the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Icebergs Modify Antarctic Landfast Sea Ice Mass Balance
Abstract. Icebergs locked in landfast sea ice strongly modify snow redistribution on Antarctic landfast sea ice, with important but still poorly constrained consequences for local ice and snow mass balance and ecology. Here, we revisit ice and snow accumulation around icebergs in Atka Bay (eastern Weddell Sea) using a combination of a digital elevation model (DEM) generated from drone photogrammetry, ground-based electromagnetic (EM) induction sounding, manual drilling, snow pits, and ice core analyses. The DEM reveals a characteristic snowdrift morphology consisting of a thick windward drift, two lateral drifts, and a snow-free tail, consistent with previous airborne observations. Snow depths derived from the DEM agree well with manual measurements. Snow properties in the drifts are dominated by dense, wind-compacted slabs. Despite substantial snow loading in drift areas, only limited slush was observed at the snow–sea ice interface, with maximum slush thicknesses of 20 cm. Instead, heavily snow-loaded areas coincide with anomalously thick sea ice (7.8 m), compared to 1.6 m in areas with undisturbed snow cover. Ice core analyses indicate extensive snow-ice formation, suggesting efficient refreezing of flooded snow and a substantial contribution to sea ice mass balance. Basal-origin ice is inferred to be thinner beneath the drifts, while thicker consolidated ice was observed in the snow-free tail. In contrast to previous airborne and modeling studies that limited mass-balance assessments to the snow distribution, this study provides direct, co-located observations of snow, slush, and ice properties, providing evidence that iceberg-induced snowdrifts in Atka Bay can promote substantial snow-ice formation and upward ice growth.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of The Cryosphere.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.- Preprint
(45403 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5496', Ruibo Lei, 27 Sep 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5496', Pat Langhorne, 09 Nov 2026
This paper makes observations that link snow redistribution around grounded icebergs to sea ice mass balance and snow-ice formation in Atka Bay. The study uses a digital elevation model constructed using drone photogrammetry, ground-based electromagnetic induction sounding, snow pits, ice cores and manual drilling. It builds on two recent studies on the icebergs of Atka Bay: one documenting the significant influence of icebergs on snow thickness variability and redistribution over landfast sea ice and for slush formation (Franke et al., 2025); and one that integrates airborne laser scanning observations with numerical snow transport simulations to investigate snow distribution on landfast ice around icebergs (Hames et al., 2026).
The paper is a novel study of the interdependencies of different elements of the cryosphere (snow, icebergs, sea ice). The results are surprising and not necessarily intuitive. It is likely that they will be important for the assessment of the thickness of landfast sea ice.
General Comments
Influence of snow on SIPL: A meter-thick sub-ice platelet layer (SIPL) exists under the landfast ice of Atka Bay (Arndt et al., 2020). Deep snow on sea ice induces earlier formation of an SIPL (e.g. see Fig 7 of Wongpan et al. (2021)). In the introductory sentences, lines 18-20 and 34-35, this is an additional mechanism by which snow cover influences sea ice thermodynamic behaviour.
Wongpan, P., M. Vancoppenolle, P.J. Langhorne, I.J. Smith, G. Madec, A. J. Gough, A. R. Mahoney and T. G. Haskell. (2021) Sub-ice platelet layer physics: insights from a mushy-layer sea ice model. J. Geophys. Res. Oceans, https://doi.org/10.1029/2019JC015918
Construction of Fig 2B: I seem to have missed how an assumed bottom growth of 0.30 m was found from a total consolidated ice thickness of 7.84 m. (see lines 184-186). How is an assumed bottom growth of 0.30 m found from a total consolidated ice thickness of 7.84 m? Is this the yellow cross on Fig 2B? Why should it be decaying exponentially, rather linearly (for example)?
Plots/schematics of salinity and texture of cores: Lines 247-260: I would have found it extremely useful to have plots/schematics of salinity and texture of windward core and ATKAASNE04. Please consider adding these. Table 1 and the text of lines 247-260 may then be able to be reduced.
Colour schemes on Fig 7A: Why have the same colour schemes, but with different ranges, been used for drill hole and EM slush thicknesses? This makes it very confusing to compare these two measurement techniques. Clearly the drill hole and EM slush thicknesses do not accurately agree with each other. However I note that the general distribution of low slush thickness around the berg and high slush thickness under the windward and tail snow drifts are reproduced by drill hole and EM methods. I also concede that both measurements are subject to all manner of errors, as described in the text (lines 289-292).
Typographic and very minor comments
Inconsistent spelling of “fast ice” and “fastice” through paper. My preference is for the former.
Fig 1: The white rectangle is not very obvious.
Line 70: change “from” to “identified by”
Line 86: “the studied iceberg”
Line 100: “elevations”
Line 107: Is the inner square shown on Fig 3?
Line 135: I don’t understand what is meant by pointing out that the negative freeboard being explained by “prior basal ice growth”
Line 178: What “surface elevation”? Do you mean “Above a surface elevation of 75 cm”?
Line 221-222: “distances” from where?
Fig 3: Is the “white dashed outline” grey? What is the grey hatching?
Lines 224: “same spatial distribution” as the snow?
Line 226: “reproduces”
Fig 4: Are the green squares not the manual CI+SIPL thickness?
Lines 237, 238 & Table 1: I’m confused because it states that 390 cm was recovered but Table 1 has depths to 397 cm.
Line 287 & Fig 7B: The agreement between the EM slush thicknesses and the manual values does not seem very convincing to me. I do concede that these are both extremely difficult measurements to make.
Line 306: Sentence finished by “:”. Is something missing?
Line 308: Suggest replacing “would match” with “matched”
Line 315-316: The diminished temperature gradient also promotes the formation of an SIPL (Wongpan et al., 2021).
Line 379: replace “athe” with “the”
Line 427: Cite the published version rather than preprint. Franke, S., Neudert, M., Helm, V., Jutila, A., Hames, O., Neckel, N., Arndt, S., and Haas, C.: Iceberg influence on snow distribution and slush formation on Antarctic landfast sea ice from airborne multi-sensor observations, The Cryosphere, 19, 6319–6339, https://doi.org/10.5194/tc-19-6319-2025, 2025.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-5496-RC2
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 337 | 165 | 62 | 564 | 62 | 68 |
- HTML: 337
- PDF: 165
- XML: 62
- Total: 564
- BibTeX: 62
- EndNote: 68
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Review on “Icebergs Modify Antarctic Landfast Sea Ice Mass Balance”
Large numbers of grounded icebergs exist along the Antarctic coastal margin. These icebergs exert sheltering effects on both wind and current fields, thereby modulating the growthdecay processes of landfast sea ice. Based on multiple observations around icebergs in Atka Bay, including airborne remotesensing surveys, groundbased electromagnetic induction sounding, drilling, icecore sampling and snowpit measurements, this paper reveals that icebergs alter winddriven snow redistribution and snowaccumulation processes. Excessive snow accumulation in the windward and lateral zones consequently gives rise to snowice formation, whereas suppressed snow accumulation in the leeward tail enhances thermodynamic seaice thickening.
This work is of great significance for studies on iceberglandfastice interactions, numerical modelling of landfast ice physical processes, as well as landfastice phenology and associated ecosystems. Its insights may even have implications for iceberg stability and onice logistical operations. It is therefore a publicationworthy study. The authors present highly valuable and rare fieldobservation datasets and demonstrate strong capability in integrating multisource data. I recommend that this manuscript be considered for publication following revision.
General comments:
Special comments: