the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Evaluation of Partitioning Methods to Identify Timescale-Dependent Drivers of Light Use Efficiency in a Wet Tropical Forest
Abstract. Tropical forests play a major role in the global terrestrial carbon cycle; however, substantial uncertainties remain regarding their capacity to continue acting as a carbon sink under changing climate conditions. This uncertainty is driven largely by the limited number of carbon flux observations in tropical regions. Using eddy covariance (EC) measurements over an 11-month period at La Selva, Costa Rica, we quantified net ecosystem exchange (NEE) and evaluated partitioning methods to estimate gross primary production (GPP) and ecosystem respiration. Daytime partitioning using morning flux data introduced substantial variability in respiration estimates due to rapidly changing micrometeorological conditions. In contrast, daytime afternoon, nighttime, and sundown partitioning methods produced strong agreement and physiologically realistic results. We therefore use the afternoon daytime partitioning method for subsequent light use efficiency (LUE) analysis. The La Selva rainforest functioned as a strong temporally stable carbon sink with no detectable seasonal trend, averaging 2.5 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1, corresponding to an annual carbon uptake of 947 g C m-2 yr-1. GPP averaged 11.8 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1. Random forest modeling revealed timescale-dependent environmental controls on LUE, with photosynthetically active radiation dominating short-term variability, while temperature and atmospheric moisture increasingly constrained productivity at weekly timescales. VPD and temperature exerted a strong negative effect on half-hourly LUE, indicating vulnerability to increasing atmospheric dryness. Our findings demonstrate that partitioning method choice and temporal scale strongly shape inferred GPP magnitude and drivers in this wet tropical forest, with important implications for interpreting carbon flux estimates from EC measurements.
Status: final response (author comments only)
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4828', Anonymous Referee #1, 30 Sep 2026
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Julia Bigwood, 10 Nov 2026
We sincerely thank the reviewer for their thoughtful and detailed review of our manuscript. We appreciate their recognition of the value of this dataset. We agree that clearly documenting the processing of EC measurements and the implementation of NEE partitioning methods is essential, particularly given the importance of these methodological choices for subsequent estimates of GPP and their environmental drivers. In response to these comments, we have substantially revised the Methods section to provide a more detailed description of the data processing, quality control, u* evaluation, and profile-based storage correction. We have also expanded the descriptions of the NEE partitioning methods, including their underlying assumptions, implementation, and differences from more commonly used approaches. Additionally, we have carefully reviewed the manuscript references to ensure that methodological descriptions and interpretations are supported by appropriate literature. We have also revisited the comparisons and conclusions drawn from the different partitioning approaches, refining our interpretation to better distinguish between differences in fitted light-response parameters and differences in resulting GPP estimates. Finally, we have clarified the limitations of our observational record and the extent to which our analyses support conclusions about environmental controls on LUE. We believe these revisions have substantially improved the methodological documentation, clarity, and interpretation of the manuscript. We have addressed each of the reviewer’s comments individually below and thank them again for their suggestions, which have helped strengthen the study.
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Julia Bigwood, 10 Nov 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4828', Anonymous Referee #1, 30 Sep 2026
After more than three decades of global EC measurements, there is still a large data gap in
the tropics. As tropical forests contribute largely to carbon and water fluxes, this data gap is
a large source of uncertainty in estimating global carbon and water dynamics. This paper
adds to closing this gap with EC data from a wet tropical forest stie in Costa Rica, even
though the data coverage is only +- one year. I think the dataset is very valuable, however the
data processing is not very thoroughly explained in the paper, e.g. info about u* filtering, data
left after QC, shape and value of storage correction, …. In addition it seems like several
references are not on the right place and/or are not the main reference for the method or
results mentioned in the text. This might give the indication that the methods and claims are
not well supported. The partitioning methods explained in the text are missing details, which
leaves the reader in confusion and limits the understanding of the results and the re-usability
of the methods. Some large conclusions about partitioning methods are drawn and in my
opinion this conclusions are not yet well supported by the analyses carried out in the study.
While the set-up and ideas behind the study are very interesting, such as comparing different
partitioning techniques, looking into drivers on different timescales, … the study itself still
raises several questions and needs some more work before publishing.
