the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Thermal conditions on the coast of Labrador during the late 19th/early 20th century
Abstract. The long-term Moravian missionary meteorological observations, conducted from the late 18th century until the 2nd World War, provide a unique perspective on climate conditions along the Labrador coast. The present paper focuses on the analysis of air temperature in the late 19th and early 20th centuries based on sub-daily observations (three to five times a day) available for six stations: Rama (1882–1890), Hebron (1882–1918), Okak (1883–1889), Nain (1882–1913, 1926–1939), Zoar (1882–1894), and Hopedale (Hoffenthal) (1882–1898). The meteorological observations were carried out by the missionaries on behalf of the Deutsche Seewarte and are preserved in the archives of Deutscher Wetterdienst (Germany).
Quality-controlled and corrected mean daily air temperature were used to calculate standard climatic characteristics, including monthly, seasonal, and annual means; climate continentality indices; day-to-day temperature variability; thermal seasons; and other characteristics. In addition to extending the climate analysis, a set of additional useful climatic indices was calculated, including Growing Degree Days (GDD), Air Thawing Index (ATI), Positive Degree Days (PDD), and Air Freezing Index (AFI). Historical temperature data from the coast of Labrador were compared with contemporary thermal conditions from 1990 to 2020. At Nain, the mean annual air temperature during 1882–1892 was 2.3 °C lower than during 1990–2020. The separate Nain record for the Early Twentieth Century Warming (1926–1939) remained 0.8 °C lower than the modern mean. At Hopedale, the mean annual temperature was −3.2 °C during 1882–1898 and −1.5 °C during 1990–2020, giving a historical–modern difference of −1.7 °C. At Nain, warmer temperature classes occurred more frequently during the modern period, particularly in autumn and summer, whereas the differences at Hopedale were most apparent in summer. The historical records also indicate a slightly greater annual temperature range and stronger climate continentality than in the modern period, with the largest temperature changes occurring during the cold season.
- Preprint
(2702 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
- RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4842', Anonymous Referee #1, 02 Oct 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4842', Anonymous Referee #2, 07 Nov 2026
General comments :
This manuscript is presenting historical meteorological observations from the Coast of Labrador spanning from approx. 1882 to 1920. The meteorological observations were carried out by the Moravian Missionaries, and the archives were preserved by the Deutscher Wetterdienst (Germany). In addition to the mean daily air temperature, a set of climate indices was calculated based on the temperature data. Historical data are compared with modern data when available.
Data presented here are valuable and of great interest to study past climatic conditions and variability. However, this paper has major issues. There is a lack of general understanding of the regional climatic context and of the previous work that have been done. A lot of analysis are done, but the fundamental objective of this paper is not clear.
Specific comments :
The introduction is presenting an interesting overview of early-instrumental meteorological data in Labrador. However, the objective of this paper is not clear. Why are you specifically presenting this time period? As you did not introduce why and on which time period you are working, it makes it hard to understand why you start your overview in 1882 with Okak and Rama data (line 67), and move back to 1771 later on (line 101).
Area, data and methods: Standardisation and correction methods are well described. About the historical stations, do you know if the stations were moved through time ? Do you know if modern weather stations in Nain and Hopedale are close to the historical stations ?
Results : Data are mostly analysed based on 1882-90 period. Can you explain why this period was selected. Most set of data are longer, and for some analysis you choose to present the whole dataset.
You are comparing short time span historical data with 30 years normal series. Each station length and year span should be clearly mentioned while analysing the results. Moreover, there is little to no impression of the 1990-2020 datasets from Nain and Hopedale. Are they complete ?
Discussion : First paragraph of the discussion is interesting, but should appear earlier in the regional setting. Otherwise, discussion is weak and do not offer an interpretation of the data in a regional context. Many times, it is mentioned that correlation analysis could have been performed but it was not. It only refers to a couple papers that did it.
Detailed comments :
line 40 : Coast of Labrador is larger than the Nunatsiavut Coast. Moravian missions were all in now the autonomous territory of Inuit of Labrador.
Line 52 : present time? At best it stoped in 1926
Line 67 : northern coast line of Labrador ? Why do you start your overview in 1882 in Okak and Rama. Is it the set of data you will be presenting in this paper ?
