Planetary-Wave modulation of mesospheric and lower thermosphere nitric oxide structure and transport during major Sudden Stratospheric Warmings
Abstract. Nitric oxide (NO) produced by energetic particle precipitation in the polar mesosphere and lower thermosphere can descend into the winter stratosphere, where it contributes to catalytic ozone loss and links solar forcing to middle-atmosphere composition and dynamics. Previous studies have shown pronounced longitudinal structure in NO transport during individual sudden stratospheric warmings (SSWs), but it remains unclear whether this organization is a recurring feature of Arctic SSWs. Here, we use ACE-FTS NO observations, SABER temperature and geopotential height measurements, MERRA-2 meteorological fields, and specified-dynamics WACCM-X simulations to examine 11 major Arctic SSWs during 2006–2024. Composite analyses show coherent NO structures near 90 km organized by planetary-wave (PW) phase, with enhanced NO preferentially located in PW troughs and reduced NO in PW ridges. This phase dependence extends through much of the 70–100 km region. Profile-derived effective NO transport rates indicate consistently stronger downward transport in PW troughs than in ridges for split events, whereas displaced-vortex SSWs show smaller and more variable ridge–trough differences. WACCM-X qualitatively reproduces the observed behavior but generally underestimates the ridge–trough contrast for split events. These results show that PW organization of mesospheric NO is a recurring feature within the analyzed event sample and provide a framework for evaluating whole-atmosphere models beyond zonal-mean diagnostics.
I have reviewed the manuscript ‘Planetary-Wave modulation of mesospheric and lower thermosphere nitric oxide structure and transport during major Sudden Stratospheric Warmings’ by Shi et al.. The authors examine PW modulation of mesospheric NO transport during 11 major Arctic Sudden Stratospheric Warmings (SSWs) from 2006 to 2024, using ACE-FTS NO observations, SABER temperature and geopotential height measurements, MERRA-2 meteorological fields, and SD-WACCM-X simulations. The results show enhanced NO located in PW troughs and reduced NO in PW ridges at 90 km. Moreover, downward NO transport is faster in PW troughs than in ridges during split SSWs. SD-WACCM-X qualitatively reproduces the observed behavior but underestimates the observed ridge–trough contrast for split events. Overall, the topic of this study is interesting; however, there are some unclear points that require clarification. I recommend publication after major revision. Please consider the following comments in revising the manuscript.
Major Comments:
1) Section 2.3 SABER. The latitude coverage of SABER is described as 83N to 52S or 52N to 83S. However, SABER appears to have coverage extending to the polar regions in Figures 2 and 4, which is confusing. Are the data interpolated in these figures?
2) Section 2.4 ACE-FTS. The authors mention that the uncertainties in the ACE-FTS NO retrievals are approximately 80% near 60 km, with generally improved sensitivity at higher NO abundances. The uncertainty is quite large and may substantially affect the analysis. How do the authors account for or address the retrieval uncertainties and data quality in their analysis?
3) Section 2.5.3 PW phase alignment for composite fields. The authors stated that “For each event and dataset, 0 reference longitude is defined as the longitude of the primary PW trough at 10 hPa on Day 0”. It is unclear how the 0 reference longitude is defined at other times. Is the reference longitude fixed based on the primary PW trough on Day 0, or is it determined separately at each time? This is particularly relevant to Figure 3, which shows composite fields averaged from Day −5 to Day +5. How is the GPH field averaged during this period? For example, is each day's GPH field first shifted according to the Day 0 reference longitude and then averaged, or is the PW phase alignment recalculated for each day before averaging? Please clarify the procedure used to construct the composite fields.
4) NO transport rate: Why is there no valid curve for the 2013 SSW in Figure 9 and the 2024 SSW in Figure 10?