the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Understanding new particle formation based on continuous nanoparticle ranking in boreal forest and urban megacity
Abstract. Understanding atmospheric new particle formation (NPF) across contrasting environments is essential for evaluating its global-scale impacts. Here, we applied a nanoparticle ranking framework to systematically compare four years (2018–2022) of continuous measurements at the boreal forest site of Hyytiälä and the megacity site of Beijing. Ranking values, as the indicator of the NPF strength, revealed contrasting seasonality: the highest-ranking days occurred mainly in spring in Hyytiälä but in winter in Beijing. The driving factors of NPF in these two distinct environments were then investigated. Unexpectedly, the concentrations of key gaseous precursors, i.e. sulfuric acid (SA) and highly oxygenated organic molecule (HOM) in Hyytiälä and SA in Beijing, did not increase monotonically with the ranking values. Together with the evolution of condensation sink (CS) as a function of ranking values, our results illustrated that NPF intensity is governed by source–sink competition rather than precursor availability alone. Further, we revealed quiet NPF signatures at low ranking values in Hyytiälä, whereas primary anthropogenic emissions obscured such signals in Beijing. The particle formation rate of 7 nm (J7) and growth rates of 7–25 nm (GR7–25) particles were calculated under different ranking levels. The results showed that J₇ increased with ranking value, whereas the GR7–25 frequently peaked outside the highest ranking interval. In addition, we also compared the ranking-based J₇ and the J₇ calculated based on traditional methods, suggesting that conventional approaches may underestimate particle formation during weak or less clearly NPF conditions (low ranking days). By combining nanoparticle ranking with normalization method, our results continuously and quantitatively characterized NPF dynamics, thereby improving our understanding in the role of NPF in atmospheric aerosol populations in two distinct environments.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.- Preprint
(1460 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(1036 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 16 Nov 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5379', Anonymous Referee #1, 01 Nov 2026 reply
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 490 | 286 | 70 | 846 | 105 | 80 | 84 |
- HTML: 490
- PDF: 286
- XML: 70
- Total: 846
- Supplement: 105
- BibTeX: 80
- EndNote: 84
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Zhang et al. performed a comprehensive investigation of the characteristics of new particle formation events in two contrasting environments, Finnish boreal forest and urban Beijing, using a nanoparticle ranking method. This study represents the latest understanding of characterizing NPF based on long-term measurements using the paradigm proposed by Kulmala et al. (2024). Compared with a previous paper from the same group of authors (Kulmala et al., 2025), which only briefly addressed the nanoparticle ranking results among the discussion of other topics, this study represents a significant advance in the findings. Overall, this is an interesting and easy-to-follow manuscript. Language polishing is needed before publication. While my comments below may not affect the main findings of this manuscript, I believe addressing them would improve the quality of this manuscript.
Major comments:
1) Line 25, page 1; also line 255, page 10. It is stated that the trend that the concentrations of key gaseous precursors do not follow the ranking values (i.e., nucleation intensity) is "unexpected". I believe the authors should be well aware of this, as their previous studies have addressed this observational fact (e.g., Cai et al., 2017). Better to rephrase "unexpected" to avoid misunderstanding.
2) Line 35, page 1; also the whole section 3.3.3. The authors take the ranking-based J as a reference and argue that the conventional case-specific J may be underestimated. While the explanation based on the GR term in the J calculation makes sense, it is recommended to also address the uncertainty in the ranking-based J. Specifically, since Eq. 3 is not a linear function, the J calculated using the average PNSD is not equivalent to the average of J calculated for each event; the former may contain some bias, whereas it is implicitly taken to be reliable in this study. Constraining this bias, e.g., by comparing the two average J values using all measured days, may in turn support the authors' argument.
3) Line 185, page 6. Previous studies (e.g., Stolzenburg et al., 2023, RMP) have reported biases of the maximum concentration method in retrieving growth rates in urban environments based on simulated NPF events. Does this affect the authors' findings? The reported growth rates seem comparable to previous results obtained using different methods, though.
4) Line 199, page 7. Why not use the formula that better accounts for coagulation, instead of giving the uncertainty here?
5) Figure 2. Using season as the x-axis and plotting rank as stacked bars may improve the accessibility of the results in this figure.
6) Writing suggestions:
a) Line 30, page 1. "calculated under different ranking levels" using ... (e.g., median particle number size distributions).
b) Lines 109-113, page 4. Rephrase. First state that NAIS was used for the whole period, as this size range is used for ranking.
c) Line 158, page 5. This sentence conveys a meaning different from the authors' intended meaning (inferred from Kulmala et al., 2024, Figs. 1 and 2). Rephrase. While the ranking method is considered an objective approach, it cannot classify NPF events and is therefore not comparable to the binary classification.
d )Lines 208-211, page 7. I doubt the necessity of emphasizing this here. This study also focuses on the analysis of sub-25 nm particles and does not address particles beyond 40 nm much. This paragraph may perhaps be integrated into the Methods section.
e) Lines 240-242, page 9. The determination of NPF events in different studies, owing to the use of PNSD instruments with different lower size limits, may also affect the findings. Some nucleation events may not be captured without sub-3 nm measurements.
f) Figure 2 caption. Explain the month abbreviations (MAM, etc.).
g) Figure 3 caption and relevant text. "normalized temperature within each ranking interval" - normalized by what?
h) Lines 303-310, page 12. Good to highlight somewhere in this paragraph that CS is high in Beijing compared with Hyytiälä.
i ) Line 338, page 13. SA dimer concentration is also an indicator of NPF in polluted megacities. See Cai et al. (2021).
j) Line 366, page 15. "normalized". Specify "normalized by what".
k) Line 454, page 18. "difference ... decreased" -> "consistency ... increased".
References:
Kulmala, M. et al., Opinion: A paradigm shift in investigating the general characteristics of atmospheric new particle formation using field observations, Aerosol Res., 2, 49-58, 10.5194/ar-2-49-2024, 2024.
Kulmala, M. et al., Understanding atmospheric processes: insights from the comparison between Beijing and Hyytiälä, npj Clean Air, 1, 26, 2025.
Cai, R. et al., Aerosol surface area concentration: a governing factor in new particle formation in Beijing, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 17, 12327-12340, 10.5194/acp-17-12327-2017, 2017.
Stolzenburg, D. et al., Atmospheric nanoparticle growth, Rev. Mod. Phys., 95, 045002, 10.1103/RevModPhys.95.045002, 2023.
Cai, R. et al., An indicator for sulfuric acid-amine nucleation in atmospheric environments, Aerosol Sci. Technol., 55, 1059-1069, 10.1080/02786826.2021.1922598, 2021.