, Kadja Flore Gali, Fan Yang, Jesse Anderson, Suryadev Pratap Singh, Jae Min Yeom, Will Cantrell, and Raymond A. Shaw. "Large aerosol particles favor haze conditions through limitations on water budget and activation kinetics." Geophysical Research Letters 53, no. 1 (2026): e2025GL117310.
2. Because this topic has been explored extensively in recent years (see my previous comment), many results in this study reproduce findings in previous studies. This is not a criticism in itself, but it means the paper would be strengthened if the authors highlighted what is new about ERF-SDM. One feature that stands out to me is that the model can simulate droplet loss to the sidewalls. To my knowledge, many previous simulations of the Pi Cloud Chamber assume reflective boundary conditions. It would be very useful if the authors can quantify the droplet loss rate to each sidewall and compared them with the loss rate to the bottom surface under different conditions. Such an analysis would be a valuable contribution to this field.
3. Fig 6 is very confusing. Fig 6c shows that the mean supersaturation reaches a constant over 1% when the injection rate is larger than 100 cm-3 min-1. In contrast, all simulations in Chen et al. (2025) with the same model setup as in this study show that the mean supersaturation is below 1% under those conditions. Please check your simulation results.
4. Why does σ_s depend on the injection rate under pre-cloud conditions (blue line) in Fig.6d? Since aerosol injection has not yet started, I would expect σ_s to be independent of the injection rate. Ln 376 “Cloudy-period values exceeded their corresponding pre-cloud values in all cases and showed no monotonic decrease with increasing injection rate”. Fig 6d shows an increasing trend of σ_s with aerosol injection rate, not “no monotonic decrease” trend. The statement in the abstract “the spatial standard derivation of supersaturation does not decrease monotonically” is also confusing.
Other comments:
1. Sec 2.2.1. Is the calculation of the sidewall fluxes similar to that in Thomas et al. (2019)? If so, please state this explicitly. If not, please explain how the approach differs from previous studies.
2. Ln 220. “monodisperse dry NaCl… continuously injected into each cell…” How frequently are new superdroplets injected? Are they injected at every time step? How many superdroplets are injected each time, e.g., one or several per grid cell?
3. Fig 1a and b. Why temperature and qv (thin line) show fluctuates at high frequency (about 2 min?)? Any explanations?
4. Fig 1,3,4,5. I suggest using a legend to show the injection rate for each line. It is difficult to read exact values from the color bar.
5. Fig 4a. Add the unit of injection rate in the legend.
6. Fig 5. Cite the source of the Pi Cloud Chamber measurements in the figure caption.
7. “(not shown)” appears twice in the paper (Ln 216, 381). Please consider adding these results to an appendix or the supplement, or rephrase those sentences.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-5922-RC1 -
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5922', Anonymous Referee #2, 14 Nov 2026
reply
Please se attached review.
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 403 | 158 | 42 | 603 | 38 | 34 |
- HTML: 403
- PDF: 158
- XML: 42
- Total: 603
- BibTeX: 38
- EndNote: 34
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Dear authors,
Unfortunately, after checking your manuscript, it has come to our attention that it does not comply with our "Code and Data Policy".
https://www.geoscientific-model-development.net/policies/code_and_data_policy.html
Namely, your manuscript does not contain a Data Availability section. The GMD review and publication process depends on reviewers and community commentators being able to access, during the discussion phase, the code and data on which a manuscript depends, and on ensuring the provenance of replicability of the published papers for years after their publication. Please, therefore, publish all the data used to produce your work in one of the appropriate repositories and reply to this comment with the relevant information (link and a permanent identifier for it (e.g. DOI)) as soon as possible. We cannot have manuscripts under discussion that do not comply with our policy.
Later, if the Topical Editor decides to continue with the review or publication process of your manuscript and you are requested to upload a new version of it, then Data Availability section must be included citing the repository locations, and corresponding references added to the bibliography.
I must note that if you do not fix this problem, we cannot continue with the peer-review process or accept your manuscript for publication in GMD.
Juan A. Añel
Geosci. Model Dev. Executive Editor