Distribution and biogeochemical controls of dissolved cobalamin (vitamin B12) in the western North Pacific
Abstract. Vitamin B12 (cobalamin) is an essential micronutrient for many marine microorganisms, yet its distribution and biogeochemical controls in the open ocean, particularly below the euphotic zone, remain poorly constrained. We investigated the vertical and zonal distributions of four dissolved cobalamin species from the surface to the deep western North Pacific. Total dissolved cobalamin (TD-B12) concentrations ranged from below detection to 1.63 pM and were generally low in surface waters. Elevated concentrations occurred below the subsurface chlorophyll maximum (SCM), extended into the upper North Pacific Intermediate Water (NPIW) at northern stations, and were also observed locally in bottom waters. Hydroxocobalamin (OH-B12) was the dominant dissolved form throughout most of the water column. From the surface to the upper NPIW, TD-B12 increased with apparent oxygen utilization (AOU), consistent with a contribution of organic matter remineralization to cobalamin accumulation. TD-B12 was also positively associated with the relative abundance of Nitrosopumiliaceae inferred from 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing, indicating an association between cobalamin accumulation and microbial community composition. In contrast, the relationship between TD-B12 and AOU disappeared below the lower NPIW, suggesting that remineralization alone cannot explain cobalamin distributions at greater depths. Elevated cobalamin within the upper NPIW suggests a role for intermediate-water transport, whereas localized bottom-water enrichment may reflect benthic sources and deep-water circulation. Overall, dissolved cobalamin distributions reflect a depth-dependent balance among microbial cycling, degradation, and physical transport.
General:
This is a very interesting manuscript investigating vertical and zonal distributions of vitamin B12 integrated together with hydrographic observations and microbial community data in order to identify biogeochemical processes controlling B12 distribution. As the authors note, vertical deep-water profiles for B12 remain scarce, as does our understanding of processes controlling B12 availability and this manuscript advances both. The Results are clearly presented and the Discussion is thorough yet concise. My main concerns relate to the Methods section, which is missing key details needed to replicate this study, especially those that a) have been shown to influence B12 recovery (e.g., flow-rate of SPE step) and b) those that directly affect the calculation of B12 abundance (e.g., the recovery rate). The recovery correction is my main concern as it affects all reported concentrations and the robustness of the data cannot be judged without more information. For that reason, I have rated 2) Scientific quality as "Fair" only. Please find detailed comments below.
Specific comments:Â
Methods:
2.1 sample collection:
L65-70: Please add the flow-rate of the SPE-extraction step as this has been previously shown to influence the recovery rate. See:
2.2 Cobalamin analysis:
Specific questions on the recovery experiment:
2.4 Other parameters:
Other recommendations:
Fig. 2: I recommend using the same y-value range for B12-concentrations in all panels. Currently, OH-B12 and TD-B12 range from 0-2 pM, while the other congeners only range from 0-0.5 pM. Since they all use the same color gradient, colors do not show the same concentrations in different panels which makes it difficult for the reader to compare panels.
Fig. 3: As for Fig. 2, I recommend to harmonise the y-range and colour-scale for panels d-f to facilitate comparison.
Section 3.4 and Fig. 6: It appears as if B12-values