Episodic Neoproterozoic Magmatism in the Northeastern Yangtze Craton: Implications for the Breakup of the Rodinia Supercontinent
Abstract. The composition and evolution of Precambrian basement are pivotal for understanding global continental crustal growth and supercontinent cycles, representing a key frontier in geological research. Although ancient basement exposures have been documented along the periphery of the Yangtze Craton, its northern margin exhibits limited and sporadic Precambrian outcrops, resulting in poorly constrained crustal evolution history for this critical period. This study identifies a series of magmatic rocks with mid-Neoproterozoic ages along the northeastern margin of the Yangtze Craton, which provides new constraints on the tectonic evolution of the Yangtze Craton in Neoproterozoic. This discovery provides critical constraints on the crystalline basement attributes and tectonic evolution during this stage, while offering vital evidence for investigating its linkage with the Rodinia supercontinent. Geochronological results reveal two magmatic episodes: 781–776 Ma granitic gneisses (Feidong Complex) and 753–730 Ma bimodal volcanic rocks (spilite-keratophyre association; Zhangbaling Group). Contrasting geochemical signatures and isotopic compositions indicate complex melting conditions and tectonic stages: the Feidong granitic gneisses exhibit highly enriched zircon Lu-Hf isotopes (εHf(t) = −16.9 to −10.9) and ancient crustal model ages, attesting to remelting of ancient continental material, elevated Sr/Y, (La/Yb)ₙ ratios coupled with significantly fractionated REE patterns showing significant HREE depletion imply high-pressure melting conditions. During this phase, decompression melting of the lithospheric mantle occurred, inducing lower crustal melting via underplating. In contrast, the Zhangbaling bimodal volcanics display diagnostic A-type granite geochemical affinities, depleted zircon Lu-Hf isotopes (εHf(t) = −3.9 to +4.3), and shallower melting depths. This upward shift in magmatic source records the transition of the northeastern Yangtze margin from initial extension to a mature rift system, directly recording the Rodinia supercontinent breakup process.
Because the authors do NOT make a convincing case for the rift setting, I cannot recommend this manuscript for publication. Specific comments below:
265 No evidence is given for a "link" to supercontinent assembly or breakup
267-270 Splites are altered volcanics, and hence usually cannot be used as geochemical indicator of tectonic setting using geochemical variables.
285-290 and Fig 9, Caution needs to be used here since elements like Ba, K, Rb, Sr and LREE are often remobilized during alteration. Should not use these elements to identify tectonic settings.
295-300 this discussion is correct and shows that the elements listed above should not be used to identify ancient tectonic settings.
320-335 It is not clear how models 1) and 3) differ from each other.
339-343 None of these features are "diagnostic" of incompatibility in continental rift settings.
365 Should this be Figure 10? If so, these diagrams are not useful for the granitic gneisses (blue dots) since they plot near tectonic setting boundaries.
384-386 A type granites also form at convergent plate margins (A2 types). Authors should distinguish the A types as either A1, A2 or both types.