Near-tree soil footprints show higher organic carbon and lower bulk density with no detectable end-of-summer moisture penalty
Abstract. Scattered trees can create fine-scale surface soil enrichment, but it is unclear how far these patterns extend through the mineral soil profile, translate into carbon stocks, and influence moisture content. We quantified the soil functional footprint of 14 established trees from four contrasting cohorts in an arboretum–grassland system under a Mediterranean climate in South Australia. Soil was sampled at 1, 2, 4 and 8 m from each stem at depth intervals to 30 cm. Directly measured surface bulk density was lower at 1, 2 and 4 m than at 8 m, while soil organic carbon (SOC) concentration was 30% higher at 1 m and declined by 8% with each doubling of distance. Total nitrogen, nitrate-N and Colwell-extractable P also varied with distance, whereas gravimetric moisture did not decline towards the trees under the end-of-summer conditions sampled. Distance × tree cohort interactions were not significant for these principal responses. After accounting for depth and tree identity, distance explained 3% of joint soil property variation whereas depth explained 39%. On an equivalent-soil-mass basis, SOC stock at 1 m distance from the tree exceeded that at 8 m by 16.5 Mg C ha⁻¹, although the categorical fixed-depth 0–30 cm SOC-stock test was not significant. Within the radially-weighted 0-8 m footprint, we combined two carbon pools, model-assisted mineral-soil SOC and current projected whole-tree carbon. Together these amounted to 67.4–123.2 Mg C ha⁻¹, with mineral-soil SOC accounting for 59–89% of this combined soil tree total. These results identify a shared, property-specific radial soil footprint characterised by lower bulk density and higher carbon and nutrient concentrations without a detectable dry-season moisture penalty. They also demonstrate why depth resolution, soil mass correction and radial area weighting are essential when converting near-tree enrichment into spatially explicit carbon accounting and monitoring. Because the near-tree zone retained higher carbon and nutrients without an end-of-summer moisture penalty, established trees may support understorey forage production and its resilience under increasing aridity rather than imposing a dry-season water cost.
Comments on “Near-tree soil footprints show higher organic carbon and lower bulk density with no detectable end-of-summer moisture penalty”
The manuscript evaluates the influence of trees in soil properties, mainly bulk density, carbon and nitrogen stocks. It compares two different ways of calculating carbon stocks to adequately represent the tree influence on this parameter. The study addresses the tree influence on soil properties with a high spatial resolution in a Mediterranean arboretum with grassland understory.
While the design is innovative and relevant and the manuscript fits within the journal’s scope, the text itself needs some revisions. In general, the use of overstatements and unsuitable adjectives across the text should be addressed (e.g. speaking of “causal species effects” when the maximum number of trees per species is 2; why not just call it “species effects”?).
Terms from repeated measures and split-plot design are mixed in the text. While these designs might be evaluated using similar models, the terms should still be separated and not used interchangeably. Therefore, I would recommend a thorough revision of the statistics section and a detailed check for the correct terminology. Further, more detailed questions and unclear points in the statistics are listed below.
While the manuscript does not provide relevant information like the height and crown geometry of the trees in the sample, the discussion of a relatively simple and well-researched phenomenon (the decrease of bulk density with increasing soil organic carbon) takes up extensive space in the discussion. I would recommend to work through the manuscript, highlighting the relevant points and shortening the ones that are not unique to this study.
The use of the term “8 m reference” should be critically assessed and revised. Given the fact that litter was collected and analysed at 8 m, it can hardly be a reference without tree influence. Finding a point with no tree influence will likely be impossible in an arboretum. I therefore suggest to remove the term “reference”, unless this is a true reference with no tree influence whatsoever.
The presentation of the water content should be tempered or completely removed as it holds no information about actual soil water dynamics in this system. Detailed comments below.
Detailed comments:
L13 – please consider mentioning the depth interval breaks in the Abstract
L17 – see comments on water content below. I would be cautious in using a single measurement from the very dry range of the soil water retention curve to prove this point. Here, it is evident that the soil is dry at every point sampled in this study, but there is no information on (differences during) the drying process at the sampling points. These differences would be much more meaningful than a soil water content measurement close to the permanent wilting point at the end of the dry season, when the soil is dry at every point.
