the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Local Emission Estimates of Methane in Northern Sweden with the MAGIC2021 Dataset and Lagrangian Transport Modelling
Abstract. Wetland methane emissions at high latitudes are central to the present and future global methane budget, yet remain poorly constrained by observations. Here we combine airborne in-situ measurements from the MAGIC2021 campaign with Lagrangian transport modelling to estimate local wetland methane emissions near Kiruna, Sweden, and test whether current bottom-up wetland models reproduce the emission field that generates the observed atmospheric signal. We find no significant difference in performance between the assessed models, WetCHARTs and JSBACH-HIMMELI, and mean emissions that agree with the observation-based estimates over the targeted plumes. Emission variability, however, is underestimated by every product, with simulated standard deviations below a quarter of the observed value for half of them. Because our footprints integrate over areas larger than the model grid cells, variability misrepresentation is attributed to emissions varying on timescales shorter than model time steps, rather than to finer spatial sampling, which the method cannot test. This explains earlier findings from the same campaign, where model emissions appeared overestimated when sampling a generic atmosphere rather than plumes alone. In WetCHARTs, rescaling to a prescribed global total causes the high latitude flux to fall as the assumed temperature sensitivity rises, so the boreal contribution is set in part by a parametrisation chosen for the tropics. Agreement over emission hotspots is therefore not evidence that the regional emission field is correct, and the apparent bias of a wetland model depends on how the atmosphere is sampled, a caveat applying to tower networks, airborne campaigns and satellite retrievals alike.
- Preprint
(36015 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 13 Dec 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5620', Anonymous Referee #1, 13 Nov 2026 reply
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 262 | 119 | 42 | 423 | 49 | 52 |
- HTML: 262
- PDF: 119
- XML: 42
- Total: 423
- BibTeX: 49
- EndNote: 52
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
This manuscript combines MAGIC2021 aircraft measurements with FLEXPART modelling to evaluate wetland methane emissions in northern Sweden. These measurements are valuable, especially given the limited satellite observations in this high-latitude region. The paper is generally well written, and the comparison of mean emissions and variability is interesting. However, several assumptions need further explanation and testing before the main conclusions can be supported.
Lines 81--87. The authors explain that four of the twelve flights were selected because of their raster patterns and clear plumes. Please provide more explicit selection criteria and explain why the other eight flights were unsuitable. How representative are these four flights, and could selecting the clearest plumes affect the conclusions about average emissions and variability?
Lines 148--150. The August climatology from 2016--2018 may not represent conditions in August 2021. Please test WetCHARTs v1.3.3, which includes 2021 (DOI: 10.3334/ORNLDAAC/2346), if avaiable. The public GCP wetland ensemble (16 diagnostic and 11 prognostic models) could also provide a broader historical comparison during 2000-2020 (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17427197), although these outputs do not cover 2021. These products may not have been available at the time of writing, but they could strengthen the revised comparison. Results from WetCHARTs and JSB may not represent the wider range of bottom-up wetland models.
Lines 174--185. This is important. “We first select the raster portion of each flight and consider the bottom 50% of measured mixing ratios as background b...” Please cite some wetland papers to support 50%.
If this is a new method for wetland, please test backgrounds calculated from the lowest 5%, 10% and 20% of measurements, alongside the current 50%. The cited examples concern cities or power plants, and their applicability to diffuse wetland emissions needs explanation. For example, lowering the background by 2 ppb increases a 5 ppb enhancement to 7 ppb. How much do these choices affect the estimated fluxes and model comparison?
Lines 186--189 and Figure 1. This is also important. My main concern is whether the measured enhancements can be attributed only to wetlands. Nearby lakes and other open-water systems may contribute, as may agricultural sources farther upwind. Low flight altitude and flights targeting wetlands do not establish source attribution. Please quantify possible contributions across the full footprints, including their effects on both plume and background measurements. Based on FIgure 1, there are clearly methane emissions from open water systems (e.g., lakes).
Lines 210--235, Figure 5. Please add a diagram or heatmap showing the FLEXPART sensitivity matrix and how it connects observations to source grid cells. The Fig. 5 is really difficult to read. Figure 5 also needs consistent footprint units, clarification of carbon versus methane mass, and correction of the repeated color bar tick labels. For example, in panel 22a, the unit is ppb g-1 m2 s, but in panel 23a, the unit is ppb mol-1 km2 s? And there are 2 "1e-2" in the color bars?
Lines 321--349. "Mixing ratios from WRF-Chem were found to overestimate ABL methane content compared to MAGIC2021 measurements" and "First, FCH4 from wetland models is not systematically overestimated with respect to the plume-approach estimates. This is the opposite of what might have been inferred from the mixing-ratio-based evaluation alone."Do the main conclusions depend on the transport model and evaluation method? I am surprised that WRF-Chem and FLEXPART yield different assessments. Please clarify it.