the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Modifying Windsonds to Improve In-Storm Measurements
Abstract. Obtaining reliable thermodynamic and kinematic profiles from within severe convective storms presents a challenge for radiosondes due to the extreme conditions to which the instrumentation is exposed. The Windsond S1 has emerged as a popular tool for severe storm research; however, exposure to heavy precipitation has been recently documented to cause relative humidity (RH) sensor malfunctions, limiting the reliability of in-storm measurements. We introduce modifications to the Windsond S1 design that limit water ingress and thereby mitigate these issues. The modifications include a redesigned radiation shield that blocks falling raindrops while maintaining adequate ventilation, a stabilizing support arm, and a tether seal. Controlled experiments using irrigation-generated precipitation at approximately 300 mm hr-1 demonstrated that unmodified sondes experienced RH sensor failures, suppressed RH variability, and power failures due to water ingress, while modified sondes remained functional throughout the exposure to the extreme rain rate. Validation profiles comparing modified and unmodified sondes launched under varied atmospheric conditions, including nocturnal flights, showed temperature differences of typically less than 1 °C and RH differences less than 10 %, with no systematic biases introduced by the modifications. These design improvements were applied to an extensive number of Windsonds S1 during the 2025 ICECHIP field campaign for in-storm deployments. Tested modifications to the Windsond S1 require minimal expertise to implement. Further, design files have been made publicly available to support the broader severe storms research community.
- Preprint
(4112 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-530', Anonymous Referee #1, 12 May 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-530', Anonymous Referee #2, 04 Nov 2026
The manuscript “Modifying Windsonds to Improve In-Storm Measurements” presents practical modifications to the Windsond S1 intended to reduce water ingress and improve measurements in heavy precipitation. The work addresses an important observational challenge in convective-cloud and severe-storm research. Its practical relevance, relatively accessible modifications, and publicly available design files make it a potentially substantial contribution to the community and clearly place it within the scope of "Atmospheric Measurement Techniques".
However, the validation is not yet sufficiently comprehensive to support several of the manuscript’s conclusions. The experiments provide promising evidence that the modifications reduce water ingress and prevent some obvious instrument malfunctions under the tested conditions. They provide less convincing evidence that the modified sondes accurately measure ambient temperature and humidity in precipitation, or that the modifications introduce no systematic biases or changes in response time. These distinctions should be addressed explicitly.
I therefore recommend more clearly separating instrument robustness from measurement accuracy, better characterizing instrument-to-instrument variability, interpreting the comparison statistics more rigorously, and providing additional methodological information to support reproducibility.
Major comments
- Section 4 demonstrates that the modified sonde avoided visible water ingress and the conspicuous failures observed in the unmodified sondes. However, neither the irrigation experiment nor the ground-based thunderstorm comparison includes an independent reference measurement establishing the ambient temperature and RH. Consequently, the modified sonde cannot automatically be treated as the correct reference simply because its measurements appear plausible and it remains operational. The statement that it allowed “accurate measurements of the environment” is therefore stronger than the evidence presented.
- The authors suggest that the temperature offsets in DU1 and IOP21 likely arise from factory calibration differences. However, no preflight intercomparison or independent calibration results are presented to support that attribution. Table 3 reports mean temperature differences of approximately −0.98 K and +1.46 K for these flights, respectively, which are appreciably larger than the typical temperature accuracy listed in Table 1. Were the paired sondes compared under common, stable, well-ventilated conditions before launch? Please report any available preflight checks and clarify whether instruments were new or reused, whether the same instruments participated in multiple tests, and whether all instruments used the same hardware and firmware versions.
- The statement in Section 5 that very high correlations imply the absence of time-dependent or height-dependent biases is not justified. High correlation can coexist with substantial constant offsets or proportional biases; moreover, temperature profiles spanning a large vertical range can be strongly correlated despite measurement differences that are scientifically important. The manuscript already provides useful scatterplots, mean differences, and standard deviations, but these do not establish equivalence between configurations.
