the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Vertical aerosol flux in urban ecosystem: how far can we push Doppler lidar aerosol observations?
Abstract. This work presents analysis of Doppler lidar-derived vertical aerosol fluxes in urban ecosystems. Based on long-term multi-seasonal measurements, we characterized the dependence of aerosol flux occurrence frequency, direction of the transport and velocity regime on seasons, diurnal cycle and altitude. To synthesize the results, we introduced the term aerosol flux intensity factor and applied it based on the aerosol flux parameters described above. This constitutes the first data analysis and characterization of vertical aerosol fluxes for an urban environment, based on multi-year (2022–2024) Doppler lidar data in Warsaw, Poland. For additional data filtering, we used data products from co-located microwave radiometer and disdrometer. The measurements were conducted within the routine observations of the Cloud Observations Network (Cloudnet-ACTRIS) at the Warsaw Observatory Station (WOS), an ACTRIS National Facility operated by the University of Warsaw, located on the roof platform of the Institute of Geophysics, Faculty of Physics, University of Warsaw (IGF UW). We observed that aerosol fluxes are most intense during Spring (MAM), particularly at the lowest altitudes during the midday Well-Mixed Layer presence. Summer and autumn (JJA and SON) represent transition periods between spring and winter (DJF), while in winter the aerosol flux intensity is generally low. Our findings suggest that the seasonal distribution of aerosol flux intensity is strongly asymmetric. After DJF, abrupt changes in vertical transport lead to a rapid intensification of aerosol fluxes over a single seasonal transition, while after spring the intensity decreases gradually. This work contributes to the multi-seasonal characterisation of aerosol flux intensity, providing a priori knowledge for aerosol vertical transport in the urban environment, and enhancing atmospheric aerosol optical property assessments, particularly in calculations based on temporal averages. The proposed methodology provides the basis for performing similar analysis at other ecosystems or measurement sites.
- Preprint
(5694 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 22 Nov 2026)
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5029', Anonymous Referee #1, 09 Oct 2026
reply
The comment was uploaded in the form of a supplement: https://egusphere.copernicus.org/preprints/2026/egusphere-2026-5029/egusphere-2026-5029-RC1-supplement.pdfReplyCitation: https://doi.org/
10.5194/egusphere-2026-5029-RC1 -
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5029', Anonymous Referee #2, 11 Oct 2026
reply
The comment was uploaded in the form of a supplement: https://egusphere.copernicus.org/preprints/2026/egusphere-2026-5029/egusphere-2026-5029-RC2-supplement.pdf
-
RC3: 'Review of egusphere-2026-5029', Anonymous Referee #3, 02 Nov 2026
reply
The paper presents a valuable dataset: three years of height-resolved Doppler lidar flux estimates from an urban ACTRIS site, screened with co-located radiometer and disdrometer data. The descriptive findings are plausible and consistent with the figures. Upward transport is strong near the surface at midday in spring and summer, weak and mixed at night, and weak and noisy in winter.
The main problems are in how the work is presented, not in the analysis itself.
- Title: it promises a study of method limits that the text does not deliver, and the novelty claim needs a clearer gap and the Leipzig case study acknowledged.
- Interpretation: several statements go further than the figures. These are the “strongly asymmetric” seasonal cycle, the low winter intensity, the link to ABL height, which is never shown, and the improved optical-property accuracy, which is never demonstrated.
- Terms: “resuspension” and “sedimentation” should be defined as a sign convention.
- Signal availability: “flux occurrence” is really the frequency of valid signal, so the intensity factor partly reflects data availability.
- Humidity filter: it relies on radiometer humidity with an uncertainty larger than its thresholds, and the Table 1 notation is unclear.
- Stationarity: the decision to skip the test is reasonable, but l. 178 contradicts the 31% stationary result.
- Text–figure mismatches: a few small ones remain, including the altitude limit, Table 2 and Fig. 12.
None of this requires re-doing the analysis. It needs clearer wording, more careful claims and a few explanations. I recommend minor-to-moderate revision. The optional additions (ABL height overlay, a robustness figure with sample sizes, a null test for the flux) would strengthen the paper.
A detailed review is attached. -
RC4: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-5029', Anonymous Referee #4, 06 Nov 2026
reply
The manuscript “Vertical aerosol flux in urban ecosystem: how far can we push Doppler lidar aerosol observations?” presents an innovative application of the eddy-covariance (EC) method to a unique dataset of vertical aerosol profiles measured in an urban environment in Warsaw, Poland. The topic is fully within the scope of Atmospheric Measurement Techniques (AMT). Overall, the manuscript is written in accordance with the conventions of scientific publishing, has a logical structure, and presents a coherent line of argument. The conclusions are supported by the results presented. For these reasons, I believe that the manuscript merits publication in AMT.
The manuscript contains no major errors or ambiguities and could, in principle, be published in its present form. Nevertheless, addressing the comments below would further strengthen the paper.
- Flux calculation: The authors introduce the quantity “aerosol flux velocity” by normalizing the covariance by the mean value. The rationale for introducing this quantity, rather than analysing the flux directly as a covariance, is that the attenuated backscatter coefficient depends on turbulence; the normalization is therefore intended to remove impact of the mean value (“In this way, one could argue that the absolute backscatter doesn't influence, as the result is normalized”). However, a covariance is calculated using deviations from the mean, so the mean value itself does not affect it – this is a well-known property of the EC method. Why, then, use a velocity that is relatively difficult to interpret physically instead of the flux itself?
- Flux divergence and the continuity equation: If horizontal homogeneity is assumed (i.e. horizontal transport is neglected), a change in aerosol flux with height (represented here by the aerosol flux velocity) implies aerosol accumulation in layers where the influx exceeds the outflux. In the dataset analysed, the aerosol flux is generally positive near the surface and close to zero at the upper measurement limit, as clearly illustrated in Fig. 7. What, then, happens to these aerosols, given the authors’ statement that “advection effects … was also bypassed, as … do not represent predominant phenomena in our dataset”? What aerosol concentrations would be expected after several or a dozen of such days?
- Alternative flux calculation: Since the paper introduces an innovative approach to estimating aerosol fluxes, it would be worthwhile to check whether the fluxes calculated using the proposed method are consistent with fluxes estimated from the temporal change in concentration at a given height.
- Technical comment on Fig. 4: The panel on the right is intended to be an enlargement of the panel on the left. However, in the left panel, near zero, the PDF is higher for stationary cases, whereas in the right panel it is higher for non-stationary cases.
- Stationarity test: For flux values close to zero, the applied stationarity test (often referred to as the Foken test) may artificially indicate non-stationarity because of division by a value close to zero. It would be worth checking whether the percentage of non-stationary fluxes is exceptionally high for values close to zero. This could provide an additional argument for not taking the results of this stationarity test into account.
- Title: The current title suggests a considerably broader scope than that of the paper, possibly that of a review article. It should be revised to reflect the actual content more precisely.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-5029-RC4
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 342 | 188 | 72 | 602 | 76 | 69 |
- HTML: 342
- PDF: 188
- XML: 72
- Total: 602
- BibTeX: 76
- EndNote: 69
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1