the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Synoptic-scale organization of multi-day black carbon variability in a regional-background environment over eastern China
Abstract. Black carbon (BC) variability reflects the combined effects of emissions, regional transport, atmospheric mixing, and removal processes, yet the temporal scales through which these processes organize receptor concentrations remain poorly constrained. Regional-background environments provide a useful perspective for identifying atmospheric controls because they are less dominated by immediate local emission fluctuations. Here, year-long hourly BC observations from a regional-background site in eastern China were combined with time-frequency analysis, backward trajectories, circulation-state transitions, and an independent 3–10 day time-domain evaluation to investigate the drivers of multi-day BC variability. BC exhibited enhanced variability at multi-day periods near one week, but the signal occurred intermittently rather than as a persistent weekly oscillation. Transport classification identified contrasting atmospheric states: Regional/slow flow was associated with higher BC (1.30 μg m-3), weaker winds (1.68 m s-1), and shallower planetary boundary-layer height (431 m) than northeastern/coastal (NE/coastal) flow (0.90 μg m-3, 2.22 m s-1, and 593 m, respectively). Transitions toward Regional/slow conditions were followed by BC increases, whereas transitions toward NE/coastal conditions produced decreases. The independently extracted 3–10 day BC component covaried with the persistence of these transport states (Spearman ρ = 0.345; segment-aware circular-shift p < 0.001). Together, these results show that the apparent near-weekly BC feature represents an emergent signature of recurring synoptic accumulation–ventilation states rather than a fixed weekly emission cycle. This study highlights the importance of incorporating atmospheric-state information when interpreting multi-day aerosol variability.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.- Preprint
(6537 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(648 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5302', Anonymous Referee #1, 28 Oct 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5302', Anonymous Referee #2, 15 Nov 2026
This manuscript examines multi-day black carbon (BC) variability at a regional-background site in Hangzhou using one year of hourly BC observations, segment-aware wavelet analysis, HYSPLIT trajectory clustering, circulation-state transition composites, and an independent 3–10 day band-pass evaluation. The topic is relevant to understanding how atmospheric processes influence receptor concentrations. The manuscript is generally well organized, and the explicit treatment of observational gaps is a strength. I recommend publication after minor revision.
Major comments:
- The distinction between synoptic variability and a weekly emission cycle requires direct testing.
Lines 229–251 and 409–419 interpret the broad, intermittent near-weekly signal as evidence favoring synoptic processes over a fixed weekly emission cycle. However, a weekly emission signal can be modified by transport, mixing, and precipitation and therefore need not appear as a persistent, narrow spectral peak at the receptor. Meteorological modulation and weekly emission variability may also coexist.The authors should examine day-of-week differences while accounting for seasonality, diurnal variability, meteorological conditions, and temporal autocorrelation. Testing whether a seven-day component remains after meteorological adjustment would strengthen the interpretation. Without such tests, the abstract and conclusions should state that the results support an important synoptic contribution, rather than presenting synoptic variability and weekly emissions as competing explanations that have been resolved. - The analysis does not yet demonstrate why a near-weekly spectral maximum emerges.
The correlation between the 3–10-day BC component and the 72-hour transport contrast is useful evidence of coupling. Nevertheless, it does not establish that transport-state recurrence generates the observed spectral maximum. Please characterize regime durations, transition intervals, and the temporal spectrum of the transport-state indicator. Comparing the spectra of transport-associated BC variability and the remaining residual variability would also help assess whether transport states explain the near-weekly feature.
The band-pass analysis is independent of the wavelet calculation, but it uses the same underlying BC observations and a selected frequency band. It should therefore be described as a complementary analytical test rather than independent observational validation.
Specific comments:
- The Spearman ρ = 0.345 result is central to the time-domain argument, and the autocorrelation-preserving test is convincing as a significance test. However, the terms "systematic" and "robust" may lead readers to over-interpret the strength of the relationship. Please give a clearer explanation of how to interpret a correlation of this magnitude. Please also explain why the two continuous segments differ appreciably (0.382 vs. 0.287) and whether this difference is best attributed to seasonal composition, segment length, or genuine non-stationarity.
- The two regimes differ systematically in mean wind speed and PBLH, so transport pathway and local ventilation co-vary. The authors describe the regime label as a compact descriptor of an evolving meteorological state. Please explain more explicitly whether the paper's claim is that transport state organizes variability beyond local wind and PBLH, or that the two are inseparable components of a single coupled state.