Lines 68-70 : Please double-check this information. Low did not run permanent weather station in Labrador, he was mobile on the territory, travelling from Hudson Bay to the Labrador Coast. Western parts of Labrador? Which researchers? Which reconstruct data? Add a reference.
Line 71 : It is not clear what data were recorded 3 times a day, Low or the Moravian? Add reference.
Line 98 : Use of “true climate variability” should be reconsidered. Many bias could occur with early-instrumental data, instruments, readings, etc.
Line 98 : “The literature” is vague, can you provide references
Line 99 : what coastal chain ?
Lines 109-111 : You have not introduced the data this paper are presenting. This sentence makes no sense at this point.
Line 116 : latin name should be in italic
Line 101 : why now you go back to 1771 ?
Line 129 : What do you mean by ice storm ? There is no ice storm mentioned in this paper
Line 132 : Tanner ?
Lines 138-140 : this is not clear why you are focusing on the 1880-1920 period.
Line : When do the pre-industrial era starts ?
Line 166 : American Arctic refers to USA ? Vizi (2008) is not the first to study climate there.
Line 194 : Add Kaspar et al., 2015; Tinz et al., 2015 to acknowledge the work of the DWD.
Nain mean monthly temperature was already published in Ouellet-Bernier et al., 2021
Line 218 : The data of the Northern project are spanning from 1768 to 1884.
Lines 225 to 240 : How similar or dissimilar are the correction applied from Nain and Hopedale data ?
Line 246 : Can you validate that Demarée et al., 2020 have been doing this method ?
Lines 257-262 : Can you explain why you choose this method with particular thresholds ?
Line 281: References, can you explain more how Labrador Current or the Atlantic Ocean influence the thermal regime.
Lines 284-286 : Continentality. It is highly influence by maritime conditions, higher thermal amplitude might be a better concept to use. Ewert’s index is usually not used in this area.
Lines 291-292: Okak data are compared with Nain modern data. You mentioned it was only compared for regional context.
Line 291 : Historical cooling or modern warming ?
Lines 294-296 : This is important ! You compared short time span historical data with 30 years normal series. Each station length and year span should be clearly mentioned, while analysing the results.
Table 4 : Is it the difference with the modern Nain data or historical ? All data are presenting the mean from 1882 to 1892 or it is the entire time period as presented in figure 3. For example, data from Rama are only available from 1882 to 1890.
Line 322 : I recommend to be careful with this statement. A change of one standard deviation in mean monthly temperature is still a large change. Historical data cover only 10 years while modern data 30 years, more variability is expected.
Line 330 : it is decreasing in October.
Figures 4-9 : y axis identification
Line 347 : it is decreasing in October. Graph must be analysed in annual cycle. Not just looking at the plot.
Lines 380-382 : You already mentioned this interpretation at lines 320-322.
Figure 10 could be explain more, or use for interpretation.
Line 414 : Can you explain skewness and kurtosis. Which Nain historical period are you analysing ?
Figures 11-12 are interesting you clearly see the climate regime moving towards warmer values.
Lines 448-482 : Can you explain how the frequencies were calculated and compared with modern data, as the historical data cover 10 yr and modern 30 yr.
Line 488 : It is not a contrast. It indicated colder summers in the past too.
Figure 16 : Titles on the figure are incorrect. Does it show the difference between modern and historical DDTV or only the modern DDTV ?
Line 532 : Is the Labrador Arctic or Subarctic ?
Figure 17a : Nain present should be beside Nain (historical) or both Present values should be together.
Discussion :
Lines 574-575 : “The historical results from Rama, Hebron, Okak and Zoar describe spatial differences
575 and were not used to assess change over time.” It is repetitive throughout the discussion. (lines 599-601, 652-655)
Lines 576-577 : It is similar because it is the same dataset
Line 584 : your data cover 10 years how can it suggests a multi-century warming ?
Lines 592-595 : Can you explain more. Do you have reference to support this hypothesis ?
Lines 598-599 : Singh et al. 2025 found a similar pattern where ? Which period ?
Lines 615-622 : It is not clear how AMO fluctuations would explain the regional differences
between Nain and Hopedale. You could easily do correlation tests with AMO or other atmospheric circulation patterns. What AMO stands for ?
