the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Organic matter as a driver of Fe(II) oxidation and persistence in the central Arctic Ocean and the Barents Sea: Implications for Marine Biogeochemistry
Abstract. This study examines how variations in organic matter sources and composition regulate Fe(II) oxidation dynamics in the central Arctic Ocean and the Barents Sea, two contrasting Arctic marine environments. Pseudo-first-order Fe(II) oxidation rate constants (log k′) deviated substantially from values predicted with the same pH, temperature, and oxygen conditions, indicating strong environmental control on Fe(II) reactivity. Under reference conditions (pH = 8, T = 15 °C, and oxygen saturation), the calculated Fe(II) half-life was 14.21 min, whereas experimentally determined half-life ranged from 0.76 to 14.7 min in the central Arctic Ocean and from 0.77 to 20.14 min in the Barents Sea. Experimental and tcalculated data yielded a standard error in log k′ of ±0.229 min⁻¹, corresponding to a half-life uncertainty of less than 1 min. The Fe(II) half-life directly reflects oxidation kinetics and constrains Fe(II) persistence, with implications for trace metal speciation and redox cycling.
Partial least squares regression (PLSR) analysis of samples from the Central Arctic station revealed significant associations (R² = 0.38, p < 0.05) between residual Fe(II) oxidation variability (Δk′) and humic-like organic matter, dissolved organic carbon (DOC), silicic acid, salinity, and nitrate, highlighting the combined influence of interrelated environmental factors on Fe(II) oxidation dynamics. Spatial variability in Fe(II) persistence across basins and depth profiles is attributed to differences in organic matter characteristics associated with distinct water masses.
- Preprint
(2512 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 02 Dec 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5751', Anonymous Referee #1, 11 Nov 2026 reply
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5751', Anonymous Referee #2, 12 Nov 2026
reply
This is an interesting study of Fe(II) oxidation kinetics in Arctic waters that focuses on how organic matter changes oxidation rates. Two types of experiments were undertaken – the first looked at changes in rates as a function of temperature and pH, the second type of experiment determined oxidation rates at constant pH and temperature in order to probe how DOM composition/sources influence oxidation rates.
The major strength in the study was that PLSR identified humic like material and DOC as parameters that influenced oxidation rates. This conclusion seemed to be robust with the interpretation supported by the results. However, I thought the manuscript would benefit from improved presentation of the results. For example, the column plots were not so clear, with similar colours used for multiple columns, so that it was hard to identify the trends being described and discussed. Furthermore, although the water masses and the PLSR seemed quite an integral part of the study, no data was presented (e.g. in table or figure form) that clearly compiled these results.
The first set of experiments (pH/T) were not discussed and I thought in general there was some slippage between results and discussion sections. Revisiting the results sections to check for points of discussion would therefore be a good idea.
Further minor comments
Line 24 Typo
Line 260: and temperature.
Line 261-264. Comparison of calculated and experimental slopes at different temperature 15°C: It is quite hard to see the similarities or differences from the plot – a table of slopes might help clearly show the points described. How was the similarity tested?
Fig 2B legend – is “Cal-G-S2020 pH 8 the calculation with Eq 5? It would be good to be consistent with notations.
Line 269: any given temperature?
Line 278: Is the acronym Ea defined? And Arrhenius equation could be shown for completeness.
Fig. 3. Is there a reason this plot is not shown in a more traditional depth profile format? It also looks like the same data is shown in Fig 3a and b, but a different colour scheme is used for the two plots, which could be confusing. Repeated use of the same colour for different depths is also confusing – especially since not all depths were sampled at each station. Maybe add to the caption that pH and temperature were kept constant for all the experiments as a reminder to the reader.
Line 295: “exhibited significant variation”. No statistical support was provided to show the significance of the variability. Could just replace these terms with “varied” since the ranges in each region are stated in the next sentence
Line 315-317. I was expecting more information about how the position of the station and the hydrography impact DOM composition and Fe(II) after this sentence – but I think this sentence actually belongs in the discussion.
Line 305-324: This discussion might benefit from a better characterization of the water masses. Maybe there is already an OMPA of the study region the authors could tap into to help bin the depths and stations into water masses? Or perhaps a T-S diagram would help contextualise this paragraph.
Line 322: “In deeper waters the decrease is observed to be higher”. This is a confusing sentence and needs quantifying.