- The band-pass analysis retains 279 matched daily observations after interpolating gaps ≤ 6 h and discarding 240 h from each segment end. Please explain how the retained segment lengths relate to the 240 h upper cutoff of the filter and why the retained record is adequate for the stated purpose.
- The phrase "emergent signature of recurring synoptic accumulation–ventilation states" is central to the paper's framing but is not defined. Please explain in one or two sentences what "emergent" is intended to convey here, and whether it implies anything about the predictability or scale-dependence of the feature beyond what is already stated.
- The band is defined empirically from the global wavelet spectrum, but the manuscript does not explain why the lower and upper bounds were set at 72 and 240 h rather than at other values. Please add a short justification.
- Section 2.4 and the limitations note that trajectories arrive at 50 m above ground and cannot represent elevated transport. Please give further discussion of how this choice may bias the regime classification in the YRD setting.
- The manuscript describes the NE/coastal to Regional/slow transitions as followed by a "mean 24 h BC increase" of 0.179 μg m-3and the reverse as a decrease of 0.196 μg m-3. Please clarify whether these are composited anomalies relative to the pre-transition baseline and whether the near-mirror symmetry is expected physically or reflects the compositing procedure. A brief explanation is needed here.
- Lines 108–124: Provide site elevation, surrounding land use, and evidence supporting its regional-background classification.
- Clarify that AE33 measurements represent equivalent black carbon (eBC), and report the relevant mass absorption cross-section and instrument settings.
- Lines 116–120: Report how many observations were removed following outlier inspection and how genuine pollution peaks were distinguished from instrumental artifacts.
- Reduce repetition between Sections 3.2 and 3.3 and the conclusions.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-5302-RC2 - The distinction between synoptic variability and a weekly emission cycle requires direct testing.
Data sets
data for Synoptic-scale organization of multi-day black carbon variability in a regional-background environment over eastern China Shuo Ding https://doi.org/10.17632/2bbrmffbpr.1
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 254 | 108 | 40 | 402 | 60 | 43 | 41 |
- HTML: 254
- PDF: 108
- XML: 40
- Total: 402
- Supplement: 60
- BibTeX: 43
- EndNote: 41
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Ding et al. investigates the synoptic-scale variability of black carbon concentrations at a regional-background site in eastern China using a combination of long-term observations, wavelet analysis, backward trajectories, and meteorological data. The study is generally well organized, and the results provide useful insights into the role of atmospheric transport and ventilation in regulating multi-day BC variability. The analysis is comprehensive, and the conclusions are generally supported by the results. I believe the manuscript is suitable for publication in ACP after dealing with the following comments.
#1. The authors rely on PBLH to explain the differences in BC concentrations among transport regimes. However, the PBLH data are obtained from CAMS reanalysis rather than direct observations. I would suggest that the authors provide more information on the spatial and temporal resolution of the CAMS PBLH data and discuss their potential uncertainties. Has the CAMS PBLH been evaluated against local observations at or near the measurement site? In particular, the reported mean PBLH values of 431 m and 593 m for the Regional/slow and NE/coastal regimes, respectively, may not represent a substantial difference when considering potential reanalysis uncertainties. It would also be helpful to provide the variability or distribution of PBLH within each regime and, if possible, compare daytime and nighttime PBLH and their relationships with BC concentrations, as boundary layer dynamics can differ considerably between day and night.
#2. The discussion of different air-mass transport regimes is primarily based on BC concentrations, meteorological conditions, and backward trajectories. I wonder whether measurements of other air pollutants, such as PM2.5, or PM2.5 chemical components, are available at or near the monitoring site. If available, incorporating these observations could provide additional insights into the characteristics and potential sources of different air masses, particularly the differences between the Regional/slow and NE/coastal regimes. Such information would help strengthen the physical interpretation of the transport classifications and their influence on BC variability. If these measurements are not available, a brief discussion of this limitation would be helpful.
#3. In Section 2.3 (Lines 147–150), the authors define high-BC episodes as periods when BC concentrations exceed the 95th percentile for at least six consecutive hours. Could the authors further justify the selection of this 6-hour threshold? A brief sensitivity analysis using alternative thresholds (e.g., 3 and 12 hours) would help demonstrate whether the identification of high-BC episodes and the associated conclusions are sensitive to this choice.
#4. The text and labels in Figure 3 are too small to read clearly. I suggest that the authors increase the font sizes to improve the readability of the figure.