Line 627-628 : Same comment but for NAO.
Lines 631-633 : Both historical and modern periods are different, hard to compare with your data.
Lines 642-643 : Ouellet-Bernier et al. (2021) showed colder and warmer years in historical data, reflecting a natural year to year variability.
Lines 663-664 : It would have been of great interest as you are presenting mean daily temperature on a 10 yr period.
Line 667 : Canadian Arctic
Line 672 : was is “real” temperature ?
Lines 670-677 : I don’t understand the point of this comparison. And why to end the discussion with this.
Conclusion :
Lines 710-711: I am not convinced about the increase of continentality and the use of this index.
Lines 712-713 (last statement) : Is it your finding if it was not tested in this study ?
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4842-RC2
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 278 | 123 | 52 | 453 | 57 | 54 |
- HTML: 278
- PDF: 123
- XML: 52
- Total: 453
- BibTeX: 57
- EndNote: 54
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
General comments:
Good introduction to previous works on understanding climate (temperature) variability on the Labrador Coast in the subarctic NA. Though the temperature data of 19th and 20th Century of the region has been collected and analysed before, this study attempts to generate diverse systematic temperature statistics to understand climate in the past, compared to modern period.
However, in its present state the article needs significant revisions and not suitable for publication. The analyses and visualizations made to support the assessments are ambiguous in general, and incoherent at places. Methodology used in the article is not well presented and lacks explanation on why/how these are used. Discussion and Conclusion sections lack focus and seamless quality expected in these sections.
Tables and Figures are mislabelled, and some are difficult to read, text doesn’t fully explain what they are and what a reader is expected to see and understand from them.
One obvious weakness is lack of homogenisation; several previous studies have used statistical analysis to find break points in the data records and corrected to adjust for site relocations and changes in instruments/observing techniques. Any historical study looking at the long-term climate change cannot fully asserted the findings without removing biases in the historical data.
Made no use of daily-data where more interesting features may lay.
Specific comments:
Fig 2 – x-axis seems busy, place ticks by multiples of 5yr or more.
[L230] Derivation of other MDAT formulae and values not clear, give more details
[L235] Its not entirely clear which corrections are applied to which stations, and for which months. Both Tables 2 and 3, follow same pattern. Its hard to see which months, or stations require larger adjustments. To make it clearer, I suggest making a plot which shows unadjusted monthly/daily values vs adjusted.
Fig3. – In panel (a) if Nain historical observations are being compared with Nain Modern data then why other stations’ data is shown, it distracts from making comparisons between historical vs modern Nain observations. Consider deleting other stations’ from the plot.
Table 4 – All stations except Nain have observations starting 1882/83, however, the difference is estimated between other stations and Nain which starts in 1926. I don’t understand what is learned from this exercise?
Figure 4 – Temperature indices (GDD, ATI, PDD and AFI) are calculated for Rama (1882–1890), but, the title for subplots suggest that historical and modern are being compared, which is not the case. There is another issue here: how similar are climatic conditions at Rama and Nain? Your own introduction explains that within short distances diverse micro-climates form, modulating weather observations taken at even at close sites. Requires co-variability assessment. Direct comparison without a valid qualifier is untenable.
Figure 5,6,8 – Ditto as in Figure 4
Figure 9 – Comparing historical and modern is valid for Hopedale but why AVG H is dot rather than line in panel (a) unlike other plots?
Figure 13,14 – Does panels show seasons or something else. Figure captions have been poor, and sometimes wrong. Please rewrite all captions where unclear.
Figure 16 – Cannot understand why LPF is applied to the data, even text doesn’t mention it.
[L534] Would be helpful to see what the criteria is
[L542] There is no Figure 21 in the MS.
And many more.
Discussion and Conclusion sections need major overhaul as the paragraphs seem unconnected and do not narrate unified understanding of the findings.
Overall suggestion is to analyse how other stations vary compared to Nain and Hopedale when they contain contemporary data. This comparison will help understand trends in other stations historical vs modern periods, without relying on unquantified similarity. Otherwise, perform and make assessments on stations which have both historical and modern data (e.g. Nain and Hopedale), withdraw the rest from the analysis.