L27 – “without a detectable dry season moisture penalty” – there is no penalty because there is simply no moisture left in the soil at any of the sampled points & depths; please avoid over-interpretation of one single measurement at the very dry range of the pF curve
L32 – please consider adding “in the topsoil” in the last sentence.
L96 – please note that soil water deficit should be assessed based on the matric potential, not based on the soil water content. This is an important point to mention, but it cannot be directly transferred to the volumetric water contents measured in this study.
L158 – please mention the sampled depth combinations before mentioning the pooling of subsamples in distance x depth combinations
L159 – why “repeated sampling”? – as far as I can see, four replicates were taken and pooled to avoid spatial autocorrelation across depths within one sample. Please check the terminology if “repeated sampling” is the correct term to use here. Furthermore, in e.g. Fig 2 the distances are referred to as “split-plots”. Please note that these are two different designs. Please avoid mixing the terminology from these two different designs.
L163 – Why “primary surface bulk density”? Why not just “bulk density”?
Statistics:
L298 - The design of the present study is not balanced (3 or 4 trees per cohort). Was this accounted for when calculating the ANOVA? Please add this information in the text (whether summed contrasts were used to account for the unbalanced design).
Please make sure to explain the calculation of fixed-depth as well as equivalent soil mass stocks briefly in the materials and methods section. Right now, it is hard to understand that two calculation approaches are applied, as the fixed depth calculation is explained in great detail and the equivalent soil mass is not mentioned explicitly in M&M.
L297 – split-plot (without “repeated measures” in brackets) is clear enough; What I understand based on the description: tree is treated as random effect; tree is nested in cohort. Strictly speaking, the distances at each tree within each cohort are the sub-plots (of the split-plot design), while the cohort is the main plot. I would recommend sticking to the terminology of one design and not use terms from repeated measures and split-plot studies interchangeably.
L316 – “planned distance contrasts” does not encompass correcting for the unbalanced number of trees per cohort by adjusting the contrast matrix, right? Please make this a part of the ANOVA
L321 – What do you mean by “distance conclusions”?
L349 – please be consistent with the abbreviation for bulk density (BD vs. rho_b in the supplement, and the units)
L518 – The equivalent soil mass was calculated for 0-5 an 5.10 cm, right? I could not find how equivalent soil mass carbon storage was calculated in the M&M section. Please add this information and distinguish clearly between the two calculation methods
Figure 6 – I do have bad eyesight, but the axis labels should still be bigger.
L602ff – is there a citation to support this?
L611 and following – I agree that the soil moisture dynamic in this system is highly interesting. However, data from one sampling campaign at the dry end of the pF curve hold only limited information about the spatial and temporal soil moisture dynamic and plant water extraction (water basically does not move in the soil once it is so dry; furthermore, it is impossible to determine if the water was taken up by the tree, the understory or has evaporated). I would therefore suggest to temper the argument that is based on one sampling time close to the permanent wilting point of your soil and highlight the need for further research in the topics mentioned on the text.
In terms of the vertical comparison of soil moisture: I think the water contents are difficult to interpret in terms of plant-available water due to the texture change in the subsoil. The difference between cohorts is very interesting!
L667 – Please supply the information on the “ecological context” like tree age, height, canopy diameter in the Material and methods section.
General: Missing information is the discussion:
L702 – I doubt that sampling up to a depth of 30 cm covers the whole picture of carbon input by trees. What about root exudates and subsoil carbon storage?
L713 – “.” At the end of the line
L730 – Given that litter was found and analysed at 8 m distance, I do not think that the 8 m position can be treated as reference (given that you mean “no tree influence” when speaking of reference). Please define “reference” and be more concise, and supply the missing information on tree height and age and crown geometry in M&M.
L731 ff – While important to cover, the discussion of the experimental design could be shortened
L769 – I would be careful in using the term “repeated observations”. This is a single sampling campaign where replicates in the four cardinal directions where pooled for each distance (this is what I understood, please correct me if I’m wrong). Repeated observations would mean that the same location was sampled multiple times. Distance is a fixed factor and therefore not a “repetition” within the tree. Maybe use “vertical depth variation and distance were accounted for” to describe the study (?).
L780 – The absence of a dry season moisture penalty is due to the fact that there is no water left in the soil at any place. (discussed above). Please revise this part.