A general probabilistic framework for prediction of extreme flow events at river confluences
Abstract. River confluences are critical nodes within river systems and are often exposed to increased flood risk, as the co-occurrence of peak streamflows and thus the superposition of flood waves from two or more tributaries may amplify their magnitudes, leading to compound extreme flow events. However, a systematic and holistic framework to analyse and predict extreme streamflows downstream of river confluences remains largely absent from the literature. This study investigates the interaction between upstream and downstream streamflows during extreme events at river confluences and provides a computationally efficient probabilistic framework for estimating extreme downstream flows based on combinations of upstream conditions from individual tributaries. In this work, a confluence is defined as the junction of two upstream river branches that merge into a downstream channel. We introduce a novel probabilistic-based methodology to describe and predict concurrent streamflows, including uncertainty quantification across the three branches when an extreme event occurs in at least one of them. Building on this, a copula-based probabilistic model is developed with a twofold objective: (i) to predict downstream flow given different combinations of upstream conditions, and (ii) to determine combinations of upstream flows associated with downstream flows exceeding specified safety thresholds. The proposed framework is demonstrated and tested using three contrasting river confluences: two confluences in the Rhine river system in Germany i.e., Rhine–Nahe at Bingen and Rhine–Main at Mainz, and the Mississippi-Missouri confluence at St. Louis in the United States. The results demonstrate that confluences sharing the same main river can behave fundamentally differently under extreme conditions. In the Rhine-Nahe system the influence of Nahe to the downstream streamflow is limited due to its smaller size compared to the Rhine. On the other hand, for the Rhine-Main confluence which is characterized by an intermediate difference between the magnitudes of the two contributing river branches, the results show that the superimposition of the flood waves remains a major control of downstream extreme floods. In contrast, for the Mississippi–Missouri confluence, where upstream streamflows of the two contributing river branches are of comparable magnitude, the simultaneous occurrence of moderate peaks is a primary driver of downstream extreme streamflows. In other words, under such conditions, the superimposition of individual flood waves is not the only dominant control on downstream extreme floods, but has the potential to lead to extreme flow events that may have catastrophic consequences. The probabilistic model developed here demonstrates high predictive skill in reproducing downstream streamflows from upstream observations with Nash–Sutcliffe Efficiency, NSE > 0.97 in all cases, despite the contrasting mechanisms underlying the generation of flood waves at the three study confluences, indicating its generalizability and robustness for estimating and predicting upstream flow combinations that may lead to downstream streamflows beyond safety thresholds.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of Hydrology and Earth System Sciences.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
The concept of dependency has often been introduced using the interplay between dependent and independent variables. This philosophical framing has been well utilized for many decades across various scientific fields, and hydrology has similarly adopted it within its domain to reflect the causal and statistical dependencies among hydrological variables. Although a variable may be categorized as independent in one context, it can become dependent when the analysis is shifted or refined into another domain or problem. Therefore, what is perceived as independent can transform into a dependency depending on the contextual boundary conditions. Ultimately, true independence is governed by nature, which defines the physical boundaries of this concept and shapes the episodes of empirical data on this planet.
In this manuscript, the authors project this concept of dependency and interdependency into the framework of river confluences in hydrology. The authors claim that predicting extreme streamflows downstream of river confluences remains largely unaddressed in the literature, and they have consequently undertaken a collaborative, multinational effort to investigate this apparent research gap. Based on the current version of the manuscript, the following points are brought forward for discussion:
In the current version of the manuscript, the definition of "confluence" found in the introduction [line 30] is incorrect. Furthermore, because the current phrasing suggests a misunderstanding of the concept, the authors should include an authoritative citation to support the definition. Currently, on line 30, the authors state that confluences are "junctions in river networks where two or more tributaries merge to form a downstream river." This definition is inaccurate. A confluence also occurs along a main river whenever a tributary connects to the main stem. For example, in the Mekong River Basin, an international transboundary river basin, the main river features confluences at junctions introduced by tributaries, such as the Tonle Sap. The definition needs to be revised to accurately reflect river network hydrology, and a relevant reference should be cited.
Lines 30–31: The authors state that streamflow downstream of a confluence is a non-linear combination of upstream contributions and categorize this process as a compound event. From the perspective of river hydrology and established nomenclature, this definition is conceptually incomplete and potentially misleading.
While downstream streamflow inherently incorporates upstream inputs, natural river hydrodynamics dictate that flow at a confluence is governed by a mutual interaction of both upstream and downstream hydraulic conditions. A classic illustration of this mechanism is the Tonle Sap in the Mekong River Transboundary Basin, where pronounced seasonal flow reversibility causes the tributary to alternate between acting as an upstream tributary and a downstream recipient. Similar backwater effects, backwater-induced flow attenuation, and seasonal reversals are well-documented across numerous global river networks, including major systems in the United States.
Consequently, the authors must cross-check the cited literature to support this statement [line 30-31] to ensure the context has not been misrepresented. If the statement accurately reflects the cited source, the source itself may be conceptually flawed or insufficient to support such a generalized claim. Relying uncritically on peer-reviewed literature can propagate systemic errors, as even highly cited papers in high-impact journals occasionally contain overlooked methodological or conceptual oversights. The authors should revise this definition to align with standard hydrodynamic principles or provide robust, contextually appropriate literature to justify their framework.