Distributed snow modeling across contrasting climatic regimes: Forcing sensitivity and regime-dependent assimilation
Abstract. Mountain snowpacks regulate seasonal water availability in climatically diverse headwater basins, yet long-term distributed snow observations remain sparse in complex mountainous terrain. This study investigates snow regime characteristics, forcing sensitivity, multi-source snow mapping consistency, and data assimilation effectiveness across contrasting climatic conditions over the 2003–2024 period in two hydrologically important basins in Türkiye: the Mediterranean-continental transition Seyhan Basin and the continental Upper Euphrates (Karasu) Basin. The spatially distributed S3M model was driven by three alternative meteorological forcing configurations (station observations, ERA5-Land, and MSWX-Past) and evaluated against ground measurements together with independent reanalysis and satellite products, including CERRA-Land, MODIS, and C-SNOW. Results demonstrate that forcing uncertainty primarily affects snow magnitude (snow water equivalent and snow depth), whereas snow-covered area (SCA) remains comparatively robust across forcing configurations (NSE 0.82-0.91). MSWX-Past consistently outperformed ERA5-Land, particularly in representing precipitation, substantially reducing systematic snow overestimation and improving agreement with independent snow observations. Spatial and long-term analyses further reveal an increasing prevalence of negative snow anomalies after 2013, accompanied by episodic decoupling between snow magnitude and persistence. Data assimilation exhibited pronounced regime-dependent behavior. In the transient Seyhan Basin, assimilation substantially improved local snow dynamics by correcting timing errors and premature melt cycles, increasing station-scale performance from KGE 0.28 to 0.61. In contrast, assimilation in the continental Karasu Basin primarily reduced large-scale accumulation biases through spatially coherent adjustments, while point-scale improvements remained spatially variable. Overall, the results demonstrate that forcing uncertainty primarily affects snow magnitude, whereas the effectiveness of data assimilation is strongly governed by snow-regime characteristics. These findings provide a transferable framework for distributed snow monitoring and demonstrate the operational potential of S3M for hydrological forecasting in climatically heterogeneous, data-scarce mountain basins.
Competing interests: At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of The Cryosphere.
Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
General comments
Very good research on the cryosphere with angle on the snowmelt process. Please, see my comments to improve the final version of the manuscript.
Specific comments
Lines 29-30. Insert more recent papers on snowmelt processes in mountain regions with links on stream flows:
- Yang T, Chen X, Hamdi R, Li L, Cui F, De Maeyer P, Duan W (2025) Rainfall‐driven extreme snowmelt will increase in the Tianshan and Pamir regions under future climate projection. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 130(1), e2024JD042323.
- Medici G, Jourde H, Cinkus G, Manetta M, Lorenzi V, Ghaderpour E, Petitta M (2026) Combining water isotope analyses and lumped parameter modelling to detect the functioning of a carbonate aquifer in a mountain range. Environ Earth Sci 85, 466. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12665-026-13181-z
Lines 29-30. Highlight the novelty of your research in the introduction.
Line 91. The specific objectives are very clear. But, what about the general goal of your research?
Lines 96-117. You need to provide more information about the climate with link on the hydrology.
Lines 96-117. You need to provide more information on surface water, presence of minor rivers and streams.
Lines 121-170. The availability in terms of time span of the different datasets should be clarified in this section.
Line 535. How to over-cross the limitations with future research? Please, discuss this point in the new version.
Figures and tables
Figure 2. Provide more detail in the caption.
Figure 2. increase the graphic resolution by rising the number of dpi.
Figure 3. Enlarge this figure, and improve the graphic resolution.
Figure 8. Figures on the axes are not readable. You can consider to split this image in two parts.
Figure 9. Make figures and labels larger on the two axes.