the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Seasonal and local-time patterns of VTEC and dTEC RMS over Hainan: temporal and horizontal characteristics of winter and summer enhancements
Abstract. Background vertical total electron content (VTEC) and short-timescale TEC variability describe different aspects of the low-latitude ionosphere. Previous East Asian studies established winter daytime and warm-season nighttime disturbances, but it remained unclear whether the winter and summer enhancements have the same temporal and horizontal character. We analyzed daily-balanced GPS and BeiDou observations from 1,793 dates during 2015-2020 over Hainan. VTEC followed daytime plasma buildup and was strongest in autumn, with a later afternoon maximum in midsummer. Detrended TEC root-mean-square amplitude (dTEC RMS) instead peaked in winter afternoons and shifted toward late evening and midnight during spring and summer. We then compared BeiDou paths that remained near one ionospheric location with paths that crossed the surrounding region. In winter, both types showed the afternoon enhancement, including within comparable viewing directions. The winter structures therefore evolve over or pass through Hainan; a stationary horizontal gradient alone cannot explain the climatological maximum. In summer, the near-midnight enhancement was also present at nearly fixed locations, confirming a temporal increase, but its strength changed markedly among viewing directions and sampled regions. The summer structures are therefore more likely concentrated in particular regions or directions than spread uniformly across the Hainan sector. Spring and autumn show the orderly transition between these winter-afternoon and warm-season near-midnight environments. Together, the results show that winter and summer dTEC enhancements share temporal development but differ in their horizontal distribution.
- Preprint
(2177 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(1523 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5242', Anonymous Referee #1, 23 Oct 2026
-
AC1: 'Author response to Anonymous Referee #1', Zheng Wang, 13 Nov 2026
We thank Anonymous Referee #1 for the constructive comments. Our detailed point-by-point response is provided in the attached PDF, including the completed F10.7 comparison and the proposed clarifications to the physical interpretation. In accordance with the instructions for the final-response phase, we have not prepared or uploaded a revised manuscript.
Zheng Wang, on behalf of all co-authors
-
AC1: 'Author response to Anonymous Referee #1', Zheng Wang, 13 Nov 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5242', Anonymous Referee #2, 03 Nov 2026
This study uses six years of GNSS TEC data to investigate seasonal and local-time patterns in VTEC and detrended TEC RMS over Hainan. The authors suggest that the winter afternoon enhancement and the summer near-midnight enhancement may differ in their directional and spatial distributions, a result of some significance for low-latitude ionosphere research. However, whether a comparison based solely on IPP motion characteristics can identify specific physical structures or determine their spatial distribution remains a question of feasibility that requires further justification. My major concerns are as follows.
1. The nearly fixed IPP of GEO satellites can sample only a limited region; and since TEC is an integrated quantity, GEO TEC does not necessarily represent the physical state at a strictly fixed ionospheric location. Observations from moving IPPs, by contrast, contain the effects of both temporal evolution and spatial sampling. Please state more explicitly in the text what a comparison between GEO TEC and TEC from other satellites can and cannot distinguish.
2. dTEC RMS can be used to measure the amplitude of short-timescale TEC variability, but it is not the only criterion for identifying MSTIDs, spread-F structures, or other small- and medium-scale processes. Identifying MSTIDs requires observations of the propagation of the disturbance in TEC from multiple GNSS stations; spread F requires direct observation with an ionosonde, or discrimination using the S4 index or ROTI from GNSS scintillation receivers. Unless the manuscript provides diagnostic evidence that supports such attribution, please avoid wording that implies a specific disturbance type. In the Discussion, the observed seasonal variations should be distinguished from hypotheses about the underlying mechanisms, and the observations still needed to determine the physical processes should be stated.
Some minor concerns:
The grammar throughout the text needs careful revision. A few examples are listed here:
Line 14: “analyzed daily-balanced GPS and BeiDou observations” — I do not fully understand what this means.
Line 15: “VTEC followed daytime plasma buildup and was strongest in autumn” is a vague description. What is “daytime plasma buildup”?
Line 17: “We then compared BeiDou paths...” — do you mean “we then compared the VTEC measured along BeiDou paths...”?
Line 33: “The amount of plasma and the strength of short-timescale structure are related but different properties.” I cannot understand this.
Line 34: “A high-VTEC ionosphere can be smooth.” I cannot understand this.
Line 39: “Two-dimensional TEC perturbation maps made the spatial evolution of traveling ionospheric disturbances visible over dense receiver networks” should be revised to “The spatial evolution of traveling ionospheric disturbances is made visible in two-dimensional TEC perturbation maps constructed from dense receiver-network data”.
Lines 78–80: I do not quite follow the data-processing procedure described here. One or two equations would help clarify it.
Line 160, Fig. 1a: What does the number given for each month in the calendar represent?Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-5242-RC2 -
AC2: 'Author response to Anonymous Referee #2', Zheng Wang, 13 Nov 2026
We thank Anonymous Referee #2 for the constructive comments. Our detailed point-by-point response is provided in the attached PDF. It clarifies the interpretation of the IPP comparison, distinguishes observations from candidate mechanisms, and addresses each comment on the wording and processing description. In accordance with the instructions for the final-response phase, we have not prepared or uploaded a revised manuscript.
Zheng Wang, on behalf of all co-authors
-
AC2: 'Author response to Anonymous Referee #2', Zheng Wang, 13 Nov 2026
Data sets
Figure source data and derived statistics for seasonal reorganization and near-midnight localization of short-timescale TEC variability over low-latitude Hainan Zheng Wang; Yusen Tian https://doi.org/10.57760/sciencedb.00zln
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 263 | 157 | 58 | 478 | 78 | 61 | 63 |
- HTML: 263
- PDF: 157
- XML: 58
- Total: 478
- Supplement: 78
- BibTeX: 61
- EndNote: 63
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
The paper presents a climatology of VTEC and dTEC RMS over Hainan using BeiDou orbital geometry to separate temporal from spatial ionospheric structures. The approach is original, the dataset is large and well documented, and the robustness tests in the supplement are convincing. The single-station limitation is honestly acknowledged. Figures 2–11 are well organised and adequately discussed in the text. I recommend publication after moderate revisions on the physical interpretation.
Major comments
The discussion identifies plausible mechanisms for both the winter and summer enhancements, but in my opinion it does not fully exploit the data to constrain them. The GEO vs. IGSO/MEO comparison is the methodological strength of the paper and could be used more explicitly to favour or disfavour specific drivers. For the winter case, the near-identity across motion classes already argues against a stationary horizontal gradient; making this point explicit would strengthen the interpretation. Additionally, the six-year dataset spans a wide range of solar activity (F10.7 ~65–200 sfu). A simple split by high/low F10.7 would help clarify whether enhancement amplitude scales with background plasma density, which is relevant for distinguishing MSTID-like processes from other candidates.
On a related note, the paper cites MSTID, spread-F, and plasma-bubble literature for the summer near-midnight enhancement, but does not directly compare the observed seasonal timing and amplitude with the occurrence statistics reported in those works. Discussing whether the observations are consistent or not with the known regional climatology of these phenomena would make the physical interpretation more grounded.
Finally, the non-linear dependence of dTEC RMS on background VTEC shown in Figure 1e is relevant to whether the enhancement is driven by a density-dependent process, as MSTIDs generally are. A brief interpretive remark on this would be welcome.
Minor comment
Figure 1 combines coverage maps, activity index time series, and a diagnostic result in a single figure. Moving the methodological panels to the supplement, where similar material already appears, would improve readability.