the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Biome.jl v0.1.0: a modular platform for mechanistic biome modeling and hypothesis testing
Abstract. Many global vegetation and biome models represent plant diversity through plant functional types (PFTs) and physiological processes. To map biomes, established models rely on fixed PFT definitions and established biome attribution schemes, which limit their adaptability to investigate new questions. Increased availability of high-resolution climate and species distribution datasets, as well as advanced computational power, now enable regional parameterization and conceptual extension of biome models, but this potential remains underutilized. Here, we present Biome.jl, a framework that unifies climate-based biome classification and mechanistic simulations of biological processes within a single, modular engine. The Biome.jl framework introduces a generalized dominance-based competition scheme in which the attribution of model pixels to a biome is determined by environmental suitability, potential productivity of PFTs, rules to translate PFTs to biomes, and biome dominance hierarchies. We evaluate Biome.jl against independent datasets, demonstrating that improved flexibility does not come at the cost of predictive power. We then illustrate the framework's customizability through two case studies: a regional parameterization of PFTs using multi-parametric grid search inference based on empirical data, and an extension of the base model with a novel stem succulent PFT and biome definition, achieved without modifying model components. By facilitating the comparison of biome concepts, offering flexible functional parameterization, and supporting multi-resolution implementation, Biome.jl redefines equilibrium biome modeling as a modular, hypothesis- and data-driven endeavor. It provides a foundation for testing climate-vegetation relationships and exploring uncertainty in biome projections under past, current, and future environmental conditions.
- Preprint
(3386 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 26 Nov 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4919', Anonymous Referee #1, 14 Nov 2026 reply
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4919', Anonymous Referee #2, 15 Nov 2026
reply
The manuscript presents a novel framework and R package for biome modeling using both different common biome maps and the process-based vegetation model BIOME4. THe package is written in Julia, and it is modular such that inclusion of additional PFTs into BIOME4 or application of alternative biome classification schemes are possible. The Julia version therefore provides a more accessible version of BIOME4 that can easily be used and applied in different biomes, or study regions; this is a clear strenght of the framework. In addition to a description of the package and BIOME4, the manuscript provides examples for potential applications of the package (high resolution tree line, inclusion of novel PFT for succulents). The code is open and availabe, together with documentations and examples. The manuscript is well written and structured. While this package is usefull for the modelling community I have several comments. Most comment do not require additional analyses but only some revisions of the text for clarification.
My main point is that the equilibrium model BIOME4 is used. The introduction highlights the importane of vegetation model for climate change reserch and consideration of transient dynamics, yet the implemented model does not simulate transient dynamics. The selection of the model is justified in the ms (eg high performance for parametrization of PFTs) and limitations are discussed. Nonetheless, I think this is a main caveat that limits the applicability of the developed package in the vegetation modeling/climate change community that typicalls requires transient simulations using daily climate forcing. In the discussion, it is mentioned that the results can be used as input for Earth system models, please provide more detail how the coupling with equilibrium biome states from BIOME4 can be done.
Given that the package includes several biome maps and that the flexibility w.r.t. biome classification is highlighed, I was expecting comparisons between biomes derived from BIOME4 and those biome maps. Such comparisons would illustrate the applicability of the package. But maybe this part of a subsequent study.
In my view the succulent PFT also shows a limitation of the approach, as agreement between the modeled distribution and observed distribution is low in some regions. For example, the succulent PFT is dominant in southern African savanna areas while it is not dominant in the South African succulent Karroo. But it is in the end up to the users of the package to ensure that biogeographic patterns of newly implemented PFTs are plausible.
In the conclusions, it is stated that the package introduces a new philosophy to biome modeling. The utilized biome models are not novel but how they are put together in the modeling framework. Please clarify what the new philosophy is.
Table A1: Description is missing for some parameters, and please also add units.
Fig A3 caption: please state earlier that this is about the succulent PFT, this info is only provided towards the end of the caption.
Â
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4919-RC2
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 396 | 280 | 61 | 737 | 72 | 74 |
- HTML: 396
- PDF: 280
- XML: 61
- Total: 737
- BibTeX: 72
- EndNote: 74
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
The manuscript introduces Biome.jl, a Julia-based framework that combines four climate-classification approaches with a mechanistic implementation based on BIOME4. Its principal innovation is separating physiological processes from user-defined plant functional types (PFTs), competition rules, and biome classification schemes. Overall, the manuscript is well written and presents a useful technical framework. I have a few minor comments on its methodological clarity and presentation:
- Interpretation of the new competition scheme. If PFTs outside their physiological limits are already excluded, how does the environmental suitability function further influence competition?Â
-  The independent validation of newly introduced PFTs remains limited. the succulent distribution dataset appears to be used for both parameterization and evaluation, while the predictive performance is relatively modest. This limitation should be discussed.
- Strengthen integration with DGVMs and Earth system models. I feel this could be strengthened by providing clearer guidance on how Biome.jl outputs, particularly PFT distributions and associated parameters, could be transferred to dynamic vegetation models. This would help bridge equilibrium biome modeling and dynamic vegetation simulations, and possibly earth system models.
Â