Specific and minor comments
- Table 1: Please distinguish accuracy from repeatability; these terms are not interchangeable. Identify the source and applicable conditions for the specifications. Section 5 discusses measurements below −40 °C, whereas Table 1 lists −40 °C as the lower measurement limit. Please explain the interpretation and quality control of these observations.
- Figure 3: It might provide more insight if you use a similar scatter plot (like Figure 12) to compare Sonde 1 and Sonde 2.
- Figures 4–10: Please consider reconciling these figures and maybe moving them to the SI.
- Difference conventions: Figure 4 defines the temperature difference as unmodified minus modified, whereas Table 3 defines differences as modified minus unmodified. Please use a consistent convention throughout.
- Modification details: Although the design files and assembly instructions are valuable, please summarize the added mass, materials, key dimensions, approximate assembly time, and cost in the manuscript. Clarify which model variants were actually tested, as the conclusions mention applicability to H1, H2, and H3 models.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-530-RC2
Data sets
Windsond S1H2 modifications for observations in rain J. S. Soderholm et al. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18228081
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 702 | 404 | 101 | 1,207 | 85 | 128 |
- HTML: 702
- PDF: 404
- XML: 101
- Total: 1,207
- BibTeX: 85
- EndNote: 128
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Overall Comments:
This is a fantastic and well written paper that highlights a major observational challenge for an actively used instrument. This type of work is critical to ensuring that observations are accurately representing the intended environment. The paper is well reasoned and laid out naturally, showing the process through which the authors identified the problem and solved it. I have only a few monitor comments that should be easily addressable, and I commend the authors on writing an excellent paper.
Specific Comments:
1). The authors provide a figure showing the modifications, but there is little/no description on how the modifications should be attached or if there are specifics to avoid while doing so. More details should be added, even if brief, that describe the process of putting the modifications on so that an average user following this would know how to use the modifications.
2). The authors mention sealing the top lid with a hot glue to prevent water intrusion. Would this not also disable the ability of the sonde to cut the balloon?
3). Lines 123-124 - when describing the second test (the pendulum), there is not that only a single modified sonde was used. Is there justification for not doing this test with both a modified and unmodified sonde? I imagine the thought is that test 1 showed that water intrusion happens, but it's possible that the additional motion of the unmodified sonde could actually reduce water errors in some cases. Potentially not the intrusion, but with holding water on the sensor the added motion could help to dislodge and remove water from the sensor head, thereby reducing errors in this situation.
4). A theme throughout the tests presented that I noticed is that there is no external reference sensor being used. Ideally, a trusted 3rd, non-Windsonde sensor would've been placed in or near the environment to provide a ground truth observation point. As it stands, the experimental setup assumes that the modified windsonde is absolute truth, which may or may not be accurate. If there are still sensor errors being caused even with the modifications, it is impossible to tell without an independent observation. I doubt this information is available at this point, so this is more of a note for future tests and potentially an acknowledgement in the text that this is the assumption being applied.
5). Quick succession launches not on the same instrument train can have wildly different flight trajectories and experience different environments, particularly in convective environments where small spatial changes can result in large thermodynamic changes. The authors do explore the spatial differences between sondes in their analysis, but I think it's worth marking the individual flights as to whether they were on the same instrument train or not.
6). A note on solar radiation corrections - these are typically applied ALL the time. For other radiosonde companies, they cannot tell for example whether you are in cloud or not in cloud and whether the correction should or should not be applied. Generally speaking, I am familiar with one company at least that takes into account altitude, lat/lon position, time of day, time of year, etc. to calculate the solar radiation correction, but that correction is applied even if its going through a thick, sun blocking cloud. This presents problems as applying the solar radiation correction for example when under cloud and not in sunlight, will cause a negative temperature error. This is relevant as the DU1 flight showed a negative temperature bias (in full sun), whereas IPO21 showed a positive temperature bias in partly cloudy conditions. While not consistent between the cloudy vs sunny cases, I do wonder if the modifications made to the sonde have altered the solar radiation behavior and therefore are introducing additional errors when the solar radiation correction is applied. This would presumably manifest differently depending on the conditions.
Technical Corrections:
Line 25 - I would include a reference or point here to link back to Sparv for readers unfamiliar with the product or company, and to reference the company for their work.