the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Thermokarst Domains of Canada
Abstract. Thermokarst refers to landforms and processes resulting from the thaw of ice-rich permafrost. Thermokarst landforms vary with ground ice, substrate, and terrain conditions, which are products of geological and climatic history. Recognizing how thermokarst manifests across vast permafrost regions provides insights into the consequences of permafrost thaw, including sediment fluxes, carbon cycling, and ecosystem changes. Here, we present a conceptual model summarizing associations between thermokarst landforms and permafrost terrain conditions, based on a compilation and analysis of 19,549 landform observations from published literature. We recognize several broad thermokarst domains in Canada, based on permafrost and ground ice distribution and past climate, further modified by organic terrain conditions, which control landform types and their general distribution. These domains broadly group the distribution of thermokarst landforms observed today and suggest the range of thermokarst trajectories expected with future climate warming. The conceptual model supports the narrative expressed in the production of the Ground Ice Map of Canada and the permafrost landsystems framework, i.e., that geological and paleoenvironmental histories, including impacts of past thaw, influence the nature and variation in ground ice and thermokarst across permafrost regions.
- Preprint
(1784 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(368 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 15 Dec 2026)
- CC1: 'Small sample sizes in eastern Canada despite available data', Robert Way, 30 Oct 2026 reply
Data sets
A database of thermokarst and related landform observations in Canada (1961 to 2024) Stephen A. Wolfe et al. https://doi.org/10.4095/pxqr7ad0un
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 303 | 145 | 22 | 470 | 63 | 27 | 26 |
- HTML: 303
- PDF: 145
- XML: 22
- Total: 470
- Supplement: 63
- BibTeX: 27
- EndNote: 26
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
I thank the authors of Wolfe et al (2026) for having prepared an interesting contribution and classification approach to thermokarst domains in portions of Canada. While these types of categorization activities undoubtedly have a various array of opinions, it is a useful typology for permafrost researchers to consider. These types of publications will also be used by researchers, consultants and communities so it is certainly valuable for this manuscript to be thorough.Â
However, despite the positives associated with this contribution, I would recommend that the paper be renamed and reframed as a characterization of thermokarst domains for a region within Canada rather than Canada as a whole like it is currently written. This contribution, while interesting, has a significant bias in the distribution of sites towards northwestern Canada, and this has likely impacted the framing of this manuscript. I am particularly concerned that the types of thermokarst environments that occur in marine deposits in Nunavik and Labrador have not been meaningfully considered. Further, a reader of Wolfe et al (2026) could conclude from Figure 3 that widespread ice wedge associated thermokarst only occurs in the continuous permafrost zone, and more importantly that wedge ice cannot be found in the isolated patches zone. Both of these interpretations would undoubtedly be affected by consideration of works and ongoing research in some of these environments underlain by postglacial marine deposits in Nunavik and Labrador.
In Nunavik, for example, L’Hérault et al (2017) provide an extensive inventory of thermokarst features which have mostly not been considered in this current manuscript. Likewise, Chiasson and Allard (2022) generated an inventory of thermal contraction crack polygons for Nunavik including ice wedges which undoubtedly included a wide array of thermokarst environments amongst the inventory. In Labrador, Wang et al (2023) provided an inventory including well over 1,000 wetlands with peatland permafrost landforms where a quick visual examination would reveal thermokarst is ubiquitous at many (most) of these sites (even the photos from the paper itself show numerous examples of thermokarst). This inventory was publicly available to the authors. Likewise, Anderson et al (2018), Way et al (2018) and Beer et al (2024) all described thermokarst at their field sites spanning the Labrador coast. Finally, in a recent literature review by Power et al (2025), the authors note that 11 different studies completed in Labrador identified thermokarst associated landforms whereas Wolfe et al (2026) only included data from 2 smaller studies in the region. Â
This is all to say that it is an interesting contribution but the current presentation of the manuscript is as a national-scale typology yet the data limitations mean that in its current form it cannot achieve this goal for some of the regions it purports to represent. The authors will need to either a) modify the contribution to better reflect that there are regions in Canada where the authors did not have sufficient sample sizes or b) incorporate additional sites and amend the manuscript to reflect this addition. It pains me to say this, but the manuscript should not be accepted without making these changes.Â
References
Anderson, D., Ford, J.D., and Way, R.G. 2018. The impacts of climate and social changes on cloudberry (bakeapple) picking: a case study from southeastern Labrador. Human Ecology, 46(6): 849–863. doi:10.1007/s10745-018-0038-3.
Beer, J., Wang, Y., Way, R., Forget, A., and Colyn, V. 2024. Uncrewed Aerial Vehicle–Based Assessments of Peatland Permafrost Vulnerability Along the Labrador Sea Coastline, Northern Canada. Permafrost and Periglacial Processes, 35(4): 461–477. doi:10.1002/ppp.2242.
Chiasson, A., and Allard, M. 2022. Thermal contraction crack polygons in Nunavik (northern Quebec): Distribution and development of polygonal patterned ground. Permafrost and Periglacial Processes, 33(3): 195–213. doi:10.1002/ppp.2150.
L’Hérault, E., Boisson, A., Allard, M., Aubé-Maurice, S., Sarrazin, D., Roger, J., and Barrette, C. 2017. Détermination et analyse des vulnérabilités du Nunavik en fonction des composantes environnementales et des processus physique naturels liés au climate: Phase 1. Université Laval, Québec City, Canada.
Power, M., Way, R.G., Wang, Y., and Lewkowicz, A.G. 2025. Permafrost and geocryological hazard research trends in Nunatsiavut, northeastern Canada. In Proceedings of GeoManitoba: 78th Annual CGS Conference & 9th Canadian Permafrost Conference. Canadian Permafrost Association, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. p. 9.
Wang, Y., Way, R.G., Beer, J., Forget, A., Tutton, R., and Purcell, M.C. 2023. Significant underestimation of peatland permafrost along the Labrador Sea coastline in northern Canada. The Cryosphere, 17(1): 63–78. doi:10.5194/tc-17-63-2023.
Way, R.G., Lewkowicz, A.G., and Zhang, Y. 2018. Characteristics and fate of isolated permafrost patches in coastal Labrador, Canada. The Cryosphere, 12(8): 2667–2688. doi:10.5194/tc-12-2667-2018.