the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Technical note: Pyrite (U,Th)-He geochronology using scanning fiber-laser He extraction: analytical workflow and case studies from two orogenic gold systems in the Russian Far East
Abstract. This study presents a new analytical approach to (U,Th)-He dating of individual pyrite grains. We demonstrate that a widely available commercial fiber-laser marking system operated in scanning mode can efficiently extract radiogenic He from pyrite encapsulated in quartz ampoules. The ampoules retain the thermal decomposition products and associated parent nuclides, allowing U and Th to be subsequently determined in the same material from which He was extracted. The proposed extraction technique was validated using pyrite from two gold-bearing sites in the Russian Far East: the Pavlik orogenic gold deposit in the Magadan Region and the Upryamoe gold occurrence, Chukotka. The resulting pyrite (U,Th)-He ages are 139.3 ± 1.7 Ma (MSWD = 2.5; n = 7) and 125.4 ± 2.1 Ma (MSWD = 0.87; n = 5), respectively. Compared with the previously developed high-vacuum furnace procedure, the scanning fiber-laser approach increases the analytical throughput of pyrite (U,Th)-He dating by approximately an order of magnitude, allowing up to eight samples to be analysed per day. By making individual-grain age determinations faster and operationally simpler, the method enables larger datasets to be acquired and thereby improves the statistical characterization of pyrite ages from a range of geological settings.
- Preprint
(4297 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 24 Nov 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5408', Anonymous Referee #1, 08 Nov 2026 reply
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5408', Anonymous Referee #2, 13 Nov 2026
reply
The paper Pyrite (U,Th)-He geochronology using scanning fiber-laser He extraction: analytical workflow and case studies from two orogenic gold systems in the Russian Far East by Yakubovich et al. proposes a novel analytical technique for (U-Th)/He pyrite geochronology. The method relies on the use of quartz ampoules and a fiber-laser in scanning mode. They show that the ampoule and laser method extracts helium from pyrite and that parent isotopes can be accurately measured from the decomposition products after helium extraction. They show that their obtained ages are reasonable given the geologic and geochronologic constraints for their chosen samples and that their dates are reproducible. The paper is mostly clear and I recommend it be published as a technical note after addressing the comments below:
Major comments:
- Overall, I would like to see a discussion of your calculations. How did you calculate the uncertainties? What uncertainties were included? How were individual dates calculated?
- I am unable to reproduce either of the plots shown in Figure 6 using the numbers provided in Table 1. Please explain which model you used when plotting the isochron in IsoplotR (maximum likelihood, least squares, etc.), how you anchored the line, and confirm that the input and output errors are correct. If any code was used to produce the plots, please be sure to include or explain what was done.
Minor comments:
Table 1 comments:
- You report U (ppm) but not Th (ppm), please include.
- What is the uncertainty on the age “±, Ma” (last column)? 1 sigma?
- Please specify that at = atoms. I initially understood that to mean “atmospheres”.
- Please include the data as a spreadsheet in the supplement if allowed for a technical note.
- Do you have the helium released at each laser power step for the Durango fragments? If yes, please include in the table.
- The table is hard to read without the header and I must scroll back to the top when I’m looking through the other samples. Could the header be repeated for the Upryamoe Pyrite and for the Durango apatite?
Figure 6 comments:
- Fig 6a. You report two uncertainties for the age (139.3 ± 1.7 | 2.7 Ma) for this, but not for the other sample.
- Figure 6. Please label x-axis “Parent” or “U and Th” or define “P” in figure caption.
- Figure 6/L256: I tried to reproduce your plots with the data given in IsoplotR online and was unable to. If you used code, could you specify and/or provide the code? Or, please be more specific as to your IsoplotR choices. Did you use the maximum likelihood model?
L77-78: Please include a citation.
L69: Please be consistent throughout the paper and use either uranium/thorium or U/Th.
L198: Are there any qualities you look for or qualities that cause you to reject a pyrite grain when picking (i.e., Shape? Color? Staining?) How were the pyrite separated from the host rock? Do you place 1 grain (300-500µm in size and 1-2mg in mass) in each quartz ampoule? Were they all single grains or did any ampules contain multiple fragments or grains?
L261: Could you expand on potential reasons for the dispersion in Durango dates?
L267-269: You mention and report the Th/U ratios. Could you add a sentence explaining what the broad ratios indicate?
L324: Could you discuss why you did not abrade the outer rim of the pyrite to reduce potential alpha-ejection effects? Or suggest that future work may consider abrasion to see if the overdispersion can be reduced?
Line edits:
L80: Delete opening and closing parenthesis where the citation is already inside parentheses “(~10-10–10-8 cm³ STP g⁻¹; Bortnikov et al., 2000; Luders and Niedermann, 2010; Stuart et al., 1994)”
L174: Add a space between “…2004) and” and correct “Rs-Pt”
L190: Figure 3 caption: delete dash after “(b)”
L203: Delete dash after semicolon: (99.5% purity; Fig. 4b).
L205: Delete dash after “with”. “…covered with protective…”
L225: Figure 4 caption: delete dash after “(a)”, “(b)”, “(c)”, “(d)”, “(e)”, and “yellow”.
L250: Figure 5 caption: delete dash after “(b-d)”
L260: Delete opening parenthesis where the citation is already inside parentheses (1.1 x 10^10 atoms; Yakubovich et al., 2024)
L266: Delete opening parenthesis where the citation is already inside parentheses (three of the latter were previously analysed by Canhimbue et al., 2025)
L285: Figure 6 caption: delete dash after “(b)” and after “Error bars”
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-5408-RC2
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 388 | 133 | 33 | 554 | 39 | 36 |
- HTML: 388
- PDF: 133
- XML: 33
- Total: 554
- BibTeX: 39
- EndNote: 36
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
This manuscript presents a new analytical approach to (U–Th)/He dating of individual pyrite grains using a widely available commercial fiber-laser system. The authors demonstrate that He can be efficiently extracted from pyrite encapsulated in quartz ampoules under scanning mode. This protocol retains the key advantage of the quartz-ampoule encapsulation method that U and Th are measured on the same aliquot used for He measurement and sulfides are prevented from entering the noble-gas mass spectrometer, and compared with the previous high-vacuum furnace procedure, it increases analytical throughput from one sample to up to eight samples per day. The utility of the laser extraction protocol is tested on two pyrite samples, and the obtained ages are consistent with independent constraints. The workflow is described in sufficient detail to be reproducible and is suitable for publication as a Technical note.
Major issues
What is the He closure temperature of pyrite? Although the authors have carried out extensive work on He migration behavior in sulfides, this manuscript does not systematically evaluate closure temperature or resetting behavior. Adding a few quantitative statements in the Introduction on the He closure temperature of pyrite would help assess whether pyrite He ages should be interpreted as ore-forming ages or cooling ages.
The pyrite samples used in this study, especially those from the Pavlik deposit, contain abundant mineral inclusions. The manuscript demonstrates that trapped He is negligible based on the near-zero isochron intercept, and the authors discuss the feasibility of dating inclusion-bearing pyrite as well as possible reasons for the elevated MSWD. However, the authors also state that pyrite contains inclusions of accessory minerals including uraninite, monazite, apatite, zircon, titanite, and xenotime (line 70), and they test the digestion procedure for complete dissolution of zircon inclusions (line 245). Could high-U or high-He-retention mineral inclusions, such as zircon or monazite, really have no effect on the age determination of pyrite? Is it better to avoid selecting pyrite grains that contain high-U or high-He-retention mineral inclusions?
Specific comments