the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
LAWS: A new crop–water coupling model integrating an agricultural module into a process-based hydrological model (CWatM v1.08)
Abstract. It is essential to jointly represent crop growth, water availability, and human water management in an integrated framework to understand future water-food interactions. Although existing large-scale coupling models have improved the representation of crop-water interactions, few integrate detailed crop growth and hydrological processes, together with their interactions, within a unified process-based framework. Here, we developed the Large-scale Agriculture Water System model (LAWS) by integrating a process-based agricultural module into the Community Water Model (CWatM). We evaluated its performance in simulating crop growth dynamics and yields across six experimental sites and at global, national, and grid-cell levels for maize, wheat and soybean. Results showed that, at the site level, LAWS reproduced the main seasonal dynamics of leaf area index and biomass for different crops and regions. Pearson temporal correlations between simulated and reference global yield-anomaly series were 0.68, 0.14, and 0.54 for maize, wheat, and soybean, respectively. Across the top 20-producing countries, the correlations between simulated and reference long-term mean yields were 0.74, 0.79, and 0.32 for maize, wheat, and soybean, respectively. At the grid-cell level, the simulated long-term mean yields showed broad spatial patterns consistent with those in the global gridded yield dataset. Overall, the yield performance of LAWS was broadly comparable to mainstream global crop models, supporting its application to large-scale assessments of crop production. Furthermore, LAWS can represent the interactions between crop growth and the water cycle, providing a framework for sustainable agricultural planning under water constraints. Through a case study, we demonstrated this capability by assessing the contribution of nonrenewable groundwater to irrigated maize production globally. In addition, its open-source and modular architecture facilitates further development to improve the simulation of agricultural systems, the water cycle, and human water management.
- Preprint
(2744 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(1336 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 23 Dec 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5417', Anonymous Referee #1, 18 Nov 2026 reply
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 262 | 111 | 28 | 401 | 67 | 31 | 33 |
- HTML: 262
- PDF: 111
- XML: 28
- Total: 401
- Supplement: 67
- BibTeX: 31
- EndNote: 33
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
This paper presents another crop-hydrological two-way coupled model, which is technically very challenging. It integrates the crop growth module from the EPIC crop model with the hydrological model CWatM and validates the results through yield comparison. The methodology is well documented, and the presentation is overall clear. Though I trust the implementation of the code, I still have a few concerns over the technical validation part and changes in land use in CWatM. Thus, I will recommend a major revision.
Major concerns:
1. I do not really understand why the authors chose yield and crop production to validate their models. The motivation, as stated in the introduction, is water consumption. That is why crop models need more information from hydrological models or another way around. This study does not create a new crop model, but integrates part of the EPIC model into CWatM. In this sense, the most straightforward technical validation is the comparison between EPIC and LAWS to ensure LAWS replicates EPIC’s behavior regarding crop growth. There will be differences that can be further explained with the added value of CWatM. On top of this, the next step can be yield validation, but this introduces more factors affecting the comparison, including the misalignment of harvested area, soil, climate, and other inputs between LAWS and other datasets. In particular, the harvested area used in this study has limited temporal resolution. Thus, validating LAWS through yield might hinder the core validation of crop growth and water because of these misalignments. I trust the authors have done the direct comparison with EPIC, which, I think, should be included in this manuscript.
2. How LAWS changes the land use type in CWatM is not clear to me. The authors explain in lines 239-241 that the agricultural land was divided into five crop categories; what does this mean? In CWatM, I understand there are three out of six land use types related to crops: grassland, irrPaddy, and irrNonPaddy. Grassland includes all the rainfed crops; irrPaddy is irrigated rice, and other irrigated crops are irrNonPaddy.
(1) When using LAWS simulates these five crops for rainfed and irrigated, did authors add more land use types in CWatM to describe these crops separately? If not, then do different crops share the same land use type in CWatM? I understand each land use type in CWatM has its own soil moisture variable and relatively independent hydrological processes. This points to whether different crops in LAWS share the same soil moisture or not.
(2) Though rice is not included in the validation in this paper, the authors did describe the modeling of rice in LAWS. Then, will rice in LAWS replace the original irrPaddy?
(3) When modeling some crops explicitly in LAWS, how did the authors change grassland and irrNonPaddy in CWatM? I understand the Kc values for these two land uses are calculated as a weighted average over all the crops. If the authors take a few crops out, then should grassland and irrNonPaddy change accordingly?
3. I do not agree with using the term ‘actual yield’ in this paper. According to crop production ecology (see the reference below), the yield simulated by LAWS is water- and nutrient-limited yield. It considers the stress of water and nutrients compared to the potential yield, but has not considered other field management factors, such as weed control, pests and diseases, and pollutants, which lead to actual yield.
Van Ittersum, M. K., Cassman, K. G., Grassini, P., Wolf, J., Tittonell, P., & Hochman, Z. (2013). Yield gap analysis with local to global relevance—a review. Field crops research, 143, 4-17.
Minor concerns:
4. Will the LAI simulation in LAWS affect the interception in CWatM?
5. Line 175, HUIS is already defined in line 170.
6. Line 187, should the canopy light extinction coefficient be crop-specific? Is this a fixed value that users cannot change in EPIC?
7. Lines 226-227. NS was obtained from PEPIC; does HIF also depend on NS?
8. Line 229, ‘similar to’ or ‘the same’? LAWS uses the same crop growth equations as in EPIC, right?
9. One of the main purposes of this coupling is the assessment of water availability and water use. LAWS and CWatM are both gridded; can the authors suggest how the crop in one grid cell can use water for irrigation from other grid cells?