Atmospheric forcing and winter landfast sea ice fracture activity near Tuktoyaktuk, Arctic Canada
Abstract. Landfast sea ice (LFSI) is a crucial socio-ecological component of the Arctic climate system, regulating ocean-atmosphere fluxes, buffering against coastal erosion, and providing a vital travel medium for hunting and transportation in Indigenous communities such as Tuktoyaktuk in the Northwest Territories of Canada. However, accelerated Arctic warming is reducing the extent, thickness, and strength of sea ice. These changes make the ice more susceptible to mechanical failure and breakup. This study investigates the atmospheric drivers and associated LFSI-pack ice interactions around Tuktoyaktuk Northwest Territories, Canada. Using satellite-based Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR), we identified 48 discrete fracture events between 2016 and 2023. These events exhibited substantial interannual variability, ranging from 3 events in 2016–2017 to 15 events in 2022–2023, out of which 38 of the 48 events (79.2%) occurred between December and March. Based on the midpoint-based nominal dates, 68.8% of LFSI fractures occurred during, or within three days following, enhanced synoptic-scale pressure-gradient forcing. Matched-control analysis showed significantly higher wind speeds on nominal fracture dates than on matched non-fracture dates (median difference = 4.9 km h−1, p = 1×10−4). Fracture events were also commonly associated with elevated wind speeds and predominantly offshore wind directions (ESE, SE, and E). These fractures highlight the sensitivity of the LFSI edge to synoptic weather patterns and may provide indicators of localized LFSI instability.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of The Cryosphere.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
The paper examines atmospheric processes around land fast sea ice (LFSI) breakout events using Sentinel-1 EW imagery and appropriate atmospheric forcing data in Taktoyaktuk, Canada. The paper has a clear narrative and is easy to follow. The results tell a good story about the atmospheric processes (wind speed, land originating winds, pressure gradients etc) and they are tied correctly to localised mechanical forcing in the LFSI. I recommend this paper for publication subject to a few minor revisions. The authors can find a detailed discussion and comments from me below:
A nice overall introduction, in my opinion it remains important to define any abbreviations not necessarily known by external readers at first mention, e.g. MODIS.
Line 24: LFSI can also be attached to island shores, or grounded by shallow bathymetry.
Line 32: It could be worth mentioning that LFSI alters primary production by regulating light transmission.
Line 35: LFSI does also moderate glacier ocean heat exchanges too.
Line 53: In my opinion, defining MODIS, or any other remote sensing instrument at first mention can help avoid any confusion.
Line 57: I see that SAR is already defined in the abstract, very good.
Line 66: I would correct this from (Chaudhary et al., 2025) to Chaudhary et al., (2025) because it is being used as an example in the text, rather than a standalone citation.
Line 67: I would define ERA5. What does ERA stand for?
After Line 75, I would add a few sentences to describe the structure of the paper. "The paper is organised as follows: Section 2 does this, Section 3 does that etc."
The study area is well described and local processes easily understood.
Because this paper focuses primarily on atmospheric forcing, I wonder if it is worth briefly mentioning that ocean forcing would also have an influence on your results, for example, sea temperatures, salinity measurements etc.
Line 109: This is very true, revisit times can sometimes miss out localised breakout events, which can happen in a very short space of time. Avoiding the influence of the polar night, which I assume ends around mid to late January, did you consider validating any Sentinel-1 scenes with optical imagery from Landsat here?
Line 114: Also worth mentioning that calm open water or smooth ice backscatter values can also be masked below the noise floor.
Line 118: Good to mention this, also could form a sub section in the discussion section since it is a limitation.
Line 136: Is this mean sea level pressure? MSLP. Define the abbreviation at first mention.
Line 140: So it is mostly tidal influences as your main oceanographic data. Perhaps one could mention that a more extensive oceanographic dataset was not available, or beyond the scope of the paper (since it is atmospheric forcing you focus on). Were there any moorings available?
Line 149: What speckle filter was used? Boxcar, Lee refined? Was any thermal noise removal included?
Line 159: Also dielectric properties, which are very important with spatial SAR backscatter, especially if LFSI has a wet surface or is completely dry.
Line 165: This can also be called a sliding window technique, but I think what you describe is the same approach.
In my opinion the applied methods and techniques are valid and suitable.
Figure 3: To me the New Ice (a) and Fast Ice (b) distributions look the same, just different colours? Are there any differences here? I understand that new ice is ice that has just formed, does that same ice all become fast ice?
Overall the results section is very good and tells a nice story about the atmospheric forcing influences, I do not suggest any changes here. I am curious to know if precipitation events could have affected SAR backscatter values, because of the introduction of surface liquid water or a snowpack.
Line 347: Here you do indeed mention that LFSI can also be grounded by shallow bathymetry.
In the discussion section, the limitations of SAR (noise floor, incidence angles) and the pauctiy of oceanographic data are left unmentioned. A brief mention of re-visit times is included, and I can understand justifying the midpoint between 2 consecutive acquisition dates. High wind speeds would strongly influence the backscatter dB values, so even a brief mention of this is valuable.
Line 387: In my opinion, high resolution dual pol Sentinel imagery would be ideal for fracture risk management, but I would also consider a higher resolution sensor. While not ideal for long term monitoring, using a mutli sensor approach that includes quad pol (fully polarimetric) SAR could also map geophysical detail of those fracture zones, which would validate the Sentinel-1 baseline. Perhaps ideas for future work. Interferometric wide swath Sentinel-1 has a higher resolution than EW mode, but of course the data has to be available for the Tuktoyaktuk region.
5. Conclusions. You crucially pointed out that seasonal melt breakup differs from local mechanical forcing events. Perhaps worth mentioning that this local variation is not an indicator of long term climate trends?
Line 425 and 426: Are these references from websites or reports? It seems that some information is missing here.