Overall I would advice to check all references, to review the methods sections to more accurately describe the analyses on
the NEE as this is the strong basis for all following analyses, to more thoroughly describe
the partitioning methods used and more clearly indicate (dis)similarities with more
common methods and lastly to strengthen the comparison between partitioning methods to more fully underpin the decision to use the afternoon method. More detailed comments can be found in the attachmentCitation: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2026-4828-RC2 -
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Julia Bigwood, 10 Nov 2026
We sincerely thank the reviewer for their thoughtful and detailed review of our manuscript. We appreciate their recognition of the value of this dataset. We agree that clearly documenting the processing of EC measurements and the implementation of NEE partitioning methods is essential, particularly given the importance of these methodological choices for subsequent estimates of GPP and their environmental drivers. In response to these comments, we have substantially revised the Methods section to provide a more detailed description of the data processing, quality control, u* evaluation, and profile-based storage correction. We have also expanded the descriptions of the NEE partitioning methods, including their underlying assumptions, implementation, and differences from more commonly used approaches. Additionally, we have carefully reviewed the manuscript references to ensure that methodological descriptions and interpretations are supported by appropriate literature. We have also revisited the comparisons and conclusions drawn from the different partitioning approaches, refining our interpretation to better distinguish between differences in fitted light-response parameters and differences in resulting GPP estimates. Finally, we have clarified the limitations of our observational record and the extent to which our analyses support conclusions about environmental controls on LUE. We believe these revisions have substantially improved the methodological documentation, clarity, and interpretation of the manuscript. We have addressed each of the reviewer’s comments individually below and thank them again for their suggestions, which have helped strengthen the study.
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Julia Bigwood, 10 Nov 2026
-
RC3: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-4828', Anonymous Referee #2, 19 Oct 2026
I apologize with the authors for taking so long to review the ms. My comments are on the pdf attached.
-
AC2: 'Reply on RC3', Julia Bigwood, 10 Nov 2026
We thank the reviewer for taking the time to give thoughtful and constructive feedback on this manuscript. We also appreciate the reviewer’s comments regarding the structure of the manuscript, the interaction between gap-filling and NEE partitioning, and the interpretation of environmental controls on LUE. We have revised the manuscript to improve the organization. We have also clarified our gap-filling rationale and addressed the potential influence of PAR normalization on the relationships between LUE, temperature, and vapor pressure deficit through an additional sensitivity analysis. Finally, we have refined the abstract and discussion to ensure that our conclusions accurately reflect the findings and limitations of this observational dataset.
-
AC2: 'Reply on RC3', Julia Bigwood, 10 Nov 2026
Viewed
Since the preprint corresponding to this journal article was posted outside of Copernicus Publications, the preprint-related metrics are limited to HTML views.
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 351 | 0 | 6 | 357 | 0 | 0 |
- HTML: 351
- PDF: 0
- XML: 6
- Total: 357
- BibTeX: 0
- EndNote: 0
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Since the preprint corresponding to this journal article was posted outside of Copernicus Publications, the preprint-related metrics are limited to HTML views.
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
After more than three decades of global EC measurements, there is still a large data gap in
the tropics. As tropical forests contribute largely to carbon and water fluxes, this data gap is
a large source of uncertainty in estimating global carbon and water dynamics. This paper
adds to closing this gap with EC data from a wet tropical forest stie in Costa Rica, even
though the data coverage is only +- one year. I think the dataset is very valuable, however the
data processing is not very thoroughly explained in the paper, e.g. info about u* filtering, data
left after QC, shape and value of storage correction, …. In addition it seems like several
references are not on the right place and/or are not the main reference for the method or
results mentioned in the text. This might give the indication that the methods and claims are
not well supported. The partitioning methods explained in the text are missing details, which
leaves the reader in confusion and limits the understanding of the results and the re-usability
of the methods. Some large conclusions about partitioning methods are drawn and in my
opinion this conclusions are not yet well supported by the analyses carried out in the study.
While the set-up and ideas behind the study are very interesting, such as comparing different
partitioning techniques, looking into drivers on different timescales, … the study itself still
raises several questions and needs some more work before publishing.
Overall I would advice to check all references, to review the methods sections to more accurately describe the analyses on
the NEE as this is the strong basis for all following analyses, to more thoroughly describe
the partitioning methods used and more clearly indicate (dis)similarities with more
common methods and lastly to strengthen the comparison between partitioning methods to more fully underpin the decision to use the afternoon method. More detailed comments can be found in the attachment