the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Stable isotope proxies from Aotearoa New Zealand peatlands and their potential for reconstructing Southern Annular Mode variability
Abstract. Peatlands dominated by the wire rush Empodisma spp. are widely distributed across Aotearoa New Zealand and hold considerable potential as archives for reconstructing past variability in the Southern Annular Mode, the dominant mode of Southern Hemisphere climate variability. However, the mechanistic links between climate, hydrology, and stable isotope signals in Empodisma cellulose remain incompletely understood. Here, using spatial (13 sites) and temporal (monthly, two sites) datasets, we examine the environmental controls on Empodisma cellulose δ13C and δ18O and their suitability for palaeoclimate reconstruction. We confirm strong spatial relationships between δ13C and temperature across the Aotearoa New Zealand latitudinal transect, consistent with carbon isotope discrimination theory under non-water-limited conditions and demonstrate that moisture variables exert no significant site-scale control, although a secondary within-site relationship with water-table depth is resolved. For δ18O, we show that internal root and shoot waters are systematically offset from root-associated water, with a species-dependent offset (Empodisma robustum > E. minus), and that the mean of internal root and shoot water is the best-performing source for predicting root cellulose δ18O in a mechanistic model. Isotope mixing modelling reveals that root water is the dominant contributor to cellulose oxygen, but that this partitioning varies systematically with season and species. Initial downcore analysis at North and South Island sites records coherent multi-decadal trends in both proxies whose relative amplitudes follow the species-dependent partitioning predicted by the modern calibration. Once corrected for the atmospheric Suess effect, however, both proxies enrich over the industrial period in the direction that would be expected from rising CO2 rather than from circulation change, indicating that pre-industrial records will be required to isolate a SAM signal. These results provide a mechanistic basis for interpreting Empodisma cellulose isotope records as proxies for past temperature and atmospheric circulation variability across the Southern Hemisphere mid-latitudes.
- Preprint
(4794 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(468 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 25 Nov 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4962', Anonymous Referee #1, 16 Nov 2026 reply
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 237 | 158 | 64 | 459 | 75 | 69 | 63 |
- HTML: 237
- PDF: 158
- XML: 64
- Total: 459
- Supplement: 75
- BibTeX: 69
- EndNote: 63
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
This study examines Empodisma spp. peatlands in New Zealand as proxies for southern hemisphere climate variability using cellulose d13C and d18O across a latitudinal transect to determine the environmental controls and determine their suitability for paleoclimate reconstruction. The authors find strong relationships between d13C and temperature across the latitudinal transect, in the absence of water limitation. They involve an isotope mixing model to determine that root water is the dominant contributor to cellulose oxygen, which varies systematically with season and species. The main advance over the previous study on cellulose oxygen isotopes from these restiad peatlands is the improved mechanistic understanding of fractionation between root water and internal plant water.
Downcore analyses reveal coherent trends but reveal that the Suess effect exerts control on the signal in the industrial period, indicating the need to factor in rising CO2 into the interpretation.
The authors point out and provide further hypotheses for observations from field data that could be answered via experimentation with temperature and moisture manipulation.
The study is well designed and thoughtfully laid out.
Specific comments:
Line 134-135: awkward wording: ‘For carbon (Amesbury et al., 2015b), we found…” Perhaps change to ‘Amesbury et al., 2015 found carbon isotopes were negatively correlated with…”
Line 142,146: CO2—subscript missing
Line 147-148: same comment as above: “For oxygen (Amesbury…), we found…”
Line 151: “These findings motivated…expanded beyond Sphagnum…” Perhaps more explicitly link the need for measuring and recording internal waters and here more explicitly indicate how this study differs from Amesbury et al., 2015 and how it moves the science forward.
Line 219: perhaps provide an introductory sentence of that indicates how this study methods differ or advance Amesbury et al., 2015
Line 256-259: ‘standard bleaching procedures’ samples were only bleached to obtain cellulose? Can you provide more details about the reagents used for cellulose extraction?
Line 308: did you consider that εb could have varied across your latitudinal gradient? See Sternberg and Elsworth, 2011 indicating the possibility of a temperature effect.
Line 473: can you show errors to these isotopic offsets provided?
Line 611: “this indicates” indicate here what ‘this’ is referring to
Figure 7: are all sites at the same elevation? If temperature exerts the strongest control, what does this look like against temperature?
720: d13C and water table depth; I’m curious how cellulose d13C differs from bulk organic d13C
Line 847: perhaps briefly reiterate H4 here (and elsewhere where hypotheses are mentioned in the discussion)
Line 964: missing word? “all moisture correlations were? Non-significant)?
Line 974: “possible physiological…” it seems this sentence could use some references.
Line 996: are E. robustum and E. minus easily distinguished downcore? Is there evidence that these species may have shifted at these sites on Holocene timescales? How difficult is it to distinguish these species?
Line 1008: to make the case for the dual d13C and d18O, the authors could consider adding a conceptual model of what these two could do to improve interpretation of downcore results
Section 4.6: the discussion is interesting and nicely lays out the factors that could contribute to understanding the isotopic shifts occurring in the instrumental part of the record as it relates to modes of climate variability, but I also was left wondering if there have been any changes in precipitation (mean annual) or seasonality that could explain the shift toward more enriched values.