Line 337: Would be good to see the evidence for the coastal currents (e.g. T-S diagram, salinity & temp profiles in SI)
Line 338 “The” should be “Station”. Please show the evidence for this statement, or provide numbers in the text.
Line 350: Not clear to me what is “obvious”. Is it that all the DOM parameters exhibit similar distributions or is it that the oxidation kinetics are reflected in the distributions of the DOM parameters. The choice of a column plot to show these relationships also limits my ability to assess the veracity of this statement.
Figure 5. Explain what P/V is in the caption.
Line 378. Don’t start a sentence with an acronym.
Line 384. Could do with a citation here.
Section 4.1. I think the discussion here could be helped by reference to the actual T-S conditions observed on the cruise, or, even better, an OMPA analysis.
Line 440. Missing “the”
Line 451-452: Two “Barents Sea” in the same sentence.
Line 453. Missing “the” or rearrange sentence to eliminate “those”.
Line 456. Rephrase “CDOM origin of autochthonous characteristics”.
Line 486. Fe(III) binding to organic matter also keeps Fe in solution. Do the authors mean thereby preventing or inhibiting oxidation?
Line 485 onwards. I think it would be clearer if discussion on oxidation rates was clearly separated from discussion of the oxidation rate constant.
Line 507-511. Most likely the detection window constrained logK.
Line 519. Equation 15 is unclear to me. It is also unclear how equation 15 is an improvement on equation 2. I also don’t think that this equation properly represents the heterogeneity of the system. Both terrestrial and marine pools will be highly heterogeneous.
Line 549-555. Put all the correlations in a table so it is easy to see which parameters correlated and which not.
Line 583. I think CDOM does not detect all organics because of interferences from inorganic ions like nitrate.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-5751-RC2
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 200 | 111 | 30 | 341 | 28 | 30 |
- HTML: 200
- PDF: 111
- XML: 30
- Total: 341
- BibTeX: 28
- EndNote: 30
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
General comments:
The paper addresses the effect of different sources of dissolved organic matter on the oxidation rate of Fe(II), which is relevant in order to understand how the proximity of ocean waters to terrestrial organic matter sources may alter the chemical speciation and bioavailability of Fe which is an essential micronutrient for ocean primary productivity.
The novelty is primarily from the location of these measurements and the combined analysis of Fe(II) oxidation rates alongside dissolved organic matter (DOM) characterisation. The different Arctic ocean basins examined are an important area to study with regards to the impact of different DOM sources on marine chemistry due to the variety of new and aged terrestrial inputs along with DOM formed in the marine environment. The wide range of DOM inputs into the different ocean basins makes this setting a useful testing ground to study the effect of DOM on oxidation rates of Fe(II).
The main conclusion from this work is that terrestrial DOM speeds up Fe(II) oxidation whereas marine DOM slows oxidation rates. The implications are that Fe(II) will be oxidised faster in ocean basins and/or coastal waters that receive higher concentrations of terrestrial DOM.
All methods and the experimental set-up are clearly explained and the authors are deploying experimental method they have used previously in the referenced literature. The only exception to this is a limited explanation regarding the choice of the multivariate statistical model used to assess the results.
The conclusions and discussion are well supported by the experimental and calculated Fe(II) oxidation experiments. With accurate description of the methods and experimental details to allow the work to be reproduced, along with suitable references to more detailed methods papers.
The authors give credit to related work but with a narrow view on the experimental setting and determination of Fe oxidation rates. There are wider implications for the work with regards to how Fe is represented in biogeochemical models and how climate change driven variability in sea ice, and increased terrestrial DOM inputs, may alter the biogeochemistry of Fe in the northern high latitudes in the future. These topics are sparingly discussed if at all in the conclusions, at the end of the discussion, or highlighted as a rationale for the study in the introduction. I believe the paper would benefit from further explaining the wider significance of these results for understanding and modelling Fe ocean biogeochemistry.
The paper is well structured however there are several things that could be altered to make it clearer and easier for the reader to follow. First, the authors should avoid the frequent use of station numbers in the text where possible. I found myself referring back to figure 1 frequently mid-paragraph to place the location of the station being discussed, it would be easier to follow the discussion and results if the sampling/experiment locations were given more descriptive names such as the name of the Basin/Sea the station is in, followed by the station number, or a Latitude coordinate or something that describes that station relative to the water mass or experimental context e.g. Barents Sea, South/Continental.
Bar chart figures should be edited to make the differences between ocean basins/seas discussed in the text clearer and highlight the statistical differences. This was mainly an issue for discussing the deep samples taken over a wider depth range. The text describes overall differences between the basins/seas, however there are a wide range of different values at different depths. Whilst I can generally see that the mean values would look as described in the text the reader shouldn’t be expected to squint at the different bar groupings to figure this out for themselves. I’d suggest putting the mean value (or other relevant statistic) as a grey line across all the bars from each station with a dotted line above and below to show the standard deviation around the mean. The y-axis on figure 3 should be set from 0 to 20 minutes to remove unnecessary white space at the top of the graph and make it easier to see the bars. I would also suggest making the colours of the bars for the Barents Sea different to those from the Arctic Ocean Basins, to remind the reader throughout of the hypothesis being tested, that these two regions are being compared because it is anticipated that these two regions will show differences in Fe(II) oxidation rate due to the differences in DOM concentration and composition.
A weakness of this paper is the use of vague qualitative language in parts of the results and discussion to describe trends in the data without the additional statistics/values to support the described trends. This is present throughout the paper but is most evident in the results sections 3.2.1 and 3.2.2. In particular when waters are described as “much fresher” with no reference to a change in salinity, or “very “Atlantic”” without any reference to specific changes in temperature or salinity. When results are described as being higher, lower or similar I anticipate these statements to be followed by some measure of how high/low/similar they are e.g. t1/2 was slower in the Nansen basin relative to the Markov (2 +/- 0.5 mins). The text needs to be edited with this in mind throughout the paper to clearly show the reader how large or different the various discussed results are.
The paper spends a significant amount of words discussing the oceanographic context in the introduction and section 4.1 and I didn’t think this was entirely necessary given that figure 1 does a good job of showing the different ocean water masses in the region, and could be enhanced further by labelling arrows with water mass abbreviations. Assuming the paper is already at or near the maximum word count, I would suggest making the description of the oceanographic setting more concise in favour of adding more on the rationale for the experiment i.e. why do we care about Fe in this setting? Explaining how Fe(II) oxidation underpins the wider biogeochemical cycle of Fe etc.
Overall this is an incredibly useful and interesting set of results derived from a fine tuned experimental set-up that the authors have developed and used previously in other settings to great effect. The manuscript needs editing and clarification to make the most of this valuable data.
Individual Scientific queries/issues:
Line 65: The paper highlights in the introduction that oxidation rate can be altered by mineral particle surfaces however it never mentions in the methods or discussion the possibility of whether or not colloidal mineral particles within the dissolved filtered seawater samples used for experiments may affect the results. Whilst I appreciate this would be difficult to measure and completely control for in the experiments, I think it deserves mentioning either briefly when discussing the experimental set-up or the results, that the seawater used for the experiments will still contain colloidal particles (some of which maybe inorganic minerals, organic or a mix of both) and the concentrations of these were not quantified.
Section 2.1: Are there any existing DOM/DOC data that can be used to highlight the differences in the strength of organic matter fluxes entering the different study areas e.g. source flux/DOM concentration of waters that flow into/become the transpolar drift?
Line 178 to 180: Was the luminol reagent purified in any way before use to remove the possibility of adding additional Fe to the experiment, or was it made up using high purity reagents that had negligible Fe initially (or other contaminants that could alter the oxidation rate results e.g. other metals, organic compounds)?
Section 2.5 and 2.6: Are there any supporting statements that can be made about whether or not the presence of Fe binding ligands can be directly associated with the measured FDOM and Lignin phenol data? If not, it should be made clearer that these are tracers of terrestrial and marine DOM sources and therefore only provide an inferred link to the presence of Fe binding ligands that will also be supplied by terrestrial and marine sources.
Line 282 to 286: The logic of this paragraph needs to be explained more clearly, I believe the takeaway is that The Arctic studies observe a lower activation energy in water with higher organic matter concentration in comparison to other studies from other regions, however this wasn’t clear to me, please consider revising the text.
Technical corrections/typos etc:
Throughout DOM is described as being allochthonous or autochthonous as well as being terrestrial and marine. Unless there is a reason for this distinction it would be clearer if the paper stuck to using marine and terrestrial to describe the different DOM sources throughout.
Line 259: “compare” should be “compared”
Line 360: Please define the abbreviation OSW on first use.