CO2, CH4, and N2O Emissions from Urban Lawns in Southern China: Characteristics and Driving Mechanisms
Abstract. Urban lawns have expanded rapidly with urbanization, substantially influencing regional carbon budgets. However, research on their greenhouse gas (GHG) source-sink dynamics remains scarce and the driving mechanisms are poorly understood. This study investigated CO₂, CH₄, and N₂O fluxes from urban lawns beneath typical broad-leaved (BF) and coniferous (CF) forests in a major city in the Yangtze River Delta (YRD) region, China. The seasonal and diurnal patterns of GHG fluxes were characterized, and the roles of environmental factors and mowing management were analyzed. Results showed that CO₂ fluxes from both lawn types exhibited pronounced seasonal fluctuations, with higher emissions in summer and lower in winter. The mean annual CO₂ flux from CF lawns (17.805 ± 1.016 mg m⁻² min⁻¹) was significantly higher than that from BF lawns (7.643 ± 0.881 mg m⁻² min⁻¹). Diurnally, CO₂ fluxes displayed a "daytime low, nighttime high" pattern, contrasting with the typical "daytime high, nighttime low" unimodal pattern commonly observed in grassland soils. Annual mean CH₄ fluxes for the BF and CF lawns were −0.452 ± 0.027 μg m⁻² min⁻¹ and −0.565 ± 0.035 μg m⁻² min⁻¹, respectively, indicating net CH₄ uptake throughout the year, with soil volumetric water content (VWC) emerging as the key common regulatory factor. Diurnal CH₄ variations followed a "daytime high, nighttime low" pattern in spring and summer but showed no clear diurnal rhythm in autumn and winter. Annual mean N₂O fluxes were 0.212 ± 0.020 μg m⁻² min⁻¹ and 0.172 ± 0.022 μg m⁻² min⁻¹ for the BF and CF lawns, respectively, with higher emissions in spring-summer and lower in autumn-winter, indicating net N₂O emission overall. N₂O also deviated from the typical diurnal pattern, likely due to pronounced fluctuations in soil water content. Mowing management showed that spring mowing caused the least disturbance to GHG fluxes, summer mowing significantly enhanced CO₂ emissions, and autumn mowing promoted CH₄ uptake and N₂O emission. By combining structural equation modeling (SEM), random forest (RF) importance ranking, and SHAP analysis, we identified fundamentally distinct environmental driver regimes between the two canopy types: the BF lawn exhibited a "temperature–inorganic nitrogen dominated" pattern, whereas the CF lawn showed a "moisture–microbial–carbon pool co-regulation" pattern. Overall, urban lawns exhibit a unique GHG source–sink pattern and regulatory regimes distinct from those of natural grasslands. Quantifying their GHG budgets is of considerable scientific value for optimizing urban carbon management and advancing low‑carbon city development.
General comments
The manuscript presents an interesting dataset on GHG fluxes in urban lawns and the seasonal and diurnal variation. The dataset presented in this manuscript has potential value, particularly because measurements of both seasonal and diurnal GHG flux dynamics in urban green spaces are relatively interesting. However, the manuscript currently lacks a sufficiently clear scientific framework to support the analyses and conclusions presented.
My main concern is the lack of a clearly articulated scientific framework guiding the study. In its current form, the manuscript reads more like a report of measurements and subsequent statistical analyses than a hypothesis-driven scientific article. The manuscript presents a large number of measurements and environmental variables, which are then analysed for correlations and statistical relationships, but it remains unclear what the central scientific questions are, why the selected comparisons are particularly relevant, and what underlying ecological mechanisms the study aims to investigate. I believe that major conceptual and methodological revision is needed before the manuscript can make a convincing scientific contribution.
The study compares grass-covered areas in two parks dominated by different functional groups of trees (deciduous versus coniferous). However, the scientific rationale for this comparison needs to be established more clearly from the start. Why is the distinction between deciduous- and conifer-dominated parks expected to influence GHG fluxes? What are the expected mechanisms and processes underlying these differences? Is the focus on the influence of tree functional groups on the functioning of the grass-covered areas, or is the study primarily investigating the effects of different tree root systems and their interactions with soil processes?
Furthermore, given the substantial tree cover at the study sites, it is worth reconsidering whether these areas should be characterised as urban lawns or rather as the ground vegetation and soil of tree-dominated urban parks. The considerable contribution of tree roots and other tree-related processes may be central to the measured soil GHG fluxes, and this should be acknowledged when defining the study system and interpreting the findings.
I would strongly encourage the authors to reconsider the overall framing of the manuscript. The Introduction would be stronger if it formulated explicit research questions and/or hypotheses. These should then guide the selection of variables, statistical analyses, and interpretation of the results. Rather than presenting all possible correlations between the measured variables, the manuscript would benefit from a more focused, theory-driven analysis addressing the ecological mechanisms most relevant to the research objectives.
The following specific comments address these concerns as well as several methodological and reporting issues.
Specific comments
Abstract and Introduction
Materials and methods
Results and figures
Statistical analyses and interpretation
I have some concerns regarding the use and interpretation of the SEM analysis.
The SEM appears to relate instantaneous GHG fluxes to a range of environmental and soil variables, but the temporal and spatial scales of variation of these explanatory variables are not sufficiently considered. Some of the included variables, such as TC, SOC, TN, and C/N ratio, represent relatively large and spatially heterogeneous soil pools. Their actual temporal variation within a single study site over the course of one year is likely to be limited compared with their spatial variation.
If these variables are sampled monthly using a small number of soil samples from a single site, it is questionable whether the resulting measurements capture genuine temporal variation. Instead, the observed differences may largely reflect sampling noise or spatial heterogeneity. Consequently, using these measurements as temporally varying explanatory variables for instantaneous GHG fluxes risks producing misleading statistical relationships.
More generally, the current SEM analysis does not appear to provide convincing new ecological insights. Although the selected variables may be relevant drivers of GHG fluxes in principle, their inclusion in a statistical model does not necessarily establish that the observed relationships represent meaningful ecological mechanisms. The model needs to be based on a clearly articulated conceptual understanding of the processes involved, including the expected causal pathways and the temporal scales at which the different variables operate.
I also have concerns about multicollinearity. Several of the included environmental and soil variables are likely to be strongly correlated. Have the authors adequately assessed and accounted for this in the statistical analyses?