Comparing Surface and Subsurface Marine Heatwaves in Ocean Reanalyses
Abstract. Marine heatwaves (MHWs) are increasingly recognised as major drivers of ecological and socio‑economic disruption, yet their subsurface expression remains poorly constrained due to sparse in situ observations. Here, we characterise properties such as the intensity, duration, and heterogeneity of subsurface MHWs using the Copernicus Global Ocean Reanalysis Ensemble Product (GREP). MHWs are detected across multiple depths (0.5–200 m) using a consistent percentile-based thresholding, applied to three reanalysis members (CGLORSv7, GLORYS2v4, ORAS5) and evaluated against well‑documented historical events. All reanalyses successfully capture the timing and general evolution of major, well-known surface expressions of MHW events when compared against the ESA Climate Change Initiative SST dataset in given areas of interest, such as, for example, events of 2011 in Western Australia, of 2015 in the Northeast Pacific Blob, and of 2006 in the Mediterranean Sea. Here, it is also shown that anomalies frequently penetrate below the mixed layer, down to 100–150 m. On a global scale, there is a positive bias of about 15 days in the mean duration for all the events with respect to satellite SST data, consistent with the limited eddy-resolving capability of the eddy-permitting GREP reanalyses, the additional smoothing introduced by ensemble averaging and the difference between the different representative depths of SST in satellite observations and models. Global diagnostics reveal that MHWs extending into the subsurface are more persistent, spatially heterogeneous, and characterised by sharper onset and decline rates than shallow events, particularly in the tropics, western boundary currents, and the Southern Ocean. Mixed‑layer variability strongly modulates the vertical propagation of anomalies, underscoring the role of vertical mixing in shaping subsurface extremes. Our results highlight both the value and limitations of current reanalyses for subsurface MHW characterisation, emphasising the need for ensemble‑based approaches to quantify uncertainty.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors serves as editor for the special issue to which this paper belongs.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
General comments
This manuscript compares surface and subsurface marine heatwave characteristics across three ocean reanalyses, combining global diagnostics with selected historical events and comparisons against observational products. The topic is relevant given the increasing use of reanalyses to investigate subsurface extremes where direct observations are limited. The main potential contribution is to establish which MHW characteristics are consistently represented across products and where their representation depends strongly on the choice of reanalysis. Such an assessment could provide useful guidance for researchers using these datasets.
However, substantial revision is needed before the methods and conclusions can be adequately assessed. Essential analytical procedures are insufficiently described, and the manuscript does not consistently distinguish interproduct agreement from observational validation, or demonstrated findings from proposed physical explanations. The objectives and principal findings also need sharper focus, particularly regarding whether differences between shallow and deep events are robust across products and how they compare with inter reanalysis differences.
The presentation deepens these scientific concerns. Long sentences, extensive parenthetical remarks, inconsistent terminology and frequent grammatical errors obscure the analysis. Methodological details appear within the Results, while findings are interwoven with interpretations that are not directly tested. Consequently, the reader must repeatedly reconstruct what was calculated and what the results actually establish. The comments below identify the main concerns and provide representative examples. They are not an exhaustive list of necessary corrections. A thorough revision of the entire manuscript is needed, rather than changes confined to the passages identified here.
Major comments
1. Clarify the analytical workflow and provide reproducible methods
The Methods should begin with a clear overview of the study design: surface evaluation against ESA CCI SST, subsurface intercomparison among the three reanalyses, and the additional comparison with ARMOR3D for one event. The purpose and scope of each dataset should be explicit.
Section 2.4 should then follow a logical sequence: preprocessing and regridding; climatology, threshold calculation and MHW detection; detrending; regional event selection; and calculation of metrics and comparison statistics. Several essential operations require clarification:
These details affect the interpretation of the results and should not be left for the reader to infer.
2. Distinguish consistency, validation and uncertainty
Agreement among reanalyses is informative but does not establish accuracy, particularly where products share models, forcing or assimilated observations. Similarly, surface agreement with ESA CCI SST provides limited evidence for subsurface performance. Please clarify the independence of the reference products and the scope of the ARMOR3D comparison.
Ensemble spread should be described as a measure of interproduct disagreement or an indicator of uncertainty with acknowledgement that shared errors are not captured. Its use to identify statistically significant differences also requires justification. In particular, comparing a difference with twice the ensemble standard deviation does not, by itself, constitute a significance test.
3. Align physical interpretations with the analyses performed
The manuscript should distinguish observed patterns from explanations supported by previous studies and mechanisms demonstrated here. Statements concerning vertical propagation, vertical mixing and the role of eddies require qualification unless supported by analyses that isolate those processes.
For example, the proposed effect of ensemble smoothing depends on whether temperatures are averaged before MHW detection. Likewise, the contribution of native model resolution needs to be considered alongside the remapping of all products to a common 1° grid. These interpretations would generally fit better in the Discussion.
4. Strengthen the scientific focus and revise the presentation throughout
Please state the research questions explicitly and organise the Results around their answers. The manuscript would be more informative if it clearly identified which metrics and regional or depth-dependent patterns are robust across products, where disagreement is greatest, and how that disagreement affects the interpretation of subsurface MHWs.
A comprehensive language and structural revision is also required. Please shorten convoluted sentences, remove unnecessary parenthetical explanations, use terminology consistently and separate methods, results and interpretation. Check grammar, units, abbreviations, citation formatting and typographical errors throughout. Long citation lists should be made more selective (limit to 3 references), with references placed close to the specific claims they support.
Selected specific comments
Abstract
Lines 11 and 21–22: Define “heterogeneity” and clarify whether it refers to temporal variability within events, spatial variability or differences among events. Ensure consistency with the metric calculated.
Lines 13–16: Clarify that historical events are selected case studies whose surface expressions are evaluated against ESA CCI SST. Specify whether this comparison concerns individual members, the ensemble mean or both.
Lines 18–20: Split this sentence and distinguish the duration-bias result from its proposed explanations. Clarify whether approximately 15 days represents a global average or a regional maximum.
Introduction
Lines 34–46: This passage illustrates recurring language problems, including repeated definitions, “implications … makes,” “Since the definition of MHWs definition,” and inconsistent use of “heatwave” and “heat wave.” Please revise throughout.
Lines 43–46: Distinguish observational coverage from sampling resolution. Satellite SST offers extensive spatial coverage, but in situ instruments do not necessarily have coarser temporal sampling.
Lines 57–58: Replace “one of the best alternatives” with a “useful approach”.
Lines 60–65: Distinguish studies using reanalyses to characterize MHWs from studies using them as reference datasets to evaluate other products.
Methods
Table 2: Explain the event selection criteria, the distinction between the larger domains and subregions, and how the listed time windows were determined.
Lines 128–130: Clarify what the histograms represent, which datasets are used, and whether climatologies and thresholds are calculated separately for each product and depth. Explain the calculation and smoothing steps in order.
Line 130: Specify the severity classification scheme and check that the cited reference corresponds to that scheme. If pointing to Hobday severity categorization it should be Hobday et al. (2018)
Results
Lines 147–150: Move the methodological information to the Methods. Any introductory paragraph here should orient the reader to the sequence of results.
Lines 154–158: The grey regions are described as “non-significant,” but the stated criterion is a bias exceeding twice the ensemble standard deviation. Resolve this contradiction and ensure consistency between the text, shading and caption. Also, avoid using "significant" if significance was not tested.
Lines 159–165: Simplify the description of maximum intensity spatial distribution. Consider adjusting the colour scale to show the regional contrasts discussed.
Lines 170–183: Move the proposed explanations to the